- Feb 5, 2002
- 166,565
- 56,205
- Country
- United States
- Faith
- Catholic
- Marital Status
- Married
- Politics
- US-Others
Fr. Dwight Longenecker
Canada is moving forward with the opportunity to administer “assisted dying” for the mentally ill.
This article explains the situation and, as usual, complicates the question in order to confuse people into accepting euthanasia. The usual utilitarian and sentimental argumentation is used. “Many of those who suffer from mental illness are also poor and homeless. They see no hope and long for a lethal and safe alternative.” or “This person is suffering intolerably and only longs to be in control of her final days. Why should we deny her that choice?”
See how the “choice” issue is thrown into the discussion? “Assisted dying” will be the patient’s choice, but it won’t really because their application for “assisted dying” will have to be approved by a panel of “experts”.
What is so chilling about this article is its intentional use of euphemisms. Doctor so and so didn’t kill the patient. He “assisted their dying.” Psychiatry is such an imprecise science, and diagnosis is so often faulty and subjective that the prospect is even more disturbing. Who ways a person is mentally ill? Aren’t all of us at least a little bit crazy sometimes?
Continued below.
Canada Approves Mercy Killing for the Mentally Ill | Fr. Dwight Longenecker
Canada is moving forward with the opportunity to administer “assisted dying” for the mentally ill.
This article explains the situation and, as usual, complicates the question in order to confuse people into accepting euthanasia. The usual utilitarian and sentimental argumentation is used. “Many of those who suffer from mental illness are also poor and homeless. They see no hope and long for a lethal and safe alternative.” or “This person is suffering intolerably and only longs to be in control of her final days. Why should we deny her that choice?”
See how the “choice” issue is thrown into the discussion? “Assisted dying” will be the patient’s choice, but it won’t really because their application for “assisted dying” will have to be approved by a panel of “experts”.
What is so chilling about this article is its intentional use of euphemisms. Doctor so and so didn’t kill the patient. He “assisted their dying.” Psychiatry is such an imprecise science, and diagnosis is so often faulty and subjective that the prospect is even more disturbing. Who ways a person is mentally ill? Aren’t all of us at least a little bit crazy sometimes?
Continued below.
Canada Approves Mercy Killing for the Mentally Ill | Fr. Dwight Longenecker