I've seen a lot of posters here claim that Harris "lied incessantly," though they've pointed out few specifics. The Federalist, though, has helpfully provided a list of 25 lies. So let's look at them:
Here are 25 of the biggest falsehoods Kamala Harris told during her Tuesday night debate with Donald Trump.
thefederalist.com
1. "Middle Class Kid"
I'm not sure how being the child of a college professor and a university research scientist disqualifies someone from the middle class. Neither is a particularly lucrative profession. Her family certainly wasn't poor, but she didn't claim that.
Verdict: Not a lie.
2. Trump's tax cuts
It should be noted that the analysis cited here by The Federalist is just a loop of the same person citing himself, and only considers data from 2018. Furthermore, it only looks at individual income tax data, which doesn't tell the whole story. While that data does show that people making less than $50,000 received the largest
percentage tax reduction that year relative to 2017, the real dollar value of those reductions was mostly pretty small. For example, people making $10,000-$15,000 saw their average taxes drop by 72%. Which is great - but the real dollar value of that "massive" drop was $85/taxpayer. In contrast, people making $500,000-$1,000,000 saw their taxes drop by a paltry 9% - which worked out to around $15,000/taxpayer. Now, if you consider those numbers as a percentage of the taxpayer's total income, the picture changes a bit. Ther person making $15,000/year regains 0.6% of their income per year, while the person making $1,000,000 regains 1.5%. Seems to me that the person making a million per year wins out in this exchange.
Verdict: Not a lie.
3. Trump "Sales Tax"
Trump has proposed a 10-20% tariff on all imports, and 60% on imports from China. While not
technically a sales tax, we would see most, if not all of that passed on to consumers, leading to higher prices for imported goods.
Verdict: Mostly true
4. Jan. 6
Contrary to the Federalist's claim, the J6 events did put American self-governance in jeopardy. And bringing up examples of military attacks is a complete non-sequitur; Harris was referring to attacks on our democratic institutions, not physical attacks on US territories.
Verdict: Not a lie.
5. Project 2025
Hard to grade this one. While Trump certainly has said that he has nothing to do with Project 2025, the fact remains that many current and former members of his administration/campaign are involved in it, and some of its provisions look a lot like things that Trump did or was trying to do towards the end of his first term. Ultimately, though, this is a statement of opinion, as no one can predict the future, and opinions are not lies.
Verdict: Opinion; not a lie
6. Just Restoring Roe
She absolutely dodged the question, but dodging the question isn't lying.
Verdict: Not a lie
7. Pro-Life Laws Criminalize Miscarriages, Ectopic Pregnancies
While technically correct in their assessment that these things are not explicitly criminalized, the Federalist conveniently ignores the real effects of recent anti-abortion legislation, which have been widely discussed here on this site. In states like Texas, hospitals have been turning women with life-threatening conditions away over fear of prosecution. Even if the laws do not explicitly criminalize these situations, the effect remains the same.
Verdict: Half true
8. Trump's abortion stance
I'll give them this one. Trump does not seem to be in favor of a national abortion ban.
Verdict: Lie
9. Ninth Month Abortions Don't Exist
Last I checked, 21 weeks gets you into the 6th month, not the 9th month. Therefore, the number of abortions performed after 21 weeks is not evidence of abortions being performed during the 9th month of pregnancy.
Verdict: Not a lie.
10. Border Bill
This is just the Federalist's opinion. Others disagree with their assessment, and again, no one can see into the alternate future where that bill passed, so no one knows for certain what the real effects would have been.
Verdict: Not a lie.
11. SCOTUS Immunity Ruling
The Federalist is splitting hairs here. The SCOTUS ruling was rather vague, and arguments couple be made for many things that the president does being "official acts." Regardless, it's pretty clear what she was getting at.
Verdict: Mostly true.
12. Fracking Ban
Again, dodging the question isn't lying. Regardless, 2019 was not 2020, so using an example from 2019 to disprove her statement about her beliefs in 2020 is misleading. By 2020, Harris had already backed away from the commitment to a fracking ban, even casting the tie-breaking vote to expand fracking leases then, so her statement that she "made herself very clear in 2020" is accurate.
Verdict: Not a lie.
13. Minnesota Rioters Bail Fund
Harris did indeed promote the Minnesota Freedom Fund in a June 1, 2020 tweet. However, at that point, they were a very small organization that had only been in operation for 4 years, having helped a total of ~500 people in that time. The aftermath of the George Floyd protests (and, in part, Harris's tweet) caused them to expand massively and seems to have changed their policies, such that they started providing bail for more dangerous/violent criminals. So, it's a bit misleading to suggest that she promoted an organization that was putting violent criminals back on the streets when - at the time that she promoted it - they were not.
Verdict: Not a lie
14. Trump's Role in J6
Trump did make the "peacefully and patriotically" statement, but he also said that his supporters needed to "fight like [heck] or [they wouldn't] have a country anymore" in the same speech. And that's before getting into the repeated lies that he told leading up to that day about the election being stolen or fraudulent. There is a pretty strong argument to be made that Trump at least had some role in inciting the J6 riot.
Verdict: Not a lie
15. J6 Deaths
I believe that the final cause of death for Officer Sicknick was a stroke. While technically "natural causes," it can be reasonably deduced that the stroke was related to the injuries he sustained on January 6th. Additionally, 4 further officers died of suicide in the immediate aftermath. Harris specifically said that these five officers died "as a result of" the January 6th riot - in that their deaths were related to it and they would likely still be alive had it not occurred. The Federalist tries to debunk her words by deliberately misinterpreting them to mean that they were directly killed during the riot.
Verdict: Not a lie
16. "Fine People" Hoax
Yep, Trump walked that one back and clarified, but it took a while, and he
did say it.
Verdict: Mostly true.
17. "Bloodbath" Hoax
Again, he said it. Maybe he didn't mean it in the way that Harris puts it, or maybe he did. As we're not mind readers, it becomes a matter of opinion.
Verdict: Mostly true.
18. Trump's NATO Comments
Technically, the Federalist is correct here - the comments that Harris refers to were about NATO members, not Ukraine. However, those comments reveal a fundamental misunderstanding about how NATO works - the defense spending targets are not binding obligations, and there are no penalties for not meeting them. If Trump wants there to be penalties, that's fine, but he needs to push for an amendment to the NATO charter to that effect - he can't just declare it unilaterally. Furthermore, his many other statements on Ukraine and Russia, as well as his evasiveness when asked directly about his preferred outcome of the current war, reveal his attitude on the conflict.
Verdict: Lie, but the Federalist misses the point.
19. Autocrats' Preferences for President
The reasons for Putin's "endorsement" of Harris have been discussed on this site already. Also, Viktor Orban is (arguably) an autocrat, and Trump specifically touted Orban's praise of him during the debate. He's also fond of pointing out his close relationships with Putin and Kim.
Verdict: Not a lie
20. Combat Zones
Harris was splitting hairs here. I'll call it a lie.
Verdict: Lie
21. Blaming Trump for Biden's Botched Afghanistan Withdrawal
Both parties bear some blame on this one. Trump negotiated a pretty bad deal (including releasing 5000 Taliban fighters), and Biden then rushed the process.
Verdict: Half true
22. Gun Confiscation
Harris did support a mandatory buyback program for "assault weapons" in 2019, but more recently, she's amended that to say that she supports an assault weapons ban, but without a mandatory buyback program.
Verdict: Half true
23. Trump's Foreign Policy Record
This is just opinion.
Verdict: Not a lie
24. Defunding the Police
“reimagin[ing]” policing and “redirect[ing] resources” from police toward what the outlet described as “other areas of government [such as] schools and small businesses.” does not sound like "defund the police" to me.
Verdict: Not a lie
25. IVF
While Trump himself may not be opposed to IVF, the abortion bans that he enabled (AKA "Donald Trump's abortion bans") have not been so discerning. The issues in Arkansas have bene well-publicized.
Verdict: Not a lie.
So, final counts are 3 lies, 7 partial truths, and 15 things that weren't actually lies. Not a strong showing from The Federalist, I gotta say.