No fallen angel gets a second chance.
I can agree Rebellion was what caused the angels to choose satan over God. Thus all that rebelled with satan are fallen angels. That still leaves the question what sin did only some of them commit that got only some portion of the fallen angels chained.
I believe you have admitted on this forum not all fallen angels are in chains. I do not believe there are degrees of rebellion that made the difference. The angels made a choice, serve God or Satan, I see no middle ground calling for a lesser punishment. All will wind up in the lake of fire, but only some are bound in chains right now.
I believe you have a dilemma. There is an answer, but you will not accept it as possible, therefore you have no answer to my question.
Believe me brother I have studied this too and did not just leap to my conclusion lightly.
I have a theory and opinion on why this is so controversial. You may correct me if you believe I am wrong.
I believe most of the people who so strongly oppose this view have removed much of the supernatural dealings of God with man from the scriptures. One example is your statement “I personally do not believe that angels have an earthly ministry today”. Other examples are supernatural dealings with men such as healings and gifts of the Spirit or just miracles in our day. Many Christians really do not like to acknowledge satan, fallen angels or demons are real. Trust me if anyone ever witnesses a manifestation of an evil spirit they will believe it.
Satan has not yet gone away nor have fallen angels, demons or the workings of a supernatural God dealing with His people sometimes in supernatural ways.
The only way to find a middle ground here is through the Scriptures. I will work toward that end and then your problem will be with the Word of God and not me.
That being said, your comment was.........
"I do not believe there are degrees of rebellion that made the difference. The angels made a choice, serve God or Satan, I see no middle ground calling for a lesser punishment. All will wind up in the lake of fire, but only some are bound in chains right now. "
IMO the rebellion came from the sin of Pride. Having the ability to chose, they made the wrong choice.
2 Peter 2:4.......
"For if God did not spare angels when they sinned, but cast them into hell and committed them to chains of gloomy darkness to be kept until the judgment."
We see here that there are some angels who rebelled and are so evil and bad that God has restricted their earthly activity. They are being held as Peter says until the Judgment. That says to me that there is definitily degrees of judgment just as there is degrees of torments in hell.
Now if there are demons who are working on this earth, which I believe that there are, and we just saw that there are Biblically some fallen angels who are incarcerated, then it is clear that the ones on earth are not being punished as are those who were "CAST DOWN TO HELL AND DELIVERED INTO CHAINS AND DARKNESS."
So I think that you can see that I really do not have a dilemma at all according the Word of God.
Some demons are active and some are chained. That fact alone confirms the fact that their rebellion led to a degree of punishment worse than those active on earth today.
YES. They will ALL wind up in the lake of fire!
Then you said.........
"Satan has not yet gone away nor have fallen angels, demons or the workings of a supernatural God dealing with His people sometimes in supernatural ways. "
Absolutely correct! I have said nothing to you that would cause you to think any different that that.
I ask you to also to consider Rev. 17:17........
"God put into their hearts (Men) to accomplish His will".
I can not correct your opinion. That is impossible as it is YOUR thinking. All I can do is say to you that I do not agree with the bottom line you support which is FALLEN ANGELS HAD SEX WITH HUMANS.
I believe that I have posted more than enough Scriptures to show Biblically that that is just not possible. I know that YOU and many others want that to be the case and I suspect it is because of some deep personal thought where that idea has become more believable that the Word of God. That is not a correction to your thinking, only my opinion.
Always good to talk to someone who can communicate civilly.