Dear dfw69,
According to the Jewish tradition there are two Messiahs: Messiah ben Joseph (sufferring Messiah) and Messiah ben David (King Eternal). I'll not expain Who is Messiah ben David in Christian forum As to Messiah ben Joseph he is "the shepherd, the stone of Israel" according to Genesis 49:24
Some Russian Ortodox Christians considered also two kinds of Messiah. However, their interpеtation differs from the Jewish one, because we have the New Testament, especially Revelation . Again, I'll not write something about The Lord Jesus Christ, our Christian Messiah ben David . The analysis of the old Russian icons can reveal, that Russian princes and kings in ~ 14-17th centuries considered themselves as the incarnation of the Michael. "Small" (not suffering! - The Lord Jesus Christ
was suffering in Christian tradition) Messiah is the man in these verses:
"5. And she brought forth a man child, who was to rule all nations with a rod of iron: and her child was caught up unto God, and to his throne... 7. And there was war in heaven: Michael and his angels fought against the dragon; and the dragon fought and his angels" (Revelation 12:5-7)
He is also "he, that overcomes" accoeding to 26. And he that overcometh, and keepeth my works unto the end, to him will I give power over the nations: 27. And he shall rule them with a rod of iron...28. And I will give him the morning star."(Revelation 2:26-28)
Scepter in the hand of the Russian king is the "rod of iron", and globus cruciger is the "morning star".
You can get some information about this at
http://www.apocalyptism.ru/michael-trinity.htm
So, if Yitzhak Kaduri said about Messiah ben Joseph - there are no contradictions between Jewish and Orthodox believers.
Let us rememeber that Cyrus was the Messiah (I know, that many people stop reading me at this point - Cyrus was not the Messiah, the Anointed One. Take it easy ). So, in some interpretation Orthodox christians and Jewish believers could be waiting for the same man, who is as "Small Messiah" (~Moscow great prince) so "Messiah ben Joseph".
Sincerely yours,
Onisim
There is no messiah other than Jesus....that is the long and short of it.Messiah Ben Joseph is a son of Israel and Israel being the lost tribes...so he could be who?....I'm confused.. as to who is Israel and who is a son of Joseph....I believe the lost tribes exist....your saying he will be a Russian ???
What will be messiah Ben Joseph mission to accomplish when he arrives?
Also could Elijah be messiah been Joseph? And will he pave the way for messiah Ben David?
Why is he considered the suffering messiah? Just some questions I have...
Well, the hebrew word for messiah would be anointed, which the kings and priest of Israel were "anointed's". And Cyrus was called an anointed.Dear dfw69,
Let us consider Cyrus as the Messiah (some believers say that he is "the anointed one" and it is not correct to use term Messiah). If we adopt, that Cyrus wad Messiah, than Messiah ben Joseph could be Jew, Russian, American and etc., while Messiah ben David could be Jew only. There is one very important requirement for Russian or American Messiah ben Joseph. He is chosen for "Jacob my servant's sake, and Israel mine elect,...though thou hast not known me." (Isaiah 45:1-4). So, in any case Russian or American "Messiah ben Joseph" is the Jewish one according to his destination .
>What will be messiah Ben Joseph mission to accomplish when he arrives?
The mission is the following :"He is my shepherd, and shall perform all my pleasure: even saying to Jerusalem, Thou shalt be built; and to the temple, Thy foundation shall be laid (Isaiah 44:27,28)". The Jerusalem of the Messiah ben Joseph is not New Jerusalem - bride of the Messiah ben David.
>I believe the lost tribes exist
It's very interesting question. I suppose, that Messiah ben Joseph has special mission concerning these 10 lost tribes of Israel which was located to the North of Judaea. So, I believe that his mission is also related with the verse: "But, The LORD liveth, which led the seed of the house of Israel out of the north country. (Jeremiah 23:8)
The topic of the lost tribes is very interesting for me. I've read, that long time ago in USA there were theories, that before Columbus lost tribes visited your country. Is it true? I mean, that these theories existed?
P.S.
>Also could Elijah be messiah been Joseph?
Elijah is in a very close relations with the Messiah been Joseph, but he is not the Messiah been Joseph.
But, please, tomorrow Time zones in USA and Russia are very different
Thank you very much for your reply ..peace to youDear dfw69,
Let us consider Cyrus as the Messiah (some believers say that he is "the anointed one" and it is not correct to use term Messiah). If we adopt, that Cyrus wad Messiah, than Messiah ben Joseph could be Jew, Russian, American and etc., while Messiah ben David could be Jew only. There is one very important requirement for Russian or American Messiah ben Joseph. He is chosen for "Jacob my servant's sake, and Israel mine elect,...though thou hast not known me." (Isaiah 45:1-4). So, in any case Russian or American "Messiah ben Joseph" is the Jewish one according to his destination .
>What will be messiah Ben Joseph mission to accomplish when he arrives?
The mission is the following :"He is my shepherd, and shall perform all my pleasure: even saying to Jerusalem, Thou shalt be built; and to the temple, Thy foundation shall be laid (Isaiah 44:27,28)". The Jerusalem of the Messiah ben Joseph is not New Jerusalem - bride of the Messiah ben David.
>I believe the lost tribes exist
It's very interesting question. I suppose, that Messiah ben Joseph has special mission concerning these 10 lost tribes of Israel which was located to the North of Judaea. So, I believe that his mission is also related with the verse: "But, The LORD liveth, which led the seed of the house of Israel out of the north country. (Jeremiah 23:8)
The topic of the lost tribes is very interesting for me. I've read, that long time ago in USA there were theories, that before Columbus lost tribes visited your country. Is it true? I mean, that these theories existed?
P.S.
>Also could Elijah be messiah been Joseph?
Elijah is in a very close relations with the Messiah been Joseph, but he is not the Messiah been Joseph.
But, please, tomorrow Time zones in USA and Russia are very different
Dear Douggg,
Thank you for the reply!
>In Christianity there is only one messiah
ОК.I agree to use terms "the Anointed One ben Josef" and "the Messiah ben David".
>In Christianity there is only one messiah...
It depends on the importance of the Nicene Creed in your Christian life. Maybe it is more correct to say
>In Ptotestantism there is only one messiah...
taking into account, that usually the Nicene Creed is not so important as the Bible in the Protestantism,
In the Nicene Creed there is the statement concerning The Lord Jesus Christ "...He shall come again, with glory, to judge the quick and the dead. whose kingdom shall have no end." The one-thousand kingdom of Christ is limited in time. How can you explain this contradiction betweeen limitation of one-thousand kingdom and statement "no end"?
The Anointed One (the Anointed One ben Joseph) and Elias pave the way for the Messiah ben David " Behold, I will send you Elijah the prophet before the coming of the great and dreadful day of the LORD…(Malachi 4:5)"
1. I don't have a thorough interpretation of the prediction of Rabbi Yitzhak.Dear Ronald,
I've read about Rabbi Yitzhak at http://eliotelwarapologetics.com/2014/01/11/rabbi-yitzhak-kaduri-predictions/
Can you recommend more thorough description of his predictions? Thank you in advance.
I have two questions.
1. At http://eliotelwarapologetics.com/ I've read "...Rabbi Kaduri wrote that he met the Messiah". But how could he met Jesus (Messiah ben David) if we can met Jesus nowdays only according to the verse: "For as the lightning, that lighteneth out of the one part under heaven, shineth unto the other part under heaven; so shall also the Son of man be in his day.(Luke 17:24)". If Rabbi met Messiah ben Joseph, there are no problems from Christian point of view.
2. The second question is very important because I'm living in Russia.
At http://eliotelwarapologetics.com/ I've read " On 24 September 2001, Rabbi Kaduri prophesied that the Gog and Magog War will commence and will last for seven or more years, according to Arutz Sheva Israel National Radio broadcast. This war involves a coalition of Islamic nations led by Russia against Israel, America, and the Western European powers."
The identification of the Russia as the country of Gog and Magog was invented by John Cumming in 1855 during Crimean War. Are the well-known events happened in Crimea in 2014, the sign, that the identification of Russia as the country of Gog and Magog is actual now again?
Sincerely yours,
Onisim
I'm all ears. Do a copy and paste of Messiah ben Joseph in the text. A prophesied messiah from the house of Joseph.So, if you can't find information concerning "the Anointed One ben Josef" in Ezekiel 37 it doesn't mean, that there is no Messiah ben Joseph in the other Bible passages.
I'm all ears. Do a copy and paste of Messiah ben Joseph in the text. A prophesied messiah from the house of Joseph.
You seem to be taking from Judaism sources their idea of a messiah ben Joseph. Their sources are from rabbinic teachings and the Talmud. Perhaps take a listen to this Orthodox Priest who came out of Judaism.