The following came up in a discussion on finalfantasynet. I find myself deeply troubled when wondering what to say to such questions. Mabee you guys can help me.
It is funny what happens when people are blessed (or cursed with) intelligence.
Obviously, my friends are having issues... I really wanna bring them to God... but hehehe... HOW? What I'd really like to do is get this issue wrapped up once and for all... but HOW? And what are your perspectives on the matter?
Midgar Fanatic said:Well since discussing humanity, within a sociological context, is bascially subjective and all we each have to go on is our own personal experience, than I think perhaps this is indeed the case. People can talk of other cultures and individuals, but if they have never truly walked in these shoes than they are really only expressing opinion which, as you have pointed out previously Terminal, can never truly be proven as fact. And since it is impossible to live the life of every human on earth, than such I think would be the case. Generalization is more apt. But even this, I think, would be heavily influenced by personal experience.
Sociologists do this all the time but I think, most of the time, they are really just stating the obvious. Besides as we all know, there are exceptions to everything and so I think this field of social science is somewhat overrated. But I have not studied this subject much so what do I know? <_<
Question: If every government in the world declared peace, and all borders were eliminated... would the world truly become a happier place? Or would humans just find something else to [staff edit] about and kill each other over?
Terminal Est said:Yes this makes sense, and as we should be aware of this, there is a difference in speaking with experience, and with opinions likes/dislikes. I think people know this, I know this too, but only when it is mentioned and underlined. People are weird ha ha.
But it does lead me to wonder, if negative views on things we know nothing of first hand truly reflect our own selves, or at least, that which directly revolves around us, (Which also logically makes sense, as humans often amplify meaning through emotional presentation, a lot more so than almost any statement.) then what does it mean to advocate or speak positively of something we know nothing of?
Anyways, answer.
Yes, I am totally convinced that man would still, despite globally claimed peace and the disappearance of ethnic restrictions, find something to feud over.
I believe this to be our nature.
For example...most wars from the past and present are for religious reason; or are they? Religion is often used as a pretext for something else entirely. Jesus didn't do anything, it was all us, so if we go to such extravagances to wage war, I am sure that such things would not diminish much even without the restrictions exemplified in the question.
People would find something, this is almost a given.
Midgar Fanatic said:Yes, well religion puts a whole different spin on things of course, I thought of this after I had already posted it and I should of phrased the question a bit differently. What if I asked the same question but asked you to imagine a context in which, as John Lennon sang, there was no religion? Does this change your answer at all?
Terminal Est said:Not really. :/ I am not a fan of religion as everyone here knows, and while it may be that religion is responsible for so many atrocities, past and present, before and after Jesus Christ...just so you know that I am not targeting Christianity only...despite that in the past, people were more apt to believe things than today due to lack of knowledge or scientific breakthrough...I do not think that people really believed as much as we think they did.
We do not know all that much today, do we? We have made discoveries, and live, at least in some parts of the world, in more peaceful times than back then...but "back then" also had great breakthroughs and discoveries.
I think that what people truly did believe was that failure to submit meant death, torture or imprisonment. Or all three. It still does in some countries today.
So, that people have always been able to question the existence of deities or the morality attributed to organized religions show that even then religion was a facade for gain, as it is much the same in today's holy wars. I love John Lennon's idea, but I just do not think that it would happen. As primitive religious concepts have slowly transitioned to more direct social causes and that racism has evolved from straight up genocide to methods a lot more subtle but just as deadly, we would definitely find something to fight over, some cause to cover it up with and use as justification.
I think people are meant for conflict and destruction, despite our will to live, understand and create, as we have been since day one when we ate neanderthals-without cokkin' em. >_>
(Even today there was a show on CBC talking about a bishop who denies the Holocaust, and that the current Pope needs distance himself away from said bishop...it all seems so ridiculous to me, which is what convinces me that religion is not needed for us to follow our nature. Religion is just an excuse, and I find it frightening that we use something as important to mankind as religion in order to further true motives.
I could be wrong however...since religion basically IS a primary factor of humanity. Who really knows what it would be like without it? Still, somehow I do not think it would be much different.
I do not like this belief though, I wish that somebody could convince me otherwise.
Question-
Is serial killing conditioned, or is it an innate mental disorder?
Stupid question I mentioned at the beginning of said post-
Okay, you will think I am weird but...we see it every day.
Pretty woman who stand out more than others, and therefore believe that the world belongs to them, men carrying an air of self importance, creepy looking people who never smile, businessman who run the economy, deep spiritual people, religious folk who quote The Bible, tyrants and overlords with ominous patriotic speeches, artists who see and feel the essence of everything...all sorts of people, many of them carrying a bit too much than what they truly are, some honest, some liars, some nice some mean...and although, of course, it is natural...when you really think about it and see all these people walking around, does not all the allure, the pretensions, ambitions and so forth seem totally ridiculous and almost pointless, when you think that every single one of those people are walking around with smelly, wrinkly...?
>_>
It is funny what happens when people are blessed (or cursed with) intelligence.
Obviously, my friends are having issues... I really wanna bring them to God... but hehehe... HOW? What I'd really like to do is get this issue wrapped up once and for all... but HOW? And what are your perspectives on the matter?
Last edited by a moderator: