New! The thread has grown so long, I've placed a linked index here in the first post below:
Page 1: messages #1-10
Page 2: messages #11-20
Page 3: messages #21-30
Page 4: messages 31-40
Page 5: messages 41-50
Page 6: messages 51-60
Page 7: messages 61-70
Page 8: messages 71-80
Page 10: messages 91-100
Page 11: messages 101-110 -
Page 12: messages 111-120
Page 13: messages 121-130
Page 14-15: messages 131-150
Page 17: messages 161-170
Page 18: messages 171-180
LINKS TO OTHER THREADS IN CHRISTIAN FORUMS
Believer's Commentary on John 8:1-11
Textual Evidence for John 8:1-11
Previously Unconsidered Evidence for John 8:1-11
Reconstructing the Text of John 8:1-11
Why Wasn't the Adultress Stoned?
Related threads:
Asterisks and Obelisks: Critical marks in Ancient Manuscripts
Codex Vaticanus
Codex Sinaiticus
The Last 12 Verses of Mark
Page 1: messages #1-10
Old Testament Quotation Structure hidden in John........#3-5
Codex Bezae ('D',5th cent A.D.) .....................................#9
Introduction to Von Soden................................................#10
Codex Bezae ('D',5th cent A.D.) .....................................#9
Introduction to Von Soden................................................#10
Page 2: messages #11-20
General Discussions...............................................#11-12
Comparison to C.H. Dodd's Outline.......................#13-14
Codex Vaticanus knows of Passage!.....................#15-19
Current view & Framing the Question...........................#20
Comparison to C.H. Dodd's Outline.......................#13-14
Codex Vaticanus knows of Passage!.....................#15-19
Current view & Framing the Question...........................#20
Page 3: messages #21-30
Background to Samuel Davidson's Attack..............#21-25
Davidson's 'Internal Evidence' against...................#29-30
Davidson's 'Internal Evidence' against...................#29-30
Page 4: messages 31-40
Critique of Davidson (cont.).......................................#31-34
Miniscule 2813 (11th cent.).............................................#35
Link to Willker's Textual commentary..............................#38
Photo of P66 & links to Hills, Tregelles/Metzger............#39
Link to Art. on Johannine Authorship...............................#40
Miniscule 2813 (11th cent.).............................................#35
Link to Willker's Textual commentary..............................#38
Photo of P66 & links to Hills, Tregelles/Metzger............#39
Link to Art. on Johannine Authorship...............................#40
Page 5: messages 41-50
Majority Text Variants & Link.............................................#41
Critique of Davidson(cont.) &link to ei mh article.............#42
Link to independant analysis of 8:1-11.............................#43
Grammatical Discussion..............................................#44-47
Scrivener's Textual notes............................................#48-49
More Grammar..................................................................#50
Link to independant analysis of 8:1-11.............................#43
Grammatical Discussion..............................................#44-47
Scrivener's Textual notes............................................#48-49
More Grammar..................................................................#50
Page 6: messages 51-60
More Grammatical discussion..................................#51-52
Link: Burgeon's Defence of 8:1-11................................#53
More Background to Textual Assault........................#54-55
Link to Pickering's New stemma & NT book..................#56
Rebuttal by 'Justified'.................................................#57-59
Response by Nazaroo.....................................................#60
Link: Burgeon's Defence of 8:1-11................................#53
More Background to Textual Assault........................#54-55
Link to Pickering's New stemma & NT book..................#56
Rebuttal by 'Justified'.................................................#57-59
Response by Nazaroo.....................................................#60
Page 7: messages 61-70
Response to 'Justified' (cont).....................................#61
Correction.....................................................................#62
Rowell: effect of 'critical notes' on believers..............#63
Typical Critical Greek text inaccuracies......................#64
A.T. Robertson on John 8:1-11 ................................ #65-67
Correction.....................................................................#62
Rowell: effect of 'critical notes' on believers..............#63
Typical Critical Greek text inaccuracies......................#64
A.T. Robertson on John 8:1-11 ................................ #65-67
Page 8: messages 71-80
Analysis of Robertson's attack...................................#72-73
Parallel case in Aramaic Studies................................#74-75
Refutation of Robertson.............................................#76-77
Modern Attack on 8:1-11............................................#79
Analysis of Modern Attack..........................................#8
Page 9: messages 81-90Parallel case in Aramaic Studies................................#74-75
Refutation of Robertson.............................................#76-77
Modern Attack on 8:1-11............................................#79
Analysis of Modern Attack..........................................#8
Analysis of Modern Attack (cont.)................................#81-82
Counter-Critique & Response.....................................#83-84
Introducing Bart Earhman's propaganda (& link).............#85
Analysis of Earhman's propaganda.................................#90
Counter-Critique & Response.....................................#83-84
Introducing Bart Earhman's propaganda (& link).............#85
Analysis of Earhman's propaganda.................................#90
Page 10: messages 91-100
Discussion of belief background ...................................#91-96
John 8:1-11 and Mark's Ending............................................#97
Link to other critiques of Earhman........................................#98
Internal Evidence: Link to John ch.6.....................................#99
Tregelles undermines his own case against 8:1-11!.........#100
John 8:1-11 and Mark's Ending............................................#97
Link to other critiques of Earhman........................................#98
Internal Evidence: Link to John ch.6.....................................#99
Tregelles undermines his own case against 8:1-11!.........#100
Page 11: messages 101-110 -
D.A.Carson's Confession of duplicity............................#101
Connection between John and Revelation!..................#102-103
Culpepper on the evolving structure of John................#104
Links between John 8:1-11 & John ch.6.......................#105
Symbolic Interpretation of 8:1-11..................................#106
Chiastic Structures surrounding 8:1-11.........................#107
Chiastic Connection to Revelation.................................#108-110
Connection between John and Revelation!..................#102-103
Culpepper on the evolving structure of John................#104
Links between John 8:1-11 & John ch.6.......................#105
Symbolic Interpretation of 8:1-11..................................#106
Chiastic Structures surrounding 8:1-11.........................#107
Chiastic Connection to Revelation.................................#108-110
Page 12: messages 111-120
More Chiastic Structure around 8:1-11....................#112
John's Use of Prophecy...........................................#113
Anderson's Two Edition Theory & Critique ............#114-118
Deep Chiastic and 'Seven' patterns in John...........#119-120
John's Use of Prophecy...........................................#113
Anderson's Two Edition Theory & Critique ............#114-118
Deep Chiastic and 'Seven' patterns in John...........#119-120
Page 13: messages 121-130
Critique of Two Edition Theory (cont.).............................#121-125
Johannine parallels with 8:1-11........................................#126
Bultmann's Rearrangement of John................................#127-...
Johannine parallels with 8:1-11........................................#126
Bultmann's Rearrangement of John................................#127-...
Page 14-15: messages 131-150
Analysis of Bultmann's Rearrangement (cont.)...............#132-150
Page 16: messages 151-160Analysis of Bultmann (finish)............................................#151-152
POV (Point of View) Analysis of John.............................#153-156
Content analysis................................................................#157
Neyrey on John 21 and its significance...........................#158-160
POV (Point of View) Analysis of John.............................#153-156
Content analysis................................................................#157
Neyrey on John 21 and its significance...........................#158-160
Page 17: messages 161-170
Nature of the Addition of John 21....................................#161-163
Pickering's 'Textual Cleansing' & statistics.....................#164-170
Pickering's 'Textual Cleansing' & statistics.....................#164-170
Page 18: messages 171-180
The Missing Link: the Lectionary Stream.........................#171-175
Link to Discussion of Bultmann.........................................#174
Link to Reconstruction of Text for John 8:1-11................#176
Dead Sea Scrolls support Early Fathers!.........................#179
Link to Discussion of Bultmann.........................................#174
Link to Reconstruction of Text for John 8:1-11................#176
Dead Sea Scrolls support Early Fathers!.........................#179
Believer's Commentary on John 8:1-11
Textual Evidence for John 8:1-11
Previously Unconsidered Evidence for John 8:1-11
Reconstructing the Text of John 8:1-11
Why Wasn't the Adultress Stoned?
Related threads:
Asterisks and Obelisks: Critical marks in Ancient Manuscripts
Codex Vaticanus
Codex Sinaiticus
The Last 12 Verses of Mark