A few thoughts
I just thought I'd jump back in to this discussion with a few little thoughts.
Lady_Firehawk said:
what caught my attention is that people more likely to Awaken were frequently involved in stuff like the occult, Wicca, other pagan stuff, tarot...
This is true. The way I see is that this just gives even more reason why Christian otherkin should be visible and active in sharing their faith in an otherwise hostile environment. There are reasons why otherkin are not generally attracted by the human expression of Christianity. A lot of the reasons overlap with the reasons why wicca is so sucessful at being attractive to young people. I don't think they're primarily theological issues, but rather they represent a huge problem in the Church of how to effectively communicate the Gospel in a way which is attractive to young people.
(Hint: It's important to show how faith interacts with all areas of life, it's not in a compartment for a special time and/or place. Also, emphasis on silence, meditative prayer, reflection, questioning, searching and simplicity of life will get you a lot more mileage and respect than rock bands and flamboyant preachers who fancy themselves as comedians.)
Lady_Firehawk said:
It's the whole reincarnation aspect I don't buy... for it is appointed unto men once to die, and then judgement.
No, I don't go along with the reincarnation thing either. A lot of otherkin seem to say "I remember being an elf in a previous life". I don't. I have no such memory, and what I talk about refers simply to the here and now. There are one or two "feelings" I have which I could imagine being descibed as memories, but I don't think that's what they are. Rather I think of them as being a glimpse, or longing, for the way things should have been, or should be.
onikirimaru777 said:
The theory of being an otherkin must be taken very lightly [...] .
Agreed.
Looking back further at these discussions of "astral planes" or levels of heaven or hell. I'm afraid I can't really go along with any of that, on the basis of a complete lack of evidence. All I will say is that there is an existance of things outside our physical experience, but the very nature of them makes it impossible for us to understand. We currently live in four dimensional space. One of those dimensions (time) proceeds linearly in one direction beyond our control. These are charactaristics only of our physical existance on earth, and are not constraints when we look at life beyond death, or concepts of Heaven or hell. Also I believe that God is not bound by these constraints - as he made them he ultimately is more powerful, and exists beyond them.
So my thinking is that there could be other "dimensions", but we can't really know about them, beyond the occasional influence on the ones which are observable to us. As such it is futile to speculate about them, and concepts such as "astral plane" are merely a flawed human over-simplification of what is beyond our knowledge, based merely on the occasional incidents where there is influence from these other dimersions.
<geek mode>For the maths / engineering geeks out there, I think of it like complex numbers, which consist of a "real" and an "imaginary" part. (the imaginary part being a multiple of i (or j for engineers), where i equals the square root of minus one. Now what we see in this world is only the "real" part of that number. For most purposes it is as if that is all that exists. We can add and subtract complex numbers, and the observation of only the "real" part shows nothing unexpected. However the interesting stuff happens when we multiply ... we cross-multiply the components, and imaginary times imaginary becomes real (and negative), whereas real times imaginary becomes imaginary. This is like the points where unobservable dimensions have a visible effect in the observed ones. It's my understanding of what humans tend to call "supernatural". However by nature of these limited observations it's impossible to tell the unobservable mechanisms behind it.</geek mode>
Anyway, my point was just that we can't know about these things, and we don't need to. And my opinion is that talk of a specific, named "astral" plane or such things is futile and far from accurate.
-----
At this point I must leave the discussion as at the weekend I'll be heading off into the forest for a blissful month without internet, phone, running water, etc. (such luxury it almost feels sinful - LOL!) I'll be back online for a few days in the middle of August, so I might drop by them and see how things have developed.
- Erufailon.