If God is all that is good, evil was necessary to give mankind freewill.
There will be freewill in heaven without evil. God did NOT create "sin."
"Sin" is the potential bi-product of choice. God DID create beings with
"choice." Disobedience was a potential existence (God is Omniscient) but
not an actual existence until someone disobeyed. God did NOT create
their disobedience. He created them with a WILL to be able to disobey.
There is a difference.
Freewill is necessary if God desired true love and not robots. Now, if this evil was necessary, God must have created it,
No. Just because knowledge of disobedience is necessary to NOT disobey,
[and you also need "motive"] (Love in response to God's Incredible Self-Sacrificing
Love and election of us out of those who are perishing), does NOT mean
that God created the disobedience or the sin.
God's KNOWLEDGE of disobedience is not the creation of it....neither is it
your creation when your teenagers exercise their freewill to misbehave.
Even if you knew it before hand...before you decided to pro-create your
children.... it would still NOT be your creation (their sin).
since He is the only one who could.
Unless He created beings who could create their own disobedience.
Thus we have the birth of God's opposite, Satan.
God's enemy, yes. And our enemy since we are born-again of God, yes.
But is satan and his demons really an "opposite" of God? I know this may
seem to be nitpicking and hyper-technical... but it is very important to
understand that good and evil are NOT exact opposites. Good is the
standand...disobedience is no standard at all. I would also ask "can
an Infinite Creator even
have an opposite?" Can something finite be
an opposite of something infinite?
You cannot know evil in the presence of God since he is almighty.
I would agree with you if you had said "cannot commit acts of disobedience"
in the presence of God...but won't we have knowledge of good and evil
in heaven? Won't we know what evil is so we can finally NEVER choose
to do it?
Thus there were two trees in the garden of Eden; life and knowledge of good and evil. It symbolizes two choices that mankind was given. Either be free of evil and exist with God or know of evil and be cast out from God.
Beside from the question of two choices verses two things to choose
from...and I realize that there is continuous nitpicking here that may
seem unreasonable...I am concerned with "know OF evil" and being
cast out from God. Clearly Jesus knows of evil even though He has
never commited any sin and has never disobeyed God.
This was God's dilemma. How do we obtain knowledge of evil and thus obtain true love and still exist in His presence?
Knowledge of evil can be "observed" in others and learned this way.
The angels who did not fall can learn from those who did fall with lucifer.
Just as Jesus can observe evil in others and have knowledge of it and
NOT commit it Himself.
What you need to do is go back to the beginning and understand the
difference between a heaven which "loses" a child of God for all of eternity
because God started with heaven without us having a knowledge of good
and evil. It is much different than SAVING a child of God out of those
who are logically lost. And I mean logically. Eternal hell and separation
are logical to exist because of multiple reasons which must be addressed
in this context. (The role of knowledge, choice, salvation and damnation
and how they are inevitable).
The answer of course is through Jesus.
Agreed. It is the Perfect Sacrifice of God becoming a Man and dying on
the Cross for our sins that makes the creation of beings capable of LOVE
and choice logical again.
It is the Holy Spirit of God Who opens our eyes up to this Perfect Logic.