Elman, I would sincerely like to ask you a question - perhaps I should start a new thread for it, perhaps not.
You quite clearly speak English, do you not?
What country did you grow up in?
USA
Upvote
0
Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.
Elman, I would sincerely like to ask you a question - perhaps I should start a new thread for it, perhaps not.
You quite clearly speak English, do you not?
What country did you grow up in?
Elman, I think what you're doing here is merging two concepts.
One of which is the world from the noumenal view - God's view, if you like.
He sees the future, past and present all together. That means that the script of the world is already written TO HIM. Meaning, effectively, that you are only performing this script as you go along.
However, you are not God. You experience the world from the phenomenal view - the individual, unaware of the future, and unable to see the past. (you can only remember it)
Now, to you and those around you - who cannot predict nor know the future or your actions - you are free.
Essentially, what you are saying is, "Even though God knows everything I will ever do, I am still unaware of it - therefore I am free."
But, you must remember, although the fact that God knows what you will do, it doesn't affect your life.
And, equally, although you don't know what you will do, it doesn't mean that your "free-will" is not any more than an illusion.
Then i recant my statement and replace it with the god situation of religion irrelevent, the moralities and ethicalities that concern us though, intrigue me.Then religion is quite relevant to your quest for interesting conversation.
From what I've seen, you seem a bit like I was many years ago. I'm not sure if that's a good thing or not.Determined in some beliefs, but still curious and open. It's the degree and manner of denial that betrays oneself. Look at some of the more vitriolic atheists' conversations, and look at some of the more moderate atheists' conversations. Look for the motives behind their arguments. =)
Spot on. If there is no god, and nature is the only driving "force", then nature hath condemned us to existence.As far as I'm concerned, the only thing that can readily be supported is that we have the illusion of free will, caused by brain function. If certain animals have the requisite brain function, they would also have the illusion of free will, but it seems to require higher brain function than other animals have.
Define "know".I know a bit of french, and I've been trying to learn a bit of pali (a dead language).
Why not?why would god create someone and then allow them to be tempted into sin so that they go to hell?
can god create a stone so large that he can't lift it?
why would god create someone and then allow them to be tempted into sin so that they go to hell?
How do you know?There is no pain after death. There is only life after death for some who respond to the love of God with love.
can god create a stone so large that he can't lift it?
Why not?
Testing God against Himself is a flawed test.
first are you implying that i respond to the love of god without love? if so that's very judgmental. you've absolutely no knowledge of my relationship with god. second, you seem to only think that because the bible and your church says it. can you yourself prove the bible is real or do you need other's scientific data? or do you believe in it because it says it is? in which case would be quite irrational. surely you must believe in it based on faith? but even so, faith without any logical basis is just stupid. no?There is no pain after death. There is only life after death for some who respond to the love of God with love.
The script God sees is one I helped to write. That means I have the ability to respond to God and to others with love or with hate. God knowing what I am going to do does not remove the fact that I am the one who decided which to do, not God.
I was not raised speaking FrenchSo why isn't French,(for example) your first language?
.
(this will lead on somewhere)
Quote:
Originally Posted by elman![]()
The script God sees is one I helped to write. That means I have the ability to respond to God and to others with love or with hate. God knowing what I am going to do does not remove the fact that I am the one who decided which to do, not God.
So you're saying, by "the script which God sees is one I helped to create" that God infact is just a passive observer - and that you're the main writer of this script!
So, in actual fact, it is humanity that has the power, and not God!
Opinions, opinions.The Creator is loving.