Funny, this thread hit on something that was on my mind, one of the reasons I joined.
I too saw a Yahoo news article that seemed to be generating strong opinions from believers and non-believers. The article was about a man who had been in a car accident, ruptured an aneurysm, and the doctors were about to give up on him, thinking that if even if he survived he would have severe brain damage, but they kept after him, repaired the aneurysm, and even one of the doctors was quoted as saying it was a miracle he survived, and that he's expected to make a full recovery.
Well, the believers were leaving comments such as "praise the Lord", the non-believers were chastising them for believing in their "imaginary friend", and that the doctors should be thanked. Still others were asking the believers if they would go to a church or to a hospital if they were having a heart attack. To me, it just seemed like the non-believers were having a field day belittling the believers, as though they must be stupid for having faith in the Lord.
Me, personally, I don't discount the work the doctors did for the man, the folks commenting would have been wise to include thanks to the doctors, but even the doctors can only do so much. If the doctors say it's a miracle that he's going to make a full recovery, then who am I to disagree with them? The Lord gives each of us our talents and abilities, and some folks were blessed with being good doctors. I have no doubt the Lord was working through the doctors and in other ways, but I would have to say that some healing took place that transcends our knowledge of medicine.
I don't think equating belief in God with belief in Santa Claus or the tooth fairy is a fair comparison. My parents eventually spilled the beans that there is no Santa Claus, and I figured out pretty quickly that my mom was really the tooth fairy. I just don't believe that the world as we know it happened by accident, or that humans who are capable of so many amazing things just grew out of random collisions of molecules after billions of years.
Just my $0.02.