• Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.

How does one come to believe something?

Arsenios

Russian Orthodox Winter Baptism, Valaam Monastery,
Site Supporter
Dec 25, 2015
2,829
982
Washington
✟196,120.00
Gender
Male
Faith
Eastern Orthodox
Marital Status
Private
Politics
US-Constitution
I have no idea what you're talking about.

Good evidence...
Publicly reproducible...
Scientifically approved...
Good, solid, materialistic, tangible, observable evidence...

My argument is that God is beyond all that...
That such evidence is shallow and superficial and meaningless...

Arsenios
 
Upvote 0

Arsenios

Russian Orthodox Winter Baptism, Valaam Monastery,
Site Supporter
Dec 25, 2015
2,829
982
Washington
✟196,120.00
Gender
Male
Faith
Eastern Orthodox
Marital Status
Private
Politics
US-Constitution
You believe it on personal faith then, correct?

I am perhaps the most faithless person I know...
I was an atheist for my first 36 years of life...
So no, it is not personal faith at all...
Any more than you setting your alarm is a matter of personal faith...
It is simply a matter of paying inward attention...

Arsenios
 
Upvote 0

ScottA

Author: Walking Like Einstein
Site Supporter
Feb 24, 2011
4,309
657
✟78,847.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
Nah, I'm more interested in your evidence, since you're making the positive claim that a god exists.

So, back to you.

Or are you stalling?
No, he was making the point, that your insistence upon evidence that does not pertain to the subject...is illogical. He knows that in order for you to begin to understand, you have to start somewhere. But your insistence upon controlling the direction of questioning, is the same as starting nowhere, and going nowhere.

You get no satisfactory answers, because you have limited things - not to include the very thing you are asking about. You may as well ask what time it is, and then say, "I don't believe you, and watches, clocks, and other timepieces are not acceptable." That's ridiculous. Why even ask?
 
Upvote 0

Arsenios

Russian Orthodox Winter Baptism, Valaam Monastery,
Site Supporter
Dec 25, 2015
2,829
982
Washington
✟196,120.00
Gender
Male
Faith
Eastern Orthodox
Marital Status
Private
Politics
US-Constitution
No, he was making the point, that your insistence upon evidence that does not pertain to the subject...is illogical. He knows that in order for you to begin to understand, you have to start somewhere. But your insistence upon controlling the direction of questioning, is the same as starting nowhere, and going nowhere.

You get no satisfactory answers, because you have limited things - not to include the very thing you are asking about. You may as well ask what time it is, and then say, "I don't believe you, and watches, clocks, and other timepieces are not acceptable." That's ridiculous. Why even ask?

Goodness - I had missed this post by TNT. Thank-you for so clearly answering it...

Insisting on material proofs of spiritual matters is indeed oxymoronic...

And then thinking that you have refuted a spiritual claim by material means continues the blunder...

TNT claims to be a seeker, and means by this that he is open to material proofs of spiritual matters...

I am only telling him [or her?] that spiritual matters are not materially discerned...

No rocket science here...

Arsenios
 
  • Like
Reactions: ScottA
Upvote 0

ToddNotTodd

Iconoclast
Feb 17, 2004
7,787
3,884
✟274,996.00
Faith
Seeker
Marital Status
Married
Goodness - I had missed this post by TNT. Thank-you for so clearly answering it...

Insisting on material proofs of spiritual matters is indeed oxymoronic...

And then thinking that you have refuted a spiritual claim by material means continues the blunder...

TNT claims to be a seeker, and means by this that he is open to material proofs of spiritual matters...

I am only telling him [or her?] that spiritual matters are not materially discerned...

No rocket science here...

Arsenios

So the upshot of all this is that you have no good evidence that you can share.

So why post? You're not going to convince any non-theist here that any unsubstantiated claim you make is any different than any other unsubstantiated claim.

At the end of the day you're simply proselytizing.
 
Upvote 0

Arsenios

Russian Orthodox Winter Baptism, Valaam Monastery,
Site Supporter
Dec 25, 2015
2,829
982
Washington
✟196,120.00
Gender
Male
Faith
Eastern Orthodox
Marital Status
Private
Politics
US-Constitution
So the upshot of all this is that you have no good evidence that you can share.

So why post? You're not going to convince any non-theist here that any unsubstantiated claim you make is any different than any other unsubstantiated claim.

At the end of the day you're simply proselytizing.

My brother, you do not know substantiation...
You are wearing materialistic blinders...
Which cannot even account for mind...
When death comes, your material life will end...

Your future is bleak and dismal...
Material goods and psycho-social approvals...
Then mental disintegration??
Nihilism has nothing to recommend it...

And nothing has indeed been recommending it for a long time now...

Arsenios
 
Upvote 0

ToddNotTodd

Iconoclast
Feb 17, 2004
7,787
3,884
✟274,996.00
Faith
Seeker
Marital Status
Married
My brother, you do not know substantiation...
You are wearing materialistic blinders...
Which cannot even account for mind...
When death comes, your material life will end...

Your future is bleak and dismal...
Material goods and psycho-social approvals...
Then mental disintegration??
Nihilism has nothing to recommend it...

And nothing has indeed been recommending it for a long time now...

Arsenios

Again... unsubstantiated. I'd like to see you in a discussion with someone who believes in a completely different unsubstantiated god.

How would such a thing end? It would just be dueling unsubstantiated claims back and forth.

Getting no one... no where...
 
Upvote 0

Arsenios

Russian Orthodox Winter Baptism, Valaam Monastery,
Site Supporter
Dec 25, 2015
2,829
982
Washington
✟196,120.00
Gender
Male
Faith
Eastern Orthodox
Marital Status
Private
Politics
US-Constitution
Again... unsubstantiated.

Getting no one... no where...

You can only give what you have to give...
Billiard balls that vanish at death...
NO one, and NO where...
Are perfect nihilistic responses to all spiritual matters...
Nothing begets nothing...

Your repetitions signal the swirl of the argument...
So I think we are done...
No more round and round...

Thank-you for conversing with me...
God bless you in your walk...

Arsenios
 
Upvote 0

Arsenios

Russian Orthodox Winter Baptism, Valaam Monastery,
Site Supporter
Dec 25, 2015
2,829
982
Washington
✟196,120.00
Gender
Male
Faith
Eastern Orthodox
Marital Status
Private
Politics
US-Constitution
In response to the OP, coming to faith or belief in anything normally comes by experience(s)...
Has ANYone EVER even come to faith in material objects in any other way???
The question is: "What experiences?"
Denial of OPE's* is not helpful.

Arsenios

*Other People's Experience
 
Upvote 0

bhsmte

Newbie
Apr 26, 2013
52,761
11,792
✟254,941.00
Faith
Atheist
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Others
I am perhaps the most faithless person I know...
I was an atheist for my first 36 years of life...
So no, it is not personal faith at all...
Any more than you setting your alarm is a matter of personal faith...
It is simply a matter of paying inward attention...

Arsenios

If it isnt personal faith, what is it based on?
 
Upvote 0

ScottA

Author: Walking Like Einstein
Site Supporter
Feb 24, 2011
4,309
657
✟78,847.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
So the upshot of all this is that you have no good evidence that you can share.

So why post? You're not going to convince any non-theist here that any unsubstantiated claim you make is any different than any other unsubstantiated claim.

At the end of the day you're simply proselytizing.
No, in fact all we do have...is "good evidence" - that is the point that we have tried to make.

What you have described, is not "good evidence", but bad. Good evidence would pertain to the subject. But if you limit your involvement to bad evidence that does not pertain to the subject...then you get no evidence at all. So...we have eternally more good evidence than you can even imagine, but you do not recognize it.

And it has been said many times, we are not here to "convince", we are here to share something you know nothing of, and might like to hear. But if you stop your ears at anything beyond your own understanding, your own world...that is not our limitation, but yours. It is you who are acting against you ever attaining "any good evidence."
 
  • Like
Reactions: Arsenios
Upvote 0

ScottA

Author: Walking Like Einstein
Site Supporter
Feb 24, 2011
4,309
657
✟78,847.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
In response to the OP, coming to faith or belief in anything normally comes by experience(s)...
Has ANYone EVER even come to faith in material objects in any other way???
The question is: "What experiences?"
Denial of OPE's* is not helpful.

Arsenios

*Other People's Experience
Yes...keeping the OP in focus is a good idea.

We come to "believe" something [not] in the way we come to "know" something. And most of the arguments here are really asking, "How do you "know" what you "believe" is true?

That is two (different) questions.

Question #1 - We come to believe something [not] by "substantiating" or "proving" it with evidence, nor even by being "convinced." We come to believe something, by first believing there is something more than we "know." That is where the personal "experience" comes in. When what we experience falls short and we know that we have not seen all there is to see - we in fact reverse our thinking to "know" there is something more. But that "knowing" is not the "knowing" that substantiates what we might otherwise "believe" - not at all.

The other component to all of what we might like to "know", but only "believe"...is that there are those who actually do "know." This component has been explained, as being by design: a plan of timed partial revelations leading to a final complete revelation of all things. These partial revelations personally happened to real people, and they were share then, and eventually written down. Similar accounts of "knowing" have continued down through all of history.

But, again, if all that one "experiences" in the world fulfills all, without a hint of "something more" - then, you have no reason to be here. And if your reason is just to campaign against the very idea of "something more"...then, what you don't realize, is that you are being used.

Question #2 - We come to "know" what is true, much like anything is known - by overwhelming evidence. Except, evidence of "something more" is not something less, it's something more - something beyond the something less you once were limited to.

So, when I say, "I know", it is because I have been beyond the horizon of this world. And yet another will say, "I know, because God met me where I was, and made himself known to me by circumstance - things that would not naturally happen."

And yet, to "know" is not to "believe", and to "believe" is not to "know."
 
Upvote 0

ToddNotTodd

Iconoclast
Feb 17, 2004
7,787
3,884
✟274,996.00
Faith
Seeker
Marital Status
Married
No, in fact all we do have...is "good evidence" - that is the point that we have tried to make.

What you have described, is not "good evidence", but bad. Good evidence would pertain to the subject. But if you limit your involvement to bad evidence that does not pertain to the subject...then you get no evidence at all. So...we have eternally more good evidence than you can even imagine, but you do not recognize it.

And it has been said many times, we are not here to "convince", we are here to share something you know nothing of, and might like to hear. But if you stop your ears at anything beyond your own understanding, your own world...that is not our limitation, but yours. It is you who are acting against you ever attaining "any good evidence."

In your unsubstantiated opinion...
 
Upvote 0

Arsenios

Russian Orthodox Winter Baptism, Valaam Monastery,
Site Supporter
Dec 25, 2015
2,829
982
Washington
✟196,120.00
Gender
Male
Faith
Eastern Orthodox
Marital Status
Private
Politics
US-Constitution
In your unsubstantiated opinion...

Enjoy your substantial billiards...

They are not the meaning of life...

This life is not about this life...

Arsenios
 
Upvote 0