Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.
Jesus died to save us from death that we deserved.
There are no transitional states of being within heaven, you just are, that is, it is a nexus where time is not part of the equation of existence.
Eternity is a timeless nexus, where time has no meaning. If time is none existent, then there are no transitional states that would suggest a time derived formula for existence.
If there is no transitional time states in heaven,
then how you entered into heaven, as an innocent and pure child of God/Light, then that is how you will remain within heaven, within the blissful eternity of LOVE.
You have unwittingly rebutted your own rebuttal and I am rather amused by it
Neither the serpent nor the earthly conditions would be there, because as according to my reply to your first quote, timeless eternity isn't transient of states and so you have a totally different existence that isn't played out in time.
Jesus said you will not be given into marriage in heaven, for you will be like the angels in heaven.
yes, the sacrifice, for undeserving sinners to be made right with God and receive eternal life, was indeed for God's glory in displaying His love for the world as romans 9 states.
you actually made a handful of conclusions about God's character and motives in your OP.
Life, being here on earth is a privilege.
One who doesn't ...well you don't want the answer to that.
Christ said ...
“Heaven and earth shall pass away: but my words shall not pass away.”
Matthew 24:35
Mark 13:31
Luke 21:33
You have a choice. Believe in any doctrine.
The ones responsible for leading you into believing their doctrine will be here and then won't.
The words spoken by Christ whose earthly name is Jesus, will remain. The truth, He spoke i.e words given to Him by The Father to give to us will out live, you, your children, your children's children and any other doctrine that doesn't direct you to the Gospels.
Heaven and earth shall pass away: but my words shall not pass away.”
Matthew 24:35
Mark 13:31
Luke 21:33
Your Alli
Very interesting philosophical question.
However, there is no God, right? So, it matters not.
Questions such as this are not going to convince you of the existence of God. They are more a question as to why you should accept the rules of God.
The discussion about such things is only justifiable if you believed there was a God.
If you did believe that there was a God and He was he all powerful and infinitely more intelligent than you, then you would accept that there are things that will only be answered when we meet Him face to face.
But, as you have designated yourself as an Atheist, the answers to your inquiry are wasted.
Heaven will have the only things that can ultimate satisfy the human soul forever... discovering and knowing an invite God more and more... we were made for that.. anything else will be pretty boring after a million years but God is endless and there will always be new mountains of discovery in Him and deeper oceans of blessing in Him
Judeo-Christianity attempts to explain not only how we are here, but also why (the purpose of existence). Yet if we examine the Christian worldview, it's clear that our existence on earth is pointless.When you are in heaven (or on the new earth... Christian lingo is inconsistent here), will you have free will? As far as I understand it, even Calvanists believe in free will, that is, they believe that one can make a choice free of coercion. My understanding is that you will have free will in heaven but no desire to sin. Why didn't God create us like that to begin with?* If Christians prefer to be in heaven, and if God would've preferred to not die on the cross, then what is the actual point of the universe's existence? In trying to explain it, Christianity renders it moot.If you have to resort to confusion to explain our purpose on earth, please don't even bother posting. If you post here to admit that you don't know our purpose or what it could possibly be, I'll admire your honesty (ask yourself the follow-up question: why believe in something by faith which cannot explain anything even if it is granted to be true?). If you say we exist for God's glory, his good pleasure, or for some other idea that does something for God and nothing for you, then face the fact that Jesus died for his own purposes and that it wasn't for you (this idea is presumably heretical as it contradicts John 3:16, the most famous passage in the entire Bible). If God loves us, why not do what's best for us instead of putting us on this earth?*Please don't tell me that he already did so with Adam and Eve; if Adam and Eve were created IN THE SAME STATE that you will be in, then there will be a fall in heaven.Possible counter argument:Adam and Eve were deceived by the serpent, and there will be no serpent in heaven.But then God has not already created the conditions of heaven, so the argument fails.
No, I'm asking why he didn't just jump to the desired end state instead of creating a world of suffering. I'm asking a question and stating commonly agreed upon facts. That is not a conclusion and cannot be one as conclusions are statements derived from given facts.
Hello.. I will attempt to answer your question.. But realize that no Christian will be able to answer all questions about God.. This is why Faith.. meaning trust in God is an essential part of a Christians make up.. We cannot know God fully nor can we fully understand His ways so we need to have trust in God in those areas where we have no understanding.. But apart from that i will give you the thoughts i have on the topic of your question..
In existence there is not then Just God and We human beings.. Their is a third group of beings which we call Angels of whom one who used to be called Lucifer now commonly known as satan desired to be equal with God and laid claim to it... God needed to demonstrate why the satanic claim was false and why God could only ever be the one and only God of all existence.. satan however had the desire to demonstrate that God was faulty and thus Gods claim to being justly the one and only God was false. This in turn would take away Gods authority in the eyes of the angels and justify satans claim to Godhood..
So now we come to Gods universe creation.. Gods creation of Human beings who where made in a good state... (note according to the Bible they only changed into a sabotaged state of being when satan in the form of a snake deceived them into accepting the Knowledge of good and evil).. What would you think if i said that i believe that God created the universe and humanity as a stage to put to the test and resolve the great controversy of satans claim to Godhood and Gods claim to exclusivity to that position/ state? And that we humans where essentially created to play our part in the resolution to this controversy by God demonstrating through us why satan was not worthy of being God and why God was the only One worthy of being God...
Now God could have ""zapped"" lucifer the moment he decided to rebel against the Authority of God. But that would not have demonstrated that satans claim to Godhood was false.. It would have only revealed that God had the power to destroy satan.. The heavenly Host,, The Angelic population would then would only submit to Gods authority out of fear of His power rather then willingly submit to His Authority out of genuine belief that God was justifiably the one and only God of all existence.. God would have become nothing more then a brutal dictator in the eyes of the angels if he had just zapped satan.. God does not wish for angels or people to submit to Him out of fear or just because God is powerful.. He wants people to willingly accept His authrotiy because they are confident that God is justified in being the one and only God of all existence..
So satan sabotaged Gods creation in an attempt to show fault in God.. And God Redeems His creation to show that He is trully an awesome God and that satans act shows that satan is unjustified in being a God.. satan must have thought He had God beaten.. Because if God had destroyed his sabotaged creation satan would have been able to stand before the Heavenly host and declared that God created a creation and ended up having to destroy it thus God could be declared a failure.. If God had chosen not to destroy the universe to allow sin to exist in His creation forever then satan culd turn around and declare to the angels that God has allow imperfection / evil to exist in his creation and therefore he could claim God was unjustified to be God for allowing such evil to continue into eternity.. But God of course used satans sabotage to demonstrate His ability to reconcile and redeem His creation..
Adam and Eve were not created in the same state as we will be in simply becuase they had human flesh which we will no longer have or be tempted by in heaven so yeah you're right on that.
Also to answer your question sure God could have eliminated us and started all over...but he saw that some would choose him and end up in heaven... so why restart if you'll have people follow you. SUre some will make the choice to go to hell, but some will make the choice to go to heaven.
Also I wouldn't say God preferred not to die on the cross. I would argue he wanted to tbh considering the destination of mankind. I mean he is love right? so he had a desire to save us.
I can accommodate your request this time.No. Please don't quote me out of context and respond to your own creation.
I'm not asking why he didn't just obliterate us. I'm asking why the earth phase couldn't have just been skipped entirely since that would seemingly be in everyone's best interests (including God).
Nihil Virus: Judeo-Christianity attempts to explain not only how we are here, but also why (the purpose of existence). Yet if we examine the Christian worldview, it's clear that our existence on earth is pointless.
Your questions betray 4 theological misunderstandings.
(1) You misunderstand the story of Adam and Eve as primarily the story of the Fall, when in fact it is a symbolic story of the birth of conscience. The key verse is Genesis 3:22: "The Lord God said: See, the man has become like one of us, knowing good from evil."
The disobedience of Adam and Eve produced 2 positive outcomes:
(a) It made humans godlike and thus made real the creation of humanity in God's image (1:26-27).
(b) For the first time it made them moral beings, able now to discern the difference between good and evil.
(2) You talk as if this life is our only career and the afterlife is like a glorified static nursing home in the sky, devoid of challenge and risk. What you overlook is the biblical implication that this life is rather our school--a place of soul-making--and the afterlife is our true career. Jesus uses images like jurisdiction over cities on the basis of proven skills in this life and Paul speaks of jurisdiction over angels and even the cosmos.
(3) You forget that we arrive in heaven with basically the same level of moral and spiritual development that we cultivated during our lifetime, and that means with the same flaws that need work.
Thus, Paradise, our preferred point of postmortem arrival, is located in the 3rd heaven and many dead Christians are not ready for the 3rd heaven and must reside, at least for a while, in the first or 2nd heaven. In other words, there are multiple heavens for various levels of development.
(4) Virus: "My understanding is that you will have free will in heaven but no desire to sin. Why didn't God create us like that to begin with?"
You seem to have a simplistic view of the necessary conditions for free will. (a) The value of our freedom to choose the good is a function of our capacity to overcome contrary inclinations. No contrary inclinations? Then our volition is either coerced or random and the very concept of spiritual growth becomes meaningless.
(b) You ignore the need for pain-dependent virtues to develop a high-quality moral character in God's eyes. Thus, there is no courage without danger, no compassion without suffering, and no generosity without want. Or are you seriously suggesting that the ideal character would lack courage, compassion, and generosity? Pain-dependent virtues presume the need for struggle and uncertainty to achieve moral greatness.
Most people be they Christian, an Atheist or other have a healthy fear of death. What is generally agreed upon is the overall point to life is to live it. How to do that is where people differ and form their own particular world view group.
It is not precise to describe Judeo-Christianity as an attempt to explain why we are here. It flat out makes numerous claims to be the deciding road map to life and death, one of which is found in Acts 4:12. Other world views make their own brand of claims about life and death.
To draw a conclusion that the Christian worldview makes it clear that their existence on earth is pointless, does not come from the statements made by the biblical writers. It comes from your alternate worldview about what you think about life and how it should be lived. Basically you're finding that Christianity for some people including yourself is pointless.
Sorry, just a question - if you read the whole Bible, what do you think about Ecclesiastes?
You need to connect that question with exploring Christian views on angels and how that relates to our existence on earth. Like you did in your initial OP when you began with:Allow me to rephrase the question:
If our existence on earth is not pointless, were the angels cheated?
Likewise you need to provide more than just a question. Provide an examination of Christianity with its' views on angels and how that points to our existence on earth.Judeo-Christianity attempts to explain not only how we are here, but also why (the purpose of existence). Yet if we examine the Christian worldview, it's clear that our existence on earth is pointless.
There are no transitional states of being within heaven, you just are, that is, it is a nexus where time is not part of the equation of existence.
Eternity is endless time. You cannot possibly be more wrong.
The "then" won't matter because the "if" condition is not met.
Taking your "then" as a pure assertion, detached from your "if", I'm still left asking the same question once again: why didn't God just make us this way to begin with?
First off, there was nothing unwitting about this. I did not casually contradict myself in the course of my argument; I offered this as a possible counter argument to my own argument.
Secondly, this counter argument does not defeat my argument.
You seem to be quite lost in what is being said. Maybe take a second look before laughing in my face.
The "then" won't matter because the "if" condition is not met.
Neither the serpent nor the earthly conditions would be there, because as according to my reply to your first quote, timeless eternity isn't transient of states and so you have a totally different existence that isn't played out in time.
And as I said, you couldn't have possibly been more wrong.
Yes it does,would you like me to quote it,it may be embarrassing in light of your claim that you have read the Bible,also 1 Peter 3:15 says be ready to give an answer not argue with someone who doesn't like the answer you giveNo it doesn't.
Right, and you should instead be pursuing truth for its own sake.
What do you mean "God has not already created the conditions of heaven?" Why is it necessary that God creates an exact heaven to begin with?
As I understand, the Garden of Eden was heaven-like but was placed in a war-zone. The earth was not perfect, there was much death and decay, the devil had already caused chaos throughout the creation process (all the death and suffering in the evolutionary progression of life occurred before the Garden of Eden became).
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?