• Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.

Poll - Once Saved Always Saved

Do you believe in the doctrine of Once Saved, Always Saved?

  • No, I don't believe in the doctrine of Once Saved Always Saved.

  • Yes, I do believe in the doctrine of Once Saved Always Saved.


Results are only viewable after voting.
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ben johnson

Legend
Site Supporter
Feb 9, 2002
16,916
404
Oklahoma
Visit site
✟99,049.00
Faith
Christian
ABIC said:
Because ben cannot believe a christian can live in sin for a season ... and still be saved....
That's true, I cannot. Neither can Paul (Rom6), Jesus (Matt7), Peter (2:1:2-10), and all the others...
God is why anyone is saved... his choice ... john 1:13
Sorry, my friend --- verse 13 says "the BEGOTTENNESS is not of men but of God".

...verse 12 says "BECOMING begotten is by believing and receiving Jesus."
God wants us to abide but he has not determine this ... it is a choice 2 peter 1:4
And if we do NOT abide, we are cast away as dried branches and burned... Jn15
 
Upvote 0

Ben johnson

Legend
Site Supporter
Feb 9, 2002
16,916
404
Oklahoma
Visit site
✟99,049.00
Faith
Christian
Ormly said:
Does the Blood of the Lamb shed for your sins mean that Christ is in you?
Receiving His graceful sacrifice, His physical presence into your heart, does. And nothing less is "salvation".

We abide IN Christ, and He abides in us; or we abide in sin. Those are our only choices...
Does the Blood have to be in you or simply upon you that one is redeemed; forgiven of his sins and the stain of Adam's trangression removed from him?
Look at how "walking" connects to "cleansing by His blood":

"If we say that we have fellowship with Him but walk in the darkness, we lie and do not practice the truth; but if we walk in the Light as He Himself is in the Light, we have fellowship with one another, and the blood of Jesus His Son cleanses us from all sin.

If we walk in the light, then His blood cleanses us.
 
Upvote 0

Ben johnson

Legend
Site Supporter
Feb 9, 2002
16,916
404
Oklahoma
Visit site
✟99,049.00
Faith
Christian
ForgivenWretch said:
Once again you have done nothing more than take God's word and try and refute it with God's word, only to benefit your self. The word of God does not contradict itself, only men such as yourself do that.
Please quote from my post, and support your words, with Scripture. Cite verses that endorse what you say, and/or cite verses that disprove what I said.

This is the dynamic of "Theological debate"; nothing is served by just saying "You're wrong".

Show me how I'm wrong.

:)
 
Upvote 0

Ben johnson

Legend
Site Supporter
Feb 9, 2002
16,916
404
Oklahoma
Visit site
✟99,049.00
Faith
Christian
RickOtto said:
Ben, refresh me.
(Ben reaches for a cold, refeshing bucket of ice-water; grins mischieviously...)
Are you once saved, always maintaining,
or once offered but not yet earned,...
is there a similar boiled down description of your soteriological ontology?
It all cuts to the meaning of "salvation".

We hear the message; the message carries the power to convict us. Jesus said, "I will draw ALL MEN to Myself". Helkuo-draw/drag.

Each man who believes, receives Christ; and walks in Him. Faith must be guarded; it can be deceived to unbelief, by deceivers (Col2:6-8, 1Jn2:26-28, 2Pet3:17); and it can be deceived by sin (James1:14-16, Heb3:6-14).

I just cited exact passages, that cannot be refuted. If anyone thinks they can, please proceed.

:)
 
Upvote 0

Ben johnson

Legend
Site Supporter
Feb 9, 2002
16,916
404
Oklahoma
Visit site
✟99,049.00
Faith
Christian
Squint said:
As stated, ANY of us as believers can fall as victims of unrighteousness in this present life...
Hi, "Squint". I agree. Do you agree that there is no such thing as "unrighteously-saved"?
We cannot for example say...we are totally and completely RIGHTEOUS except by WORD'S imputations to us as believers. The fact remains that ALL of us are YET BOUND in mind and body with INDWELLING SIN.
Please read 1Jn3:5-10. Clearly, he who PRACTICES sin not only does not know God, but is stated as "of the devil". What is your opinion of this passage?
Paul called that presence NO LONGER I. We "disassociate" ourselves as being THE SAME AS that which INDWELLS US" and we SEPARATE ourselves FROM that working, even though that WORKING remains WITH US...and can PREVAIL over us IF we do not understand that IT is NOT US. We simply fall back into 'blurring the lines."

Paul said that "whenever" he wanted to DO GOOD, that EVIL was present with him. EVIL then is a CONSTANT COMPANION...but it is NOT US as believers. THIS is what we are supposed to SEE.
Please re-read Romans6, 7, and 8; you're missing the "big picture". In ch6, he states that "we cannot dwell in sin; we are EITHER slaves to sin (and dead to Christ), OR dead to sin and slaves to righteousness and God. Plainly stated is "present yourselves as alive to Christ Jesus".

In ch7, Paul speaks of the WAR between the "new born-again spiritual nature", and the "old dead-but-not-GONE nature". He cries in despair, "Who will SAVE me from this war in my members?!?!"

Chapter 8 is the solution to the problem. He speaks of "walking in the flesh --- if we DO, we must die"; and he speaks of "walking in the Spirit --- by the Spirit putting to death the deeds of the flesh --- that we LIVE."

So --- we live in war, no LONGER. For Christ did what the flesh was too weak TO do. Rom8 is very clear...
That too is my point. What many try to present, is that there is ETERNAL LOSS of that former believer but that is NOT THERE anywhere presented in scripture for ANY believer. That is an imposition that is not available in scripture.
He who dies unbelieving and unrepentant, dies in his sin; and will never enter the gates of Heaven.
Scripture does teach that there is POST DEATH salvation. All "total salvation" is POST DEATH. WE do not have our FULL SALVATION until we are REMOVED from the presence of INDWELLING SIN and EVIL PRESENT.
I'm sorry, while alive we dwell in repentance and forgiveness. He who dies WITHOUT repentance, dies without forgiveness --- in this life and in the next.

There is no "post-mortem-salvation". Heb9:27 says "it is appointed once for a man to die, and after this comes judgment" --- and Rom2:6-8 says our judgment is EITHER to immortality, OR to wrath and indignation.
Romans 11:26 teaches that ALL OF ISRAEL shall be SAVED...even the PAST TENSE "made" enemies of the Gospel.
The "all", is a "generality"; and does not deny "each individual, if he/she believes".
Since there is OBVIOUSLY evil present with us, we should be aware that we are NOT ALONE in the flesh.

Jesus, on nearly EVERY PAGE of the Gospels addressed OTHER ENTITIES in mankind. It is VERY LIKELY that those scriptures ARE IN FACT addressed to THOSE ENTITIES...
In 1Jn4, "Greater is He that is in you, than he that is in the world." Please read Lk10:17-19; we have authority over all evil entities.

...but don't forget verse 20, it's the KEY. There is no rejoicing that evil is subject to u s --- it's no big deal. The important thing is that our names are written in Heaven.
Jesus spoke to satan IN PETER. Does this make PETER SATAN? Of course NOT!
He was not speaking to anyone but Simon-Peter. By calling Peter, "satan", He was making a point at the consequence if Peter could succeed at saving Jesus.

Jesus had to be "lost", for mankind to be "found". There was no other way.
The devil and his messengers who ARE found to be WITHIN mankind will NOT be saved and they CAN take their victims back, particularly if those VICTIMS do not "know" the difference between themselves as God's children and what we are ALL bound with. They think it's JUST THEM...just as YOU may think.
There is no "great war between Good and evil, between God and the devil, between "yin" and "yang"; it's "God --- almighty omnipotent omniscient omnipresent perfect and perfect-love creator-of-the-Universe", and the devil is just a fallen angel. He's wiley, and has some smarts; but he's no big deal, with Him in us.

...besides, how smart could satan BE, to "throw away Heaven"???
Not every thought that crosses the minds of men is FROM THEM. The DEVIL imposes HIS THOUGHTS and WILL on MANKIND. God also IMPOSES His Thoughts and Will upon mankind. Mankind is simply NOT ALONE in their "thought processes" or in their "actions."
Yet man can choose.
Light takes into consideration, the fact that we are NOT ALONE...
There are four "forces" in a man's life:
1. God
2. devil
3. people
4. self

Each should be understood, place and application.
When did sin indwelling the flesh and the EVIL that is present with us STOP SINNING? It NEVER stops. WE are asked NOT to "yield" ourselves to THAT WORKING but this also does not make THAT WORKING us...Indwelling SIN and EVIL PRESENT can come back to be OUR MASTER, but that is not the same as US just as it was not with Paul.
Do you agree that 'we cannot WALK (abide) in sin"?
Belief is a "work" of faith. Faith "works" through LOVE. Those who LOVE are perfected therein.
Careful --- you are right, "saving-faith" is a WORK". Further, it's GOD'S work.

...but please read the context --- Jn6:26-27 --- it's God's work that WE WORK".

We are active in our salvation, not passive. Matt7:24-27
I do not believe any believer is PERFECTED in LOVE whilst simultaneously NOT seeing the difference between themselves and what ALL MANKIND are bound with...and then simultaneously CONDEMNING the slaves of sin to be burned alive forever in conscious torment. That is not love.
Mankind cannot dwell in sin; passages like 1Cor6:9-11, Gal5:19-21, Eph5:5-6, and especially 1Jn3:5-10 are very clear...
Judgment can and DOES still abide on that which we are ALL bound with.
John5:24 ""Truly, truly, I say to you, he who hears My word, and believes Him who sent Me, has eternal life, and does not come into judgment, but has passed out of death into life."
IF and WHEN you see this "difference" then you may understand. But if you DON'T you are just bypassing the obvious and laying the blame where it does NOT belong.
I understand, "Squint".
enjoy!

squint
I "enjoy" --- and HE is my joy and my song.

It is as the Psalmist said, "The Lord is my strength and my song, and has become my salvation." 118:14

:)
 
Upvote 0

A Brother In Christ

Senior Veteran
Mar 30, 2005
5,528
53
Royal city, washington
✟5,985.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
Once again you have to deal with

romans 4:5 But to him that worketh not but believeth on Him that justifieth the ungodly, his faith is counted for righteousness ..

scripture speak much louder than me arguing

That's true, I cannot. Neither can Paul (Rom6), Jesus (Matt7), Peter (2:1:2-10), and all the others...
Sorry, my friend --- verse 13 says "the BEGOTTENNESS is not of men but of God".

...verse 12 says "BECOMING begotten is by believing and receiving Jesus."
And if we do NOT abide, we are cast away as dried branches and burned... Jn15

1 cor 3:15 If any man's good work shall be burned, he shall suffer loss: but he himself shall be saved; yet so as by fire.

2 tim 2:13 Since we are unfaithful, Yet He abideth faithful: He cannot deny himself.

1 cor 12:21 and the eye cannot say unto the hand, I have no need of thee: nor again the head to the feet, I have no need of you.

eph 1:22 and hath put all things under his feet, and gave Him to be the head over all things to the church 23 which is His body, the fulness of Him that filleth all in all.



Once again... who work is savaltion?

answer... John 1:13.... God's work
 
Upvote 0

Rick Otto

The Dude Abides
Nov 19, 2002
34,112
7,406
On The Prairie
✟29,593.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Others
quote=Ben johnson;(Ben reaches for a cold, refeshing bucket of ice-water; grins mischieviously...)
^_^
It all cuts to the meaning of "salvation".

We hear the message; the message carries the power to convict us. Jesus said, "I will draw ALL MEN to Myself". Helkuo-draw/drag.

Each man who believes, receives Christ; and walks in Him. Faith must be guarded; it can be deceived to unbelief, by deceivers (Col2:6-8, 1Jn2:26-28, 2Pet3:17); and it can be deceived by sin (James1:14-16, Heb3:6-14).

I just cited exact passages, that cannot be refuted. If anyone thinks they can, please proceed.

I knew you couldn't boil it down if your front row seat in church depended on it!

No scripture can be refuted, so you can't trick me! I know better than to attend just any argument I'm being invited too!:D

But if your gonna sell that message you should at least give it a catchy acronym like OSAS. Even I prefer that to "Presevation of The Saints" !:cool:
 
Upvote 0

squint

Well-Known Member
Jul 23, 2007
16,182
903
Mountain Regions
✟20,405.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
Hi, "Squint". I agree. Do you agree that there is no such thing as "unrighteously-saved"?

Don't know what that catch phrase may mean to you.

I do know without doubt that ALL OF ISRAEL SHALL BE SAVED, even (past tense) EMEMIES of the GOSPEL from Romans 11:26... who have obviously perished in the flesh by now...;)

Please read 1Jn3:5-10. Clearly, he who PRACTICES sin not only does not know God, but is stated as "of the devil". What is your opinion of this passage?

That statement in particular is from 1 John 3:9 which implicates the DEVIL in ALL SINS...I do not believe that mankind can be both God's offspring as Paul taught in Acts 17:23-29 and devils as that would reflect on our Father.

I also know that ALL OF ISRAEL were taught to be God's children in Deut. 14:1 and Psalm 82:6 and of course not all of them were believers, NOR could they be because God place a spirit of stupor upon them to blind and deafen them...again...Romans 11.

There are then some that are meant to see in this present life but that does not preclude God from saving them ALL, as Paul taught that "mystery" in Romans 11.

Please re-read Romans6, 7, and 8; you're missing the "big picture". In ch6, he states that "we cannot dwell in sin;

Don't see that particular statement in Romans 6 Ben...We cannot say we "have no sin" as a present tense condition and be "in Truth." 1 John 1:8 Paul also had sin indwelling his flesh that he termed NO LONGER I twice in Romans 7...and Paul taught that "whenever" he desired to do good that EVIL was present with him. This does not make Paul the same as the sin that obviously still indwelt his flesh NOR does that make Paul "EVIL."

we are EITHER slaves to sin (and dead to Christ), OR dead to sin and slaves to righteousness and God. Plainly stated is "present yourselves as alive to Christ Jesus".

We are advised not to yield to sin...meaning that it is still their to yield to, particularly if EVIL is present with us whenever we desire to do good.

In ch7, Paul speaks of the WAR between the "new born-again spiritual nature", and the "old dead-but-not-GONE nature". He cries in despair, "Who will SAVE me from this war in my members?!?!"

Again and obviously Paul still had an opponent in his flesh...the sin indwelling his flesh that was NO LONGER I and the EVIL PRESENT with him. I don't recall us being promised sinless flesh in the scriptures. Sin is both an active tense "indwelling" in the flesh and an interior (via thought) action and an exterior (via works) action which same is of the devil.

Chapter 8 is the solution to the problem. He speaks of "walking in the flesh --- if we DO, we must die"; and he speaks of "walking in the Spirit --- by the Spirit putting to death the deeds of the flesh --- that we LIVE."

Death was a daily reckoning for Paul because of what was "with" him in his flesh. Paul admitted that in his flesh he still served the law of sin...which he also elaborated upon in regards to it's working by the Law empowering...and Paul could not avoid that IF he followed the law via his flesh or fleshly ritual(s.)

So --- we live in war, no LONGER.

Don't see that either Ben.

Ephesians 6:12
For we wrestle not against flesh and blood, but against principalities, against powers, against the rulers of the darkness of this world, against spiritual wickedness in high places.

2 Corinthians 10:4-5
(For the weapons of our warfare are not carnal, but mighty through God to the pulling down of strong holds;)
Casting down imaginations, and every high thing that exalteth itself against the knowledge of God, and bringing into captivity every thought to the obedience of Christ.

These workings do not stop. The Word is Living and Active in these regards in our behalf.

For Christ did what the flesh was too weak TO do. Rom8 is very clear...
He who dies unbelieving and unrepentant, dies in his sin; and will never enter the gates of Heaven.

I'm not denying that there is eternal punishment Ben. But we may very well differ on "who" is going to suffer that fate. In the light of the facts that Paul was "not alone" in his own flesh...having EVIL PRESENT, carrying a special messenger of Satan with him, having indwelling sin that was NO LONGER I, it is perfectly legitimate to see THE CAUSE of those things IN PAUL that were NOT Paul as the ones who would be suffering that fate, the DEVIL AND HIS MESSENGERS.

Jesus clearly showed that THESE ENTITIES were IN MANKIND and Jesus also spoke to THEM in MANKIND on nearly every page of the Gospels. So in the light of THOSE FACTS it is somewhat disingenuous to neglect a RENDERING of those parties IN our understandings in these matters, and not just jump on the backs of the SLAVES OF SIN, seeing as how the condition of being A SLAVE does without doubt DICTATE that there is also a MASTER OF SLAVES of sin.

I'm sorry, while alive we dwell in repentance and forgiveness.

Obviously then you acknowledge the battle. If you never had sin transpire in flesh or mind you'd have no need to repent or be forgiven for yielding.

We have an advocate with The Father. The Devil and his messengers do NOT.

He who dies WITHOUT repentance, dies without forgiveness --- in this life and in the next.

Sorry Ben. I don't believe that God's Love HALTS at the point of death.

Anyone who dies is RELEASED FROM SIN. (Romans 6:7) And of course Romans 11:26 does teach that past tense enemies of the Gospel as it pertains to Israel shall be saved because they are LOVED for the "fathers" sake, not because of what they did or didn't do. They were enemies, but they ARE loved by God anyway and He thusly SAVES them.

There is no "post-mortem-salvation". Heb9:27 says "it is appointed once for a man to die, and after this comes judgment"

There are many forms of judgment Ben. Judgment as it pertains to mankind is that ALL would honor The Son.

John 5:
22 For the Father judgeth no man, but hath committed all judgment unto the Son:
23 That all men should honour the Son

And who does NOT honour The Son? The devil and his messengers IN mankind who RESIST GOD. We are simply not alone in flesh or mind Ben. It's easy to just blame mankind...but the facts of these matters fully implicate the devil and his messengers IN mankind...ALL DAMNATION JUDGMENT can and does abide on those resistors IN mankind beyond any doubt.

--- and Rom2:6-8 says our judgment is EITHER to immortality, OR to wrath and indignation.

Were mankind the ONLY parties in this matter I'd have to agree, but Jesus clearly showed otherwise.

Satan spoke through Peter. Satan entered Judas. An entire LEGION occupied the body of a single man of the Gadarenes. Jesus NEVER CAME to condemn the captives, but to DIVIDE AND FREE THEM Ben. If your theological presentations are void of the most obvious, how can they be RIGHT?

I could give dozens of scriptures that EXONERATE mankind... you should know them without the numbers:

-If any man hear my words and believe NOT, I judge him Not

-I judge NO MAN

-The Father judges NO MAN

etc etc...

The "all", is a "generality"; and does not deny "each individual, if he/she believes".

There is a cause of unbelief Ben. That cause is the "god of this world" who blinds their minds, lest the light should shine upon THEM...(the cause of blindness)

Wherever The Word is sown SATAN comes to steal same from the heart.

It's not like this does NOT transpire IN believers either Ben. We are told to RESIST the devil. That means the DEVIL is upon us as well. It's not a resistance that we "see" with our eyes. It's the DEVIL who steals from the hearts.

In 1Jn4, "Greater is He that is in you, than he that is in the world." Please read Lk10:17-19; we have authority over all evil entities.

I don't think I need to beat the point to death...Paul taught that in the SAME LUMP there is BOTH a vessel of honor and a vessel of dishonor and wrath. When we look at Paul's disclosures unto HIMSELF in Romans 7, the extension is very logical to chapter 9, and into chapter 11 as well when we see the "spirit of stupor" which was PUT UPON Israel. That is what was NOT Israel. The children of the flesh...the CHILDREN OF THE DEVIL.

Just think about this for a moment Ben. IF Jesus addressed children of the devil in the Pharisees...He was, YES, speaking to THEM in the Pharisees just as He said.

...but don't forget verse 20, it's the KEY. There is no rejoicing that evil is subject to u s --- it's no big deal. The important thing is that our names are written in Heaven.
He was not speaking to anyone but Simon-Peter. By calling Peter, "satan", He was making a point at the consequence if Peter could succeed at saving Jesus.

I have no reason to believe that Peter was Satan Ben. All of Israel are God's children and to make them SATAN is brings a huge problem then to GOD having children of the devil as HIS children. No Ben...THEY are SEPARATE ENTITIES from mankind and they are found IN mankind beyond any reasonable doubt.

Those who cannot look to those parties in their positions are only doing so because of THEIR influences in blinding us to the OBVIOUS...but of course to take this "personally" is an offence to most. Nobody wants THAT MUCH Truth...;)
There is no "great war between Good and evil, between God and the devil, between "yin" and "yang"; it's "God --- almighty omnipotent omniscient omnipresent perfect and perfect-love creator-of-the-Universe", and the devil is just a fallen angel. He's wiley, and has some smarts; but he's no big deal, with Him in us.

I don't think so either Ben... but I certainly cannot deny THEIR workings here on earth NOR do I have to blame my fellow man for THEIR workings with their slaves...God does win this battle for ALL MEN even if they go blind to their graves.

...besides, how smart could satan BE, to "throw away Heaven"???

Satan was not EVER presented in scripture as EVER being "holy." Being perfect in "all his ways" only makes him a PERFECT DEVIL. Jesus said he was a liar, and a murderer FROM THE BEGINNING. John 8:44

Yet man can choose.

God placed a spirit of stupor on Israel so they COULDN'T CHOSE. That "working" was very effective.

So it's NOT like their "minds" were not TAMPERED with. God can also INTERPOSE into the minds of mankind. There is no thought of ours that He does not KNOW and YES, God does tamper also with the wills of men...

In the light of these two OTHER workings IN mankind, I can say without any doubt that men's will's ARE tampered and tamperable...and NOT just of them. We don't gain our reward by "making good decisions."
Each should be understood, place and application.
Do you agree that 'we cannot WALK (abide) in sin"?
Careful --- you are right, "saving-faith" is a WORK". Further, it's GOD'S work.

Every person serves God in this present life. The vessel of dishonor and wrath was RAISED IN PHARAOH that God would show His Superior Power OVER them. In that way PHARAOH served God too...by carrying that vessel to JUDGMENT...and we all carry these things IN US to our respective crosses, whether we "realize it" or NOT. It's just a fact for all men. Each man bears "his own burdens" before the Lord, and YES the words and deeds of the vessels of dishonor and wrath are judged, as are the good words and deeds. This transpires in ALL men.
Mankind cannot dwell in sin; passages like 1Cor6:9-11, Gal5:19-21, Eph5:5-6, and especially 1Jn3:5-10 are very clear...

None of those citings say that we have no sin Ben, or that we don't dwell in it.

Here again was Paul's reality. If this was his reality, then it is ours also:

Romans 7:17
Now then it is no more I that do it, but sin that dwelleth in me.

Romans 7:20
Now if I do that I would not, it is no more Ithat do it, but sin that dwelleth in me.


WE are not IT. IT dwells in our flesh. WE are not OF THE FLESH. We are OF THE SPIRIT.

IF we as "believers" SEPARATE ourselves from this working...we DO then have OUR freedom even in the MIDST of their IMPOSITIONS.

Those things IN US don't HAVE God's LOVE. Mankind DOES. And we would probably stop crawling all over each other in FALSE JUDGEMENTS and look to our real, but thankfully TEMPORARY enemies who WILL have their DAY OF WRATH if we only PERCEIVED them via WORD's Disclosures. His Word is LIGHT upon THEM. That's the ONLY way we know.

enjoy!

squint
 
Upvote 0

squint

Well-Known Member
Jul 23, 2007
16,182
903
Mountain Regions
✟20,405.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
Being regenerated causes a bittersweet identity crisis.

It shore do Rick...it shore do. Not every brainwave that crosses our nerve endings is ours, and that can be sometimes startling...but it's the truth.

I simply don't want to be A SLAVE. None of us do or should want to be such.

We overcome by FAITH which works THRU Love and THAT is a great reward, even in this present life. Particularly when we finally see that our fellow man is in fact GOD'S offspring. All of them. And we know what is OF THEM that AIN'T.

Matthew 10:34
Think not that I am come to send peace on earth: I came not to send peace, but a sword.

You'll come to know it's a pretty clean cut.


Remember the wisdom of Solomon and "the child."
 
Upvote 0

Rick Otto

The Dude Abides
Nov 19, 2002
34,112
7,406
On The Prairie
✟29,593.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Others
I was so upset about it & confused by it, I got diagnosed "schizophrenic". Did 8 months "on the ward".
I'd read in LOOK magazine that Dr. Leary said you could "see God on LSD" & I did so much LSD one day, I "woke up" in intermingling mists of white & golden light. I looked down at myself & instead of seeing my body, I saw effervescent light.
A whole lot more & interesting stuff happened, but what I came away from it with was I was put here for a purpose & I was intent on finding out what it was & fulfilling it.
I think the only reason I wasn't killed by it was because of the reason I did it.
 
Upvote 0

Ben johnson

Legend
Site Supporter
Feb 9, 2002
16,916
404
Oklahoma
Visit site
✟99,049.00
Faith
Christian
RickOtto said:
I knew you couldn't boil it down if your front row seat in church depended on it!
I don't like the front row; you can't doze off without everyone knowing it, can't wipe your nose, can't smile at the cute girl in the choir without the whole church talking about it...
No scripture can be refuted, so you can't trick me!
Ahhhh, you know that I was sayin' "Scriptural UNDERSTANDINGS can be refuted by clearer other Scriptures".
I know better than to attend just any argument I'm being invited too!
What good is a party without you?
But if you're gonna sell that message you should at least give it a catchy acronym like OSAS.
Most Calvinists object to "OSAS"...
Even I prefer that to "Preservation of The Saints" !
OK, "osas" it is...

;)
 
Upvote 0

A Brother In Christ

Senior Veteran
Mar 30, 2005
5,528
53
Royal city, washington
✟5,985.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
"A_Brother", there is no "ungodly believer". Salvation is Christ in us --- if He is IN us, then HIS righteousness is OURS; we are righteous, not ungodly.

If we are ungodly, then as Jesus said "we will be known by our fruits" --- and He is NOT in us, for He will not participate in ungodliness.

I've given you the Scripture; how do I convince you of this?

"Saved belief", abides in Him and not in sin. It's black and white; we are EITHER slaves to sin and ALIEN to Christ, or we are slaves to Him and righteousness and do not walk in sin. Rom6 is clear --- please tell me what you think of the whole chapter...

Once again you have to deal with

romans 4:5 But to him that worketh not but believeth on Him that justifieth the ungodly, his faith is counted for righteousness ..

scripture speak much louder than me arguing

That's true, I cannot. Neither can Paul (Rom6), Jesus (Matt7), Peter (2:1:2-10), and all the others...
Sorry, my friend --- verse 13 says "the BEGOTTENNESS is not of men but of God".

...verse 12 says "BECOMING begotten is by believing and receiving Jesus."
And if we do NOT abide, we are cast away as dried branches and burned... Jn15

1 cor 3:15 If any man's good work shall be burned, he shall suffer loss: but he himself shall be saved; yet so as by fire.

2 tim 2:13 Since we are unfaithful, Yet He abideth faithful: He cannot deny himself.

1 cor 12:21 and the eye cannot say unto the hand, I have no need of thee: nor again the head to the feet, I have no need of you.

eph 1:22 and hath put all things under his feet, and gave Him to be the head over all things to the church 23 which is His body, the fulness of Him that filleth all in all.



Once again... who work is savaltion?

answer... John 1:13.... God's work

waiting
 
Upvote 0

heymikey80

Quidquid Latine dictum sit, altum viditur
Dec 18, 2005
14,496
921
✟41,809.00
Faith
Calvinist
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Republican
Romans 8:31-eoc. Eternal security of those who truly rely on Jesus Christ for salvation.

However, I don't believe in all things labeled "OSAS". Some things labelled "OSAS" aren't.

This is not "Once I think I'm saved I'm always saved."

This is not "Once I say a formula I'm always saved."

It's "Once I'm actually saved, I'm always saved."

It seems clear to me that everyone believes this in one sense. If you're judged & admitted to heaven, it doesn't seem you can be ejected. If you believe that, the only real question we'd be arguing over is what time you become secure -- not whether you will be secure.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rick Otto
Upvote 0

beloved57

Well-Known Member
Jun 16, 2006
4,017
43
✟4,663.00
Faith
Calvinist
Romans 8:31-eoc. Eternal security of those who truly rely on Jesus Christ for salvation.

However, I don't believe in all things labeled "OSAS". Some things labelled "OSAS" aren't.

This is not "Once I think I'm saved I'm always saved."

This is not "Once I say a formula I'm always saved."

It's "Once I'm actually saved, I'm always saved."

It seems clear to me that everyone believes this in one sense. If you're judged & admitted to heaven, it doesn't seem you can be ejected. If you believe that, the only real question we'd be arguing over is what time you become secure -- not whether you will be secure.
The elect are saved before time began..

2tim 1:

9Who hath saved us, and called us with an holy calling, not according to our works, but according to his own purpose and grace, which was given us in Christ Jesus before the world began,

All that which tranpires in time is to bring us to the realization He saved us..Then in time he calls the elect by the gospel..
 
Upvote 0

Ben johnson

Legend
Site Supporter
Feb 9, 2002
16,916
404
Oklahoma
Visit site
✟99,049.00
Faith
Christian
Squint said:
Don't know what that catch phrase may mean to you.
Simply --- is it possible to be "walking in sin" (unrighteous), but still be saved?
I do know without doubt that ALL OF ISRAEL SHALL BE SAVED, even (past tense) EMEMIES of the GOSPEL from Romans 11:26...on who have obviously perished in the flesh by now...
Did he mean "all Israel-every-last-PERSON", or did he mean "all-Israel-as-a-concept"?

Heb9:27 asserts that "it is appointed once for a man to die, and after that comes judgment" --- connect that with a passage like Rom2:6-8, judgment is EITHER to "eternal life" (immortality), OR eternal death. There is no room for "after-judgment-redemption".
That statement in particular is from 1 John 3:9 which implicates the DEVIL in ALL SINS...I do not believe that mankind can be both God's offspring as Paul taught in Acts 17:23-29 and devils as that would reflect on our Father.
It simply says that "we who are God's, are righteous; he who is not righteous, does not belong to God.
I also know that ALL OF ISRAEL were taught to be God's children in Deut. 14:1 and Psalm 82:6 and of course not all of them were believers, NOR could they be because God place a spirit of stupor upon them to blind and deafen them...again...Romans 11
That must be understood on context; in Matt13:15, they closed their own eyes and ears. And Rom9:32-33 clearly states "they did not arrive at righteousness BECAUSE they pursued it by works rather than by faith".
There are then some that are meant to see in this present life but that does not preclude God from saving them ALL, as Paul taught that "mystery" in Romans 11.
Jesus said, "NOT EVERYONE shall inherit the kingdom of God". Matt7:21
Don't see that particular statement in Romans 6 Ben...
It's verse 1-2[/quote]We cannot say we "have no sin" as a present tense condition and be "in Truth."[/quote]Do you accept the difference between "walking in sin", and "walking in repentance (in Christ, in His forgiveness)"?
1 John 1:8 Paul also had sin indwelling his flesh that he termed NO LONGER I twice in Romans 7...and Paul taught that "whenever" he desired to do good that EVIL was present with him. This does not make Paul the same as the sin that obviously still indwelt his flesh NOR does that make Paul "EVIL."
Rom7 is still the "battle". And the solution is still chapter 8. We walk EITHER in sin, OR in Him and righteousness. There is no "middle-ground".
We are advised not to yield to sin...meaning that it is still there to yield to, particularly if EVIL is present with us whenever we desire to do good.
That is exactly right --- yet, we are powerless to resist sin. The secret --- is to draw close to Him, that HE becomes the power of our resistance. James4:6-8.
Death was a daily reckoning for Paul because of what was "with" him in his flesh.
Paul was clearly speaking of spiritual death in Rom8:12-14.
Ben said:
So --- we live in war, no LONGER.
Don't see that either Ben.
It's in Rom8 --- "What the flesh could not do, God did --- sending His Son in the likeness of sinful death, He condemned sin in the flesh, that the Law might be fulfilled in us, who walk not after the flesh but according to the Spirit".

Walking according to the Spirit, is not-walking-in-sin.
I'm not denying that there is eternal punishment Ben. But we may very well differ on "who" is going to suffer that fate.
What you, or I think, is irrelevant before Scripture. Unbelievers are condemned (1Jn5:10).

"Unbelief", is inseparable from "walking in sin". He who believes, dwells in Christ, Christ dwells in him (her?), and anyone so-dwelt walks in His righteousness rather than sin. While we live, we have temptation; thus it is a CONSTANT admonition to walk in Him and NOT in sin, to CONTINUALLY guard against deception.

This is the only understanding of Col2:6-8: "As you have received Christ, so walk IN Him... SEE that no one takes you captive according to philosophy and empty deception, according to worldly principles, rather than according to Christ."

And that's why I persist in OSAS debates; to convey the true Scriptural admonition to my brothers and sisters to "excercise diligence in their faith and their standing in Christ."
Sorry Ben. I don't believe that God's Love HALTS at the point of death.
God is LOVE. 1Jn4:16 (He who abides in love, abides in God, and God abides in Him.)

And God is just. Rom3:26 (God is just and justifier of HE WHO BELIEVES.)

If a man chooses to go to Hell, God's justness forbids Him to interfere.

I know with certainty that God DOES love those who perish; and there is a part of God's heart that will always remember them, and will remember what they could have been had they followed Him.

Jesus wept --- God does too. Please read Ezk18:32.
Anyone who dies is RELEASED FROM SIN.
What do you think that means? That someone who has lived in sin, fornication drunkenness murder robbery etcetera, suddenly DIES and his sin-account is CLEARED??? It is not. Please re-read the passage --- he's saying "anyone who has DIED TO SIN (and become alive in Christ), is released from sin". It's identical to what Jesus said:
"He who commits sin is a slave to sin; ...if therefore the Son shall make you free, you shall be free indeed." Jn8:34-36
There are many forms of judgment Ben. Judgment as it pertains to mankind is that ALL would honor The Son.
I'm speaking of Rom2:6-8. No way is "wrath/indignation", also "Heaven-bound".
I could give dozens of scriptures that EXONERATE mankind... you should know them without the numbers:

-If any man hear my words and believe NOT, I judge him Not

-I judge NO MAN

-The Father judges NO MAN

etc etc...
Cite the references, and let's discuss them. Just as we've discussed your understanding of Rom6.
I don't think I need to beat the point to death...Paul taught that in the SAME LUMP there is BOTH a vessel of honor and a vessel of dishonor and wrath.
No --- three vessels. NASV translates "atimia" in that passage, as "COMMON". Thus, there are:
1. Vessels of honor (saved)
2. Vessels of common (saved)
3. Vessels of wrath fitted (themselves!) for destruction
Satan was not EVER presented in scripture as EVER being "holy." Being perfect in "all his ways" only makes him a PERFECT DEVIL. Jesus said he was a liar, and a murderer FROM THE BEGINNING. John 8:44
"From the beginning", does not mean "from creation". For God could not have created him sinful and a liar.
Ben said:
Mankind cannot dwell in sin; passages like 1Cor6:9-11, Gal5:19-21, Eph5:5-6, and especially 1Jn3:5-10 are very clear...

None of those citings say that we have no sin Ben, or that we don't dwell in it.
Yes, they do. Let's talk about one --- perhaps the Galatians passage?

I look forward to your response.

:)
 
Upvote 0

squint

Well-Known Member
Jul 23, 2007
16,182
903
Mountain Regions
✟20,405.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
Simply --- is it possible to be "walking in sin" (unrighteous), but still be saved?

Ben I want to be very clear on this matter.

WE are NOT alone in our flesh. Scripturally speaking it is and remains ENTIRELY possible that BOTH conditions, that of the sinner and the SAINT are in the SAME LUMP.

God raises EITHER ONE as HE sees fit and DEALS with those TWO PARTIES who are NOT THE SAME in entirely OPPOSITE MANNERS. One unto ETERNAL LIFE and one unto ETERNAL DEATH.

When this understanding is applied to scripture, BECAUSE it is a FACT, then the entirety of The Word makes PERFECT sense. Apart from this understanding there will only be confusion as a result.

Did he mean "all Israel-every-last-PERSON", or did he mean "all-Israel-as-a-concept"?

You can "re-term" ALL OF ISRAEL however you like. The fact does remain however that ALL OF ISRAEL, even ENEMIES of the Gospel are stated as 'SHALL BE SAVED.' There is no getting around that presentation by "conceptualizing" ALL OF ISRAEL in any other manner when ENEMIES of the Gospel are SAVED.

That presentation effectually eradicates both determinist and freewill doctrines as we commonly know them BECAUSE both presentations cannot deal with the simple statement and must somehow ERADICTE or ELIMINATE plain speaking via various forms of "conceptualization."

Heb9:27 asserts that "it is appointed once for a man to die, and after that comes judgment"

I agree with and have no problem with ETERNAL JUDGMENT. I do not agree that eternal damnation is going to fall on any person. I do agree that the devil and his messengers who are FOUND IN MANKIND will suffer that fate of eternal damnation.

In addition, and staying with the topic matter of this thread, there is not ONE SINGLE EXAMPLE of any believer in the entire N.T. who is said to be going to suffer the fate of ETERNAL TORTURE/DAMNATION.

In short, that presentation DOES NOT EXIST in scripture as it pertains to "believers."

--- connect that with a passage like Rom2:6-8, judgment is EITHER to "eternal life" (immortality), OR eternal death. There is no room for "after-judgment-redemption".

All "redemption" is post death Ben. We do not have the "entirety" of redemption while we are in this present life. WE ALL have corruptible bodies and minds. That's just a fact. And Romans 11:26 says otherwise as far as Israel is concerned. But of course anyone is free to NOT believe that in order to sustain their doctrinal positions.

There is a certain fact about the people of Israel that cannot be avoided. Scriptures teach that THEY are ALL God's children. I for one do not believe that God is going to be casting away forever His Own children. THAT is why THEY are ALL going to be SAVED, even those who were MADE enemies of the Gospel.

It simply says that "we who are God's, are righteous; he who is not righteous, does not belong to God.

Again I agree. Where I disagree howeve is to view ANY person as ALONE in the flesh. Jesus clearly showed the presence of THE DEVIL and his messengers to be WITH mankind. So rendering any determinations apart from THIS FACT will remain one sided and short of logic.

That must be understood on context; in Matt13:15, they closed their own eyes and ears.

I'm not denying that it was their eyes and their ears anymore than any of us can deny that the sin that indwells us is OURS because it is OUR FLESH.

This does NOT mean however that ISRAEL was the "same as" the SPIRIT OF STUPOR that God is said to have PLACED upon them in Romans 11. God did not place them upon themselves. God DID place "a spirit of stupor" upon them.

And Rom9:32-33 clearly states "they did not arrive at righteousness BECAUSE they pursued it by works rather than by faith".

"Works" that do not include LOVE are not of faith.

Faith "works" THRU LOVE. The "evidence" of faith are the WORKS of LOVE. That is why James says faith apart from WORKS is DEAD faith because there are no WORKings OF LOVE. Those who say that they have faith but do not do the works of LOVE are and remain as blinded SLAVES of SIN.

The Good News however is that God does not COUNT SINS against us or our fellow man. (2 Cor. 5:19) God DOES count sins against the devil and his messengers who are FOUND in mankind. So again, these two parties DO exist in the flesh and are dealt with in entirely different and opposite manners as stated above.

Jesus said, "NOT EVERYONE shall inherit the kingdom of God". Matt7:21

I have no problem with that scipture Ben, nor any other. I do have a problem rendering any scripture apart from THE FACTS that there are TWO PARTIES involved in all of these matters who are dealt with differently.

[/quote]That is exactly right --- yet, we are powerless to resist sin. [/quote]

The question pertaining to SIN and it's works does boil down to which party is IN CONTROL. I have no use in blaming only mankind while IGNORING the fact that none of us are alone in the flesh.

The secret --- is to draw close to Him, that HE becomes the power of our resistance. James4:6-8.

IF a slave of sin remains entirely A BLINDED CAPTIVE for their entire life, that STILL does not mean that God condemns them. That slave can and will go free of sin...and their captOR(S) can be entirely DAMNED.

"Unbelief", is inseparable from "walking in sin". He who believes, dwells in Christ, Christ dwells in him (her?), and anyone so-dwelt walks in His righteousness rather than sin. While we live, we have temptation; thus it is a CONSTANT admonition to walk in Him and NOT in sin, to CONTINUALLY guard against deception.


One part of deception is to NOT be aware that the sin indwelling us IS NOT US just as it was NO LONGER I for Paul. Another part of deception is to NOT be aware that the EVIL PRESENT with us is NOT US just as it was NOT PAUL.

This is the only understanding of Col2:6-8: "As you have received Christ, so walk IN Him... SEE that no one takes you captive according to philosophy and empty deception, according to worldly principles, rather than according to Christ."


There are predators here on this earth Ben...The predators are the ANTI-CHRIST spirits. I have no use thinking that those are my fellow man.

I know with certainty that God DOES love those who perish; and there is a part of God's heart that will always remember them, and will remember what they could have been had they followed Him.

I don't believe in "free will" choice Ben. Mankind's will's in the light of the fact of our present bondage to indwelling sin which is NOT US and EVIL PRESENT with us "whenever" we try to do good INDICATES beyond any doubt that the will's of mankind are CONTINUALLY tampered with by THOSE WORKINGS.

I'd like you to think about that concept for a bit in your next response. You might find it a little harder to condemn your fellow believers who have fallen captive in light of the facts, and perhaps someday you'll turn to the real enemies in these matters for your rightfully discerned judgment.

No man using his freewill can eradicate the presence of our enemies.

enjoy!

squint
 
Upvote 0
Status
Not open for further replies.