Did you even read what I said. If a man can't keep an open heart toward God, then he is in rebellion, which is witchcraft, he is a double minded man, a luke warm man.
Upvote
0
Originally posted by SnuP
Did you even read what I said. If a man can't keep an open heart toward God, then he is in rebellion, which is witchcraft, he is a double minded man, a luke warm man.
Hi, Dave! Your thoughts are mirrored in Hebrews 10: "How much severer punishment do you think he will deserve who has trampled underfoot the Son of God and has regarded as unclean the blood of the covenant by which he was sanctified, and has insulted the Spirit of grace?"By saying we can lose our salvation, I feel that you are making a mockery of Christ's blood!
Originally posted by Ben johnson
What did you think of my post in this thread, post #135? About two dozen Scripture references. Anything I'm not understanding or that I'm missing?
God bless you guys!!!
I worry WAY more about people who are outside of Christ than people who are in, namely non believers. our passion should be more for the lost than for professing christians.
Originally posted by Miss Shelby
I agree with you that we are mandated to witness to the lost... one of our concerns as Christians should certainly be to lead lost souls to Christ.
I know of a person on another messageboard who is a Calvinist Christian. I don't know how long she has been a believer, but for the last 2 years I have seen her on messageboards professing a belief in Christ.
Recently though, has been questioning the authenticity of the Bible and also thinks that Judaism is a false religion..and thinks that Christianity might be bogus. I don't know why she is having doubts, but she point blank said that if she was one of the elect she didn't have to worry because God would call her back. It's people like that who I fear for. I don't think that God is under an obligation to come and get her if she decides to walk away.
Michelle
Originally posted by DaveKerwin
The prodigal son might shed some light. Though the son walked away from his father, he was still his son. Though his son sinned against him, he was still his son. And what was the father's responce upon the son's return? It was a celebration. You may say that the sonship was a result of his return. I disagree with that because the sonship was always there, just not the fellowship. Walking away did not take away his sonship, it just hindered that boy's life. If that lady decides to walk away, it does not nullify her from Grace. I know for myself, when I was in sin, I knew the whole time who God was, and that I was doing wrong. But I needed a wake up call, which I got. And I came back stronger than ever.
Let us remember that God is the judge, he is on the throne. We will never know for sure if a person's salvation can be lost. Based on the scripture that we both read, we come to different conclusions. Fine, there is room for that. Let us at least agree that salvation is from Christ alone!
And if it is true that it is of more importance to spread the gospel to non-believers, then where are the debates about that ?
Perhaps; but most of the NT is focused not on salvation, but on growth. As Hebrews 6 says, "Therefore leaving the elementary teaching about the Messiah, let us press on to maturity, not laying again a foundation of repentance from dead works and of faith toward God..." This cuts to the nature of our salvation. One who holds to Carnal Christianity, simply prays "The Sinner's Prayer"---and he believes that his salvation is secure. He can cheerully return home and place God up on a shelf next to the Christmas decorations, and then get about the REAL business of life. If that includes occasionally getting drunk or even sleeping with a couple of girlfriends, what of it? He's still the Father's SON, isn't he? Even if he's not in close FELLOWSHIP with God, he still has SAVED-RELATIONSHIP, just-like-the-Prodigal-son, RIGHT? Every Sunday, well, every Sunday morning, he goes to church and sings and listens to the preacher, and then gives nary-a-thought about God the rest of the week.side note : I worry WAY more about people who are outside of Christ than people who are in, namely non believers. our passion should be more for the lost than for professing christians.
Format? Was it somehow formatted illegibly? I don't think re-posting it is necessary---are you game to simply go back a page? First I defined our salvation as not a work by us, but a work by God---salvation is by receiving Christ. I showed that salvation is abiding in Christ---and cited 2Jn1:7-9 which warns us to watch ourselves, about the decievers, for if we go too far and not abide in the teachings of Christ, we HAVE NOT GOD---clear warning against falling-from-salvation.that was a long post Ben, if you want a reply then please post again, and ask specific questions directed to me. maybe I am the only one that is distracted by its length and format.
Originally posted by DaveKerwin
witchcraft? I will ignore that one.
I am double minded sometimes, I rebel sometimes, I am luke warm sometimes. Guess what, so are you. So is everyone. We are all sinners. There is no one righteous on their own merit. Though we are christians, we still sin. RIGHT? I have never met a person that became a christian and no longer struggled with sin. Our righteousness was given to us for the very reason that we were unable to get it ourselves. If we were unable to get it in the first place, then we will be unable to maintain it. We are not our own!! We belong to God, we were bought at a price. The price was the blood of Jesus Christ. We no longer belong to ourselves. By saying we can lose our salvation, I feel that you are making a mockery of Christ's blood!
Snup, I agree with you completely---I do not find anything in the Bible that says "God will trample on your will". They ("Predestined-Election" proponents) cite Ezk36, that God "removes their stone-hearts and replaces them with hearts-of-flesh". I counter this by reading the identical passage in Ezk11, where after that passage he writes: "But for those who go after abominations and detestable things, I will bring their conduct down on their heads"---unilateral heart-change from GOD? Hardly. Obviously He changes the hearts of those who turn to Him---and those who prefer abominations and detestable things pay the price.if you shut up your heart to what God is saying and shut God out then He cannot save you less He trample on your will and force salvation upon you. There is no work here.
Originally posted by Ben johnson
Fellowship is salvation. "He who HAS the Son, HAS THE LIFE. He who has not the Son of God has not the life. I write this that you ...may KNOW you have eternal life." 1Jn5:12-13 And yet, John writes: "Many deceivers and antichrists have gone out into the world. WATCH YOURSELVES that you might not LOSE what you have GAINED. Anyone who GOES TOO FAR, and does not ABIDE in the teachings of Christ, has not God!" (2:1:7-9) Can it be clearer? We are saved by CHRIST, IN US.
...but He is IN us at OUR DISCRETION! It is up to US to receive Him, AND to abide in Him.
"Abide in ME, and I (will) abide in you. Anyone who does NOT abide in Me is cut off and ...cast into the fire." John15:6 Abiding is salvation! 1Jn4:15-16
No "limited atonement", no "divine-installed-salvation", no "selected election". Being saved is "receiving Christ, and abiding IN Him". It is possible to disbelieve, hardened by the deceitfulness of sin and fall away from the living God (Heb3:1-14), to fall away from Christ (Gal5:4), to wander from the truth and perish (James 5:19-20), to fall away from the faith (1Tim4:1), to be taken captive by philosophy and empty deception (Col2:8), to reject faith and suffer shipwreck in regard to faith (1Tim1:19), to have ESCAPED through SAVED KNOWLEDGE but to TURN AWAY from Jesus and again become entangled in world's defilements and overcome (2Pet2:20-22), on and on and on. Where is the Scripture that says "you cannot become unsaved"? There is not one.
Originally posted by Ben johnson
Perhaps; but most of the NT is focused not on salvation, but on growth. As Hebrews 6 says, "Therefore leaving the elementary teaching about the Messiah, let us press on to maturity, not laying again a foundation of repentance from dead works and of faith toward God..." This cuts to the nature of our salvation. One who holds to Carnal Christianity, simply prays "The Sinner's Prayer"---and he believes that his salvation is secure. He can cheerully return home and place God up on a shelf next to the Christmas decorations, and then get about the REAL business of life. If that includes occasionally getting drunk or even sleeping with a couple of girlfriends, what of it? He's still the Father's SON, isn't he? Even if he's not in close FELLOWSHIP with God, he still has SAVED-RELATIONSHIP, just-like-the-Prodigal-son, RIGHT? Every Sunday, well, every Sunday morning, he goes to church and sings and listens to the preacher, and then gives nary-a-thought about God the rest of the week.
...if the nature of our salvation is FELLOWSHIP, then diligence and perseverance becomes more than casual, off-stage, in-the-wings-concepts---nay, they become central and critical to our approach. If salvation can be forfeit, then every moment of our ever day becomes colored quite differently, do they not?
I showed that salvation is abiding in Christ---and cited 2Jn1:7-9 which warns us to watch ourselves, about the decievers, for if we go too far and not abide in the teachings of Christ, we HAVE NOT GOD---clear warning against falling-from-salvation.
I countered two verses offered, first: "nothing can separate us from His love", by demonstrating that He loved us BEFORE we were saved and and He will still love us if we fall away and perish. The second, "no one will SNATCH us from His hand", I cited the Greek that "snatch" is "harpazo", which means "forcibly remove"---which does not refute the premise that salvation can be freely forsaken.
Romans 5:17-18 ...
Tell me---do you really believe that Jesus meant to convey that the son was still saved, while he was in the other country, living immorally and loose? Do you know the Greek words for, "alive again"? He was dead---vs 24,32---do you believe Jesus was speaking of one who was dead-but-still-SAVED?
Doesn't "dead", mean dead spiritually? Please look up the Greek for "alive again", and "dead", and tell me if you really think that somehow Jesus intended to tell a story of someone who "squandered his inheritance on wine and women and loose living", but-was-still-saved?
If that son-in-the-parable, had DIED in the far land, what would his eternal destiny have been? Can an immoral man enter Heaven? The earthly father symbolized the Heavenly father. The son's leaving, symbolized leaving God. Loose-living in the parable symbolized loose living. His returning home symbolized returning-to-God. Any argument on this?
"I tell you, there is more joy in HEAVEN over one sinner who repents, than over ninety-nine righteous persons who need no repentance." Lk15:7
Before the prodigal son repented, while he was in the far land, do you say that he was saved? Can one be UNREPENTANT-AND-SAVED?
Luke13:3...
Originally posted by SnuP
Well it is obvious that you don't understand my post. I talk about matters of the heart, and you say that I'm talking about works.
Keeping an open heart toward God has nothing to do with works.
Keeping an open heart toward God has nothing to do with works.
Keeping an open heart toward God has nothing to do with works.
It's a matter of having a heart open to recieve from God what ever He choses to give or say. If you are double minded in this then I fear for your salvation. But I am pretty confident that you are not double minded concerning your heart toward God. I believe that regardless of your past experiences with salvation, that if you shut up your heart to what God is saying and shut God out then He cannot save you less He trample on your will and force salvation upon you. (This God would never do because then the gift would not be free and it would not be an act of love but rather of dictatorship.) There is no works here. If you see works involved in what I have posted then you are fanticising out of your own fears.
This is a matter of heart not flesh or works.
Originally posted by SnuP
What good is salvation if you never develope a relationship with your creator. Thats the whole point of salvation. Salvation is the starting point in your relationship, not the ending point. If you never go beyound salvation then you have failed to run the race and you forfet the prize. You are like a branch that produces no fruit and is fit only for the fire. Sorry, but Jesus said that last one.
Originally posted by Ben johnson
Yet for all of my words, no refutation is offered to all of the verses I cite to destroy the belief of "OSAS". We are saved by believing, by receiving Christ, be abiding in Him, by fellowshipping with Him and with God and with the Spirit, indwelt by Christ and the Spirit, by walking in the Spirit and not in the flesh---all of these things are simply facets of the concept of "BORN-AGAIN".
If salvation is FELLOWSHIP (and it is---1Jn1:3-6), then KEEPING OURSELVES IN THE LOVE OF GOD (Jn21) is absolutely a choice, daily.
What am I doing wrong in the debates? Why can I not convince them? Or if I am wrong, why can they not convince me? I cite Scripture---if I am wrong, I welcome the instruction---Scripturally. But if the Scriptures we present, cannot be refuted (in their presentation), can "OSAS" belief stand?
Originally posted by DaveKerwin
So now our salvation can be lost by how we feel in our heart? I thought perseverence was the biggie on maintainings salvation. I will tell my friend who smokes weed to just feel right about God in his heart and don't worry about his works. I will tell him to just keep an open heart to God and leave it at that. What do you think ?
Don't fear for my salvation, you have enough fear in your life.
Originally posted by DaveKerwin
No one who knows God would agree with the attitudes in your post.
Use me as an example. I believe salvation cannot be lost. Please restate your post directed at me, and make every accusation you can. Seriously. If you feel a person who believes in OSAS has the attitudes you just described, then lets find out by using me as an example. So go ahead, ask and accuse.