I have dialogued with many folks over the years about the Colossians texts and the texts in 2 Cor 3 as well. I studied these even before becoming adventist and still came to the same conclusion. The texts in Colossians initially had me thinking as you do but a closer look convinced me that it could not be speaking specifically of the 7th day Sabbath being nailed to the cross.
I appreciate your honesty that you see the plain reading of the Colossians text as not supportive of the SDA position.
The wording that settles it is this contextual verse:
14
Blotting out the handwriting of ordinances that was against us, which was contrary to us, and took it out of the way, nailing it to his cross;
The laws that were hand writings were the ceremonial laws of Moses not the 10 commandments. The ceremonial laws were said to be against the people in the book of Duetoronmy.
2 Corinthians 3 calls what was written and engraved on stones as the ministry of death. Breaking one of the 10 commandments was not without punishment under the old covenant. How could that not be against them?
Also here in this verse
16
Let no man therefore judge you in meat, or in drink, or in respect of an holyday, or of the new moon, or of the sabbath days:
The bolded parts of this text shows that Paul was speaking of the ceremonial sabbath/s when he was speaking of meat/drink offerings in direct conjunction with speaking of the sabbath days.
The Greek word for Sabbath in that text is
[SIZE=-0][SIZE=-0] 4521 sabbaton {sab'-bat-on}. There is no separate word for days. Even if there was were not the weekly Sabbaths days?
[/SIZE][/SIZE]
Because the ceremonial sabbaths were fulfilled at the cross. They were a shadow of things to come and pointed to Christ. The 7th day Sabbath does not point to Christ as the lamb of God but as a holy day of rest set aside to commune with our savior to rest physically and spiritually.
How do you know? If the NT does not say gobs and gobs about how we are not to keep the feasts how do you know you are not breaking God's commands?
[SIZE=-0][SIZE=-0]
[/SIZE][/SIZE]
The law could never save, that was not it's job. The legalistic Jews were to be instructed to turn their eyes on Christ. The law had it's glory and it's place but Christ glory was to take it's place. Paul was just using the metaphor of the glory on Moses face to illustrate that point. He never said we were to throw the law away. Grace demands the law be intact and functioning.
I disagree. Paul says to cast off the bondswoman covenant. Grace doesn't demand that the 10 commandments be intact and functioning any more than it does keeping the feasts. You don't need law to need grace. The sin nature that came upon all men as a result of Adam's sin made grace necessary.
[SIZE=-0][SIZE=-0]
[/SIZE][/SIZE]
Yes and the spirit is actually a lot more stringent in the area of obedience yet you seem to say we don't have to worry about obedience which is so contrary to everything the Bible tells us.
Yes, we should not worry about anything! If we are worrying about obedience then we are focused on ourselves. God does not want us to worry. Be anxious for nothing!
Yes, following the Holy Spirit will lead us to a higher standard. Love, joy, peace, patience, etc.
[SIZE=-0][SIZE=-0]
[/SIZE][/SIZE]
The Holy Spirit will never lead you to break His Holy Laws. This is a lie and an illusion as to what is truth. The Holy Spirit is only promised to those who obey God's commandments. Sabbath observance is as the Bible says a day of delight the holy of the Lord. No amount of Sabbath observance can save us but if we are in Christ we wouldn't think about breaking it. How can we crucify our Savior afresh like that?
Yes, you have no problem in not keeping the feasts. Did God not give those laws? Are those laws less holy?
The Holy Spirit is given to those to who come to Christ in faith. He then changes us. I think you are looking at it from the other way around - we change then receive the Holy Spirit. We come just as we are to Christ and He changes us.
What is the command we are to follow to receive the Holy Spirit?
Ephesians 1 "13In Him, you also,
after listening to the message of truth, the gospel of your salvation--
having also believed, you were sealed in Him with the Holy Spirit of promise, 14who is given as a pledge of our inheritance, with a view to the redemption of God's own possession, to the praise of His glory."
Besides the Bible says we CAN'T crucify the Lord afresh. If breaking any part of the 10 commandments is crucifying the Lord afresh then we are all lost.
The implications are solid as a rock. You cannot establish something and not observe it.
The context does not speak to that.