You're all echoing the same in your own way. Something's broken. You'd think it would be better in Christian circles but it appears that's not the case. I'm surprised.
In your opinion, what's going on with Christian women in relation to dating?
Well, since Christian women are imperfect human beings, you have the sanctified attitudes and character mixed in with the unsanctified, and what you get is variable. The starting material varies, and how much the Holy Spirit has changed will vary. Some are better than others, even though they're all saved. You've probably had to deal with this in men, Christian men get to deal with this in women.
So, there are going to be some common threads between Christian and non-Christian women, but there's another layer to Christian women which may or may not be present, which is spiritualizing her choices.
So, take what women like and are attracted to - and I realize there is variance, you have your types of guys that you like, but bear with me - and add 100%, consistent Christ-like character on top of that, and that is what Christian women will say they expect. If you take her at her word, you've got multiple deal breakers simply because being the best human you can be is not enough. So she's going to have to settle - but when she settles, what kinds of guys does she settle for? Christian women that I have been into have not settled for me. Sometimes it's guys in the church, sometimes it's guys outside the church, but my problem is it's not me.
With Christians, much is done in community. In that community, if there are attractive women, there will be multiple male "orbiters" each. They want to get to know her better or get a chance to make a move and ask her out. When I was in college, "friends first" was generally the acceptable way for couples to get together among Christians, so that really exacerbated the condition. If a reasonably attractive woman throws a party in a mixed group, there will often be quite a few guys there. If she's not the most social of women and does it anyway, the women at the party can easily be outnumbered. If she picks anyone, she'll pick her favorite. This is lived experience.
On multiple occasions, Christian women have said to each other that there's no one in the area to date
in my presence. I hope they like cats.
Then, there's what many (I won't say every) unmarried women on CF have posted about dating, relationships, what they say they want in men, and how they live. You've had a taste, I've had a bigger taste since I've been here longer. In this context, I have found that when I am asked to share what I honestly want in a woman, I get attacked for it so I have learned to craft my answers if I answer. I don't wish to break any rules or call anyone out, so I'd rather not get too specific. It's less than impressive. I realize this is a subset of Christian women, but I'm not going to have access to these kinds of conversations with the women at church.