Ed1wolf
Well-Known Member
- Dec 26, 2002
- 2,928
- 178
- Country
- United States
- Faith
- Presbyterian
- Marital Status
- Single
Ed1wolf said: ↑
So you know what a dog knows just by body language and facial expressions?
ken: I didn’t say that. When I am angry, my dog has the look of fear in his eyes, his head lowers, and his tail goes between his legs. When I am happy, my dog acts excited, his head is raised, and his tail wags. My dog can often recognize my mood and he reacts accordingly.
I am not saying that dogs dont have simple emotional responses to simple human emotions. That is a far cry from a moral system though.
I believe you did, go back and reread what you wrote. Cops are the arm of justice that brings someone to justice under the law. Of course, you can be forgiving and still be moral. Forgiveness is part of morality too. Of course, as humans and our limited knowledge and insight, we may forgive the wrong person and get take advantage of. But God knows who should be forgiven and who should not based on His omniscience.Ed1wolf said: ↑
But you said that a good cop always shows mercy and lets the person go. Now you are contradicting yourself.
ken: I never said that. It is not a cops job to dole out mercy or justice. I said you could be forgiving and still be moral. Do you know the difference?
Ed1wolf said: ↑
The Christian God doesn't do nothing, He either punishes you in this world with government authorities or in the next world in hell.
ken: He should have STOPPED Hitler; he should have STOPPED Amin. He should have STOPPED Mao. Punishing them after they slaughtered millions is a little too late.
How do you know He should have stopped them? You dont have an objective moral standard to say they did anything objectively wrong. But He created a free will and primarily natural law universe in order to destroy evil forever. So such people are possible to exist in such a universe. People can freely choose to do evil. 99.9% of the time it is up to us to stop them. This is how we grow spiritually which is another purpose of this universe, we grow by fighting evil ourselves without any supernatural help from God.
Ed1wolf said: ↑
No, because God and us are both persons, so we have similar moral systems. Especially since we are made in the image of God we were created with a moral conscience.
ken: How about those people (like Amin or Dahmer) whose moral system is much different than Gods? Are they moral too?
They are immoral according to God's objective moral standards. But if atheistic evolution is true, then they did nothing objectively wrong.
Ed1wolf said: ↑
Dogs are basically programmed to do certain things and respond to certain stimuli in basically the same way everytime, they dont have a true free will. Without a true free will you cannot make moral decisions.
ken: What is the difference between free will vs True free will? Because nobody has complete free will; everybody’s desires are restricted in one way or another. So if true freewill is complete freewill; then I say you don’t have it either. If you disagree, try walking into a bank and taking all their money and see what happens.
s.
Actually I meant to call it a true will. Only fully personal beings have a true will. A true will enables you to refuse food even though you are healthy and hungry, dogs cant do that because they dont have a true will. Dogs are not fully personal beings, they do have a few aspects of personhood such as emotions, but not much beyond that. They definitely dont have a true will.
Upvote
0