• Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.

Is touching yourself a sin? (2)

Status
Not open for further replies.

Floatingaxe

Well-Known Member
Apr 14, 2007
14,757
877
73
Ontario, Canada
✟22,726.00
Faith
Word of Faith
Marital Status
Married
Politics
CA-Conservatives
This is the scriptural error of eisogesis; putting your own ideas into God's Word. Nowhere in the Bible does it say this is sin, or even a substitute for a spouse. Nowhere. Full-stop.

This is your idea through your Biblical paradigm, and probably your church's as well, but it is extra-Biblical; not Biblical.


We have been given minds that, when united with Christ, know what is sin and what isn't--apart from the Word. We have been given the basics in the Word, and all sins that are not distinctly written out for us in the Bible can easily fall into any of the main categories. Masturbation falls into the category of sin on a few levels. Self-gratification of the flesh, fornicatoion, adultery, self-abuse, and cheating the marriage bed.

It's not my idea. It is the Holy Spirit's voice I am hearing on the matter. Otherwise, I wouldn't be bothering with this thread.
 
Upvote 0

Breetai

For I am not ashamed of the Gospel...
Dec 3, 2003
13,939
396
✟31,320.00
Faith
Lutheran
Marital Status
Private
Politics
US-Others
We have been given minds that, when united with Christ, know what is sin and what isn't--apart from the Word.
True, yet... not all Christians agree on everything; do we?

We have been given the basics in the Word, and all sins that are not distinctly written out for us in the Bible can easily fall into any of the main categories. Masturbation falls into the category of sin on a few levels. Self-gratification of the flesh,
Is that one ("self-gratification of the flesh) actually in the Bible, or is it an extra-Biblical teaching? You know, kind of like how Catholics believe in purgatory even though it's nowhere found in the Bible?

fornication,
What's the definition of this, and how can you say it includes masturbation?

Masturbation is sleeping with someone other than your wife? All silliness of that idea aside, what if you aren't married? Adultery doesn't apply at all.

self-abuse
Potentially, but not always. I don't think most people cause physical damage to themselves when masturbating.

and cheating the marriage bed.
How so? There are no other partners involved. If one partner has a problem with it, then you could say it might be sinful. But, there are no extra-marital partners involved. As long as neither spouse has a problem with it, should they be unable to fulfill their partner, I fail to see any "cheating" going on here.

It's not my idea. It is the Holy Spirit's voice I am hearing on the matter.
Even if these menial inconsequential things? How about the other Christians which disagree with your conclusions? Do you hear the Holy Spirit's voice, while you don't? How would you know that? We must check that's being said against the Bible, and what you said about the legalities of masturbation in this case are extra-Biblical.

Concerning the dangers of masturbation you are absolutely right and it is Biblical.
 
Upvote 0

Floatingaxe

Well-Known Member
Apr 14, 2007
14,757
877
73
Ontario, Canada
✟22,726.00
Faith
Word of Faith
Marital Status
Married
Politics
CA-Conservatives
self-gratification of the flesh


It's selfishness, plain and simple. Giving in to base desires is self-gratification. Do you really need to be told this? OK I am sure you must know that IF you are married, it is adultery. I will spell it out that sex--any kind of sex--outside of marriage is fornication, so, married or single, you commit it with yourself.

Self-abuse isn't always hurting yourself! Sheesh...you abuse yourself sexually when you touch--it is unnatural to manipulate one's sexual organs to achieve sexual gratification--that is abuse of the proper function of a body.

What is this? Ninth grade?

You cheat the marriage bed of the pleasure of sex between yourself and your wife. No wife yet? Then you rob yourself of such pleasure and rob her of a pure you in the future. It is just a matter of remaining pure, and masturbation robs purity.

Menial and inconsequential you say? Well, it's not either of those things.

If you want the Bible to spell everything out for you, I hardly think you would follow it anyway with such an attitude. God gives us the sense of right and wrong. Many ignore it in favour of their own sense of right and wrong. Somehow I believe that "if it feels good, do it" is the law of this land. So sad.
 
Upvote 0

Gukkor

Senior Veteran
Jun 14, 2006
2,137
128
Visit site
✟25,702.00
Faith
Christian Seeker
Marital Status
Single
You know, it just occurred to me, Floatingaxe, that perhaps people would take your points more seriously if you didn't treat them like children in your posts. Surely you can make your arguments against masturbation without throwing in the additions of "what is this? 9th grade?" or "do you really need to be told this," can't you? Just a thought.
 
Upvote 0

holo

former Christian
Dec 24, 2003
8,992
751
✟85,294.00
Country
Norway
Faith
Agnostic
Marital Status
Private
It's the honour due God to which I am referring. All our deeds are to be done for Him.
Bull.

You don't have sex for the glory of God, you have sex because you are a sexual being who enjoy sex, and so does your husband. Likewise, you don't scratch your back or eat dinner for the glory of God, but because you have an itch and you are hungry. You can choose to THANK and and honour God FOR those things, but don't try to convince me that you're DOING it for Him.

And you still haven't provided a speck of evidence as to exactly WHY masturbation should be harmful, least of all biblically. You just make up your own meaning of various words like "selfishness" and "fornication", which has NEVER meant masturbation to ANYONE, EVER, in ANY LANGUAGE.

It is obvious that YOU couldn't even get close to masturbation without falling into an abyss of perversion, but SPEAK FOR YOURSELF.
 
Upvote 0

Breetai

For I am not ashamed of the Gospel...
Dec 3, 2003
13,939
396
✟31,320.00
Faith
Lutheran
Marital Status
Private
Politics
US-Others
Bull.

You don't have sex for the glory of God, you have sex because you are a sexual being who enjoy sex, and so does your husband. Likewise, you don't scratch your back or eat dinner for the glory of God, but because you have an itch and you are hungry. You can choose to THANK and and honour God FOR those things, but don't try to convince me that you're DOING it for Him.

And you still haven't provided a speck of evidence as to exactly WHY masturbation should be harmful, least of all biblically. You just make up your own meaning of various words like "selfishness" and "fornication", which has NEVER meant masturbation to ANYONE, EVER, in ANY LANGUAGE.

It is obvious that YOU couldn't even get close to masturbation without falling into an abyss of perversion, but SPEAK FOR YOURSELF.
Stop with the personal accusations.
 
Upvote 0

Zecryphon

Well-Known Member
Aug 14, 2006
8,987
2,005
52
Phoenix, Arizona
✟19,186.00
Faith
Lutheran
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Constitution
True, yet... not all Christians agree on everything; do we?

Is that one ("self-gratification of the flesh) actually in the Bible, or is it an extra-Biblical teaching? You know, kind of like how Catholics believe in purgatory even though it's nowhere found in the Bible?

What's the definition of this, and how can you say it includes masturbation?

Masturbation is sleeping with someone other than your wife? All silliness of that idea aside, what if you aren't married? Adultery doesn't apply at all.

Potentially, but not always. I don't think most people cause physical damage to themselves when masturbating.

How so? There are no other partners involved. If one partner has a problem with it, then you could say it might be sinful. But, there are no extra-marital partners involved. As long as neither spouse has a problem with it, should they be unable to fulfill their partner, I fail to see any "cheating" going on here.

Even if these menial inconsequential things? How about the other Christians which disagree with your conclusions? Do you hear the Holy Spirit's voice, while you don't? How would you know that? We must check that's being said against the Bible, and what you said about the legalities of masturbation in this case are extra-Biblical.

Concerning the dangers of masturbation you are absolutely right and it is Biblical.
Fornication​
Hebrew,
זנה, zānāh = "to commit adultery," especially of the female, and less frequently of mere fornication, seldom of involuntary ravishment; also used figuratively in the sense of idolatry, the Jewish people being regarded as the spouse of Yahweh (2Ch_21:11; Isa_23:17; Eze_16:26). Once we find the derivative noun תּזנוּת, taznūth (Eze_16:29). In the New Testament, with both the literal and the figurative application, we find πορνεία, porneía, and πορνεύω, porneúō (Mat_5:32; Mat_15:19; Joh_8:41; Act_15:20; 1Co_5:1; 1Co_6:13, 1Co_6:18; 1Co_7:2; 1Co_10:8; 2Co_12:21; Gal_5:19; Eph_5:3; Col_3:5; 1Th_4:3; Rev_2:14, Rev_2:20, Rev_2:21; Rev_9:21; Rev_14:8; Rev_17:2, Rev_17:4). The intensive ἐκπορνεύω, ekporneúō = "to be utterly unchaste" is found in Jud_1:7. Every form of unchastity is included in the term "fornication."

From the International Standard Bible Encyclopedia.
 
Upvote 0

Zecryphon

Well-Known Member
Aug 14, 2006
8,987
2,005
52
Phoenix, Arizona
✟19,186.00
Faith
Lutheran
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Constitution
Stop with the personal accusations.
"Stop with the personal accusations."

He can't. Personal attacks are holo's preferred form of communication. He's got nothing else and his posts prove that fact repeatedly.
 
Upvote 0

Breetai

For I am not ashamed of the Gospel...
Dec 3, 2003
13,939
396
✟31,320.00
Faith
Lutheran
Marital Status
Private
Politics
US-Others
It's selfishness, plain and simple. Giving in to base desires is self-gratification.
So what? Do you ever eat at McDonald's or KFC? Do you ever watch a movie, or watch a programme on the TV? Did you listen to music for personal enjoyment? Do you ever stop to smell the roses? How is any of this sinful or wrong? You have not showed this, and you cannot!


Do you really need to be told this?
Do you really need to be told how hypocritical without Biblical basis what you just said is?
OK I am sure you must know that IF you are married, it is adultery.
HOW??? You CANNOT backup with you just said Biblically OR linguistically! It is not adultery! What you said is purely made-up by either you or by whoever is feeding this stuff to you. It is not a Biblical idea. What about mutual masturbation with your spouse? Is that sinful, too? How about oral sex? What about using a condom or even the rhythm method of birth control?
I will spell it out that sex--any kind of sex--outside of marriage is fornication, so, married or single, you commit it with yourself.
I will spell this out for you. E-I-S-O-G-E-S-I-S. That's eisogesis. It means to impose your own meaning, or personal bias, into scripture. This is exactly what you are doing here. N-O-W-H-E-R-E. That's nowhere in the Bible does it talk about masturbation or imply that it is fornication. If it did, then you'd be free to divorce your spouse just because they had a [wash my mouth][wash my mouth][wash my mouth][wash my mouth] (according to Matthew 19:9). That is utter silliness. Rubbish. That is exactly where your eisogesis leads to.

Self-abuse isn't always hurting yourself! Sheesh...you abuse yourself sexually when you touch--it is unnatural to manipulate one's sexual organs to achieve sexual gratification--that is abuse of the proper function of a body.
Tell us, what is your source for this? Did you just make it up?

What is this? Ninth grade?
Stop with this childishness.

You cheat the marriage bed of the pleasure of sex between yourself and your wife.
First of all, if both spouses agree that this is okay, it IS NOT CHEATING in the secular sense. Secondly, NOWHERE IN THE BIBLE is masturbation mentioned. You are taking your own thoughts, and trying to fit them into Christian doctrine. Well guess what, it's not Biblical. It goes into the same category as purgatory, baptizing for the dead and celestial marriage.

No wife yet?
Do you always assume things about others? STOP IT!

Then you rob yourself of such pleasure and rob her of a pure you in the future.
What in the blue heck are you going on about? Firstly, you're again assuming that not masturbating makes someone "pure." Just what do you consider "pure" anyway? Heck, if spouses know about their own bodies and what feels good, it may even enhance their sex life.

It is just a matter of remaining pure, and masturbation robs purity.
Will I go to purgatory if I touch?

Menial and inconsequential you say? Well, it's not either of those things.
We're discussing an issue that some Christians argue is sinful when the Bible says "no comment." This is not at all a major theological issue, and should not be made into one.

If you want the Bible to spell everything out for you, I hardly think you would follow it anyway with such an attitude.
By junior high school, or high school, or whatever grade 9 is where you are, many students had the sense to avoid personal attacks when trying to make and backup a claim. Are using such personal attacks "doing something for God"?

God gives us the sense of right and wrong.
So does the environment you were brought up in. Are you able to separate the two?
Many ignore it in favour of their own sense of right and wrong.
And many add to it with their own set of ideas and rules.

Somehow I believe that "if it feels good, do it" is the law of this land. So sad.
Agreed, but many people take what you said way too far. Some ultra conservative Christians forfeit things like cars, dancing, television, etc. because they are more worried about trivial parts of the law over the gospel of grace and forgiveness.
 
Upvote 0

Breetai

For I am not ashamed of the Gospel...
Dec 3, 2003
13,939
396
✟31,320.00
Faith
Lutheran
Marital Status
Private
Politics
US-Others
Fornication​
Hebrew,
זנה, zānāh = "to commit adultery," especially of the female, and less frequently of mere fornication, seldom of involuntary ravishment; also used figuratively in the sense of idolatry, the Jewish people being regarded as the spouse of Yahweh (2Ch_21:11; Isa_23:17; Eze_16:26). Once we find the derivative noun תּזנוּת, taznūth (Eze_16:29). In the New Testament, with both the literal and the figurative application, we find πορνεία, porneía, and πορνεύω, porneúō (Mat_5:32; Mat_15:19; Joh_8:41; Act_15:20; 1Co_5:1; 1Co_6:13, 1Co_6:18; 1Co_7:2; 1Co_10:8; 2Co_12:21; Gal_5:19; Eph_5:3; Col_3:5; 1Th_4:3; Rev_2:14, Rev_2:20, Rev_2:21; Rev_9:21; Rev_14:8; Rev_17:2, Rev_17:4). The intensive ἐκπορνεύω, ekporneúō = "to be utterly unchaste" is found in Jud_1:7. Every form of unchastity is included in the term "fornication."

From the International Standard Bible Encyclopedia.
Would this include masturbation?
 
Upvote 0

Floatingaxe

Well-Known Member
Apr 14, 2007
14,757
877
73
Ontario, Canada
✟22,726.00
Faith
Word of Faith
Marital Status
Married
Politics
CA-Conservatives
You know, it just occurred to me, Floatingaxe, that perhaps people would take your points more seriously if you didn't treat them like children in your posts. Surely you can make your arguments against masturbation without throwing in the additions of "what is this? 9th grade?" or "do you really need to be told this," can't you? Just a thought.


Oh people do take my words seriously. Hence the ridiculous arguing.

Anyhoo, my voice has been heard, and I am done with this. There is no convincing of foolish men. I am of the same mind as King Solomon about that.

Proverbs 10:23
Doing wrong is fun for a fool, but living wisely brings pleasure to the sensible.

Proverbs 16:22
Discretion is a life-giving fountain to those who possess it, but discipline is wasted on fools.

 
  • Like
Reactions: Nadiine
Upvote 0

Floatingaxe

Well-Known Member
Apr 14, 2007
14,757
877
73
Ontario, Canada
✟22,726.00
Faith
Word of Faith
Marital Status
Married
Politics
CA-Conservatives
Bull.

You don't have sex for the glory of God, you have sex because you are a sexual being who enjoy sex, and so does your husband. Likewise, you don't scratch your back or eat dinner for the glory of God, but because you have an itch and you are hungry. You can choose to THANK and and honour God FOR those things, but don't try to convince me that you're DOING it for Him.

And you still haven't provided a speck of evidence as to exactly WHY masturbation should be harmful, least of all biblically. You just make up your own meaning of various words like "selfishness" and "fornication", which has NEVER meant masturbation to ANYONE, EVER, in ANY LANGUAGE.

It is obvious that YOU couldn't even get close to masturbation without falling into an abyss of perversion, but SPEAK FOR YOURSELF.


Wrong. It is the same sin as fornication and adultery. You are fooling yourself, and worst of all, dragging down others with you by your forceful defense.

Proverbs 18:22
Fools have no interest in understanding;
they only want to air their own opinions.
 
Upvote 0

Nadiine

Well-Known Member
Apr 14, 2006
52,800
48,336
Obama: 53% deserve him ;)
✟292,219.00
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Republican
"Stop with the personal accusations."

He can't. Personal attacks are holo's preferred form of communication. He's got nothing else and his posts prove that fact repeatedly.

Just saying HI to Zecryphon & FloatingAxe!! I was away for 3 months and thought I'd peek my head in the door and see what's up around here again :holy: :wave:

I hope ya-awl are behaving! lol :p
:hug: :hug:
 
  • Like
Reactions: Floatingaxe
Upvote 0

Floatingaxe

Well-Known Member
Apr 14, 2007
14,757
877
73
Ontario, Canada
✟22,726.00
Faith
Word of Faith
Marital Status
Married
Politics
CA-Conservatives
Floatingaxe's views are just too off base for me to take seriously anymore. The stuff she is saying in this thread...


The stuff you say in defense is not to be taken seriously in any way by those who seek after God in their daily lives.

Serving God fully doesn't leave people with the kind of dead time on one's hands to even entertain the notion to touch. God's ways are so much higher than man's...His standards are also. Serving Him takes us into territory and a kind of busy-ness that doesn't lend to auto-arousal and masturbation...our thoughts are to be held captive to the obedience of Christ.

2 Corinthians 10:5
casting down arguments and every high thing that exalts itself against the knowledge of God, bringing every thought into captivity to the obedience of Christ,


Sexual thoughts that accompany and generate this behaviour are sin, and constitute adultery, in God's opinion. You don't like it, that's clear. But it has nothing to do with me...it is obstinacy, plainly.
 
Upvote 0

Floatingaxe

Well-Known Member
Apr 14, 2007
14,757
877
73
Ontario, Canada
✟22,726.00
Faith
Word of Faith
Marital Status
Married
Politics
CA-Conservatives
Alright, alright, if we've no points left to throw out besides "floatingaxe is mean" and "you guys are all immature and stubborn," how about we just call it a thread and end the discussion? It seems clear to me that both sides are running out of steam.


Great idea.


However, I am not mean. Jesus is Lord.
 
Upvote 0

Dyin2live

Active Member
Aug 26, 2006
269
9
33
California
✟22,947.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Single
No one really knows if masturbation is rite or wrong. The Bible never mentions it. Im sorry but, you can't call masturbation fornication (lol that rhymed). These are to different things. Fornication involves another person, and masturbation does not. Is masturbation a sin? I don't know.
But for me personally I would like to give it up, it doesn't feel rite for me based on my convictions. If it feels rite for you, then you decide.
 
Upvote 0

Floatingaxe

Well-Known Member
Apr 14, 2007
14,757
877
73
Ontario, Canada
✟22,726.00
Faith
Word of Faith
Marital Status
Married
Politics
CA-Conservatives
No one really knows if masturbation is rite or wrong. The Bible never mentions it. Im sorry but, you can't call masturbation fornication (lol that rhymed). These are to different things. Fornication involves another person, and masturbation does not. Is masturbation a sin? I don't know.
But for me personally I would like to give it up, it doesn't feel rite for me based on my convictions. If it feels rite for you, then you decide.


EVERYONE can know for certain what is right and what is wrong in ANY area of life. Where one is unsure, he needs to ask the Father, and God will reveal it to him. It is for us to know!

Yes, it is fornication. And self abuse. One should have enough fear of God and love and respect for oneself to be able to refrain from such a base act.

May God bless you and keep you as you seek His will for your life. It is by Hs strength that we live in those difficult areas. God is good and He is there beside you to help you. Surrender to His ways of righteousness and be blessed and find yourself growing in God! Amen!
 
Upvote 0
Status
Not open for further replies.