No, i never said anything like that. I'm saying that it is understandable when a person wants to die because he/she is under extreme circumstances. They are suffering in other words.
But why no? Now, you also made yourself look very interesting by "the mind your own business" part. If someone came to you, being depressed by these same circumstances you are going to tell him it's up to you if you want to die from it because its none of your business? I bet even other atheists out there would look at your response as a neg on you.
and yet again you can't conceive or understand how your "god doesn't exist" line is completely useless here. It doesn't matter if you think God doesn't exist or not, the person who wants to die does.
Also, the counter analogy i gave of "100% proof of God" flew over your head. The point is that no matter if he is real or not, hating your life and wanting to die all because of wanting to be with him is generally wrong. It's irrelevant, get over it and stop using that as an argument because it makes you look illiterate.
You really do not understand what you are reading at all, its just not my last sentence, its as if you are just trying to pry in the "God does not exist" point for an atheist ego-sooth.
Wow, this is fun. Ahem. You said I took your words out of context. That is an accusation that I take seriously. Here are your words, again:
So let me get this straight, when a person is suffering that badly, to the point that death is the best release of that pain, that isn't a category of an extreme circumstance of suffering?
Please show how I (quoting you) took your words out of context. Please clarify your position on the spectrum of suffering. Paper cuts to terminal diseases. Is one not allowed to end their life if they have a paper cut but on is allowed if they have a painful disease. You have not stated your position on this point.
I'm sure there were a couple of typo's and weird grammar here, but you said:
But why no? Now, you also made yourself look very interesting by "the mind your own business" part. If someone came to you, being depressed by these same circumstances you are going to tell him it's up to you if you want to die from it because its none of your business? I bet even other atheists out there would look at your response as a neg on you.
Um, yeah. I stand on my position. I don't care (and I'd like to be very clear here) what you think other atheists think. You don't get to say what other people think. I don't live my life according to what others believe, and I don't think anyone should. Again, mind your own business. To be clear - as you have not been - I would not advise anyone to take their life. I would also not advise anyone not to take their own life. Mind your own business.
My favorite part is this:
and yet again you can't conceive or understand how your "god doesn't exist" line is completely useless here. It doesn't matter if you think God doesn't exist or not, the person who wants to die does.
I've never stated that "god does not exist". I have asked questions related to the existence of a god. And, this is very important, it absolutely matters if a god exists. If one exists, I'd like to know. If one does not exist - and, you really have not been honest here - any time spent worshiping / doing god stuff absolutely must be time wasted. Again, come on, just be honest. I thought that lying was one of your sins.
I understand what an analogy is, but I've never heard yet of a counter analogy:
Also, the counter analogy i gave of "100% proof of God" flew over your head. The point is that no matter if he is real or not, hating your life and wanting to die all because of wanting to be with him is generally wrong. It's irrelevant, get over it and stop using that as an argument because it makes you look illiterate.
Its so weird. You keep saying that whether god is real or not, blah, blah, blah. Not realizing that REAL or NOT REAL is the important part. And, the hating your life part - what are you talking about? Can you provide examples of people who hate their lives and want to die to be with "the lord"? It seems like you are just pulling this out of your butt. You referenced 100% proof of god but provided none. 0%. So, I'll ignore that part
The part that I hoped you would clarify was here:
Here is a added scenario to what you put in so you can understand why it is irrelevant.. lets say God is proven to exist 100%, does that make wanting to die and hating your life here all because you want to be with him - right?
Dude, this is frustrating. Here is the math, as I see it: God may / may not exist => Person hates their life => Person wants to be with god => Person is wrong to kill them self to be with god. Do I have the "math" right? Thanks for your replies, but I sure would appreciate it if you would answer the direct questions that I've asked. I think it would speed things up. Cheers.
Again, we are talking about people possibly wanting to die to be with "the lord".