Sketcher
Born Imperishable
You're essentially asking two questions:It clearly states in Deuteronomy 14:8 that we’re not to eat pork. In fact, Deuteronomy and Leviticus clearly state a lot of things that we don’t adhere to.
13:6 through18: We’re instructed to kill without mercy -even your own family members- anyone who tries to convince you to worship other gods.
17:2 through 13: Kill anyone who does evil-such as worshipping the stars- and violates the covenant. And if you’re not sure if the party is guilty, take it to court and if the Judge finds the party guilty and you refuse take part in stoning the defendant to death, then you should be killed too.
21:18: Kill your own son if he is rebellious.
Thou shalt not kill, but Deuteronomy, Leviticus, and Exodus is full of examples like this where we are to kill people for sinning. What about “as we forgive those who trespass against us”? I seem to have made executing people the theme here, but there are instructions/laws on other topics as well that we don’t follow, I’m assuming because they just don’t seem consistent with our faith.
So why is it OK to have a pork Bratwurst at the church fundraising event these days when God clearly forbids it?
You could argue that things were different back then and don’t apply today. But that would nullify the Ten Commandments. These laws I’m referring to were issued on the same day. They just didn’t make the top ten list.
1) Why does practice in New Testament times contradict certain Old Testament commands?
2) Why do certain Old Testament commands seem to contradict each other?
First of all, the second question indicates that more study of the Old Testament is needed. You are right in that the Old Testament laws were issued the same day, in fact Jews don't really chop up the Law into segments like some Christians do (i.e. ceremonial law, moral law, etc). It's all just law to them. Some laws require certain things to be in place in order to be rightly obeyed according to Jewish thought, and others do not. The point is, it is one unit, and if it is one unit, it won't be self-contradictory. I'll give you another prime example, Exodus 21:12:
"He who strikes a man so that he dies shall surely be put to death."
The first part describes murder. The second part describes execution. There's a difference. Further study of the Law will reveal what comprises murder, as accidental killings are not worthy of execution. And also, there are specific requirements for execution to take place, i.e. on the testimony of at least two witnesses to the crime.
So when dealing with apparent contradictions in the Old Testament law, do further study. It will help clear a lot of things up. The same principle is good for dealing with apparent contradictions between New Testament teachings.
As for the first question, the commands you cited were given to Jews. And according to Jewish tradition, there are certain laws that God gave to everyone, and there were additional laws that he gave the Jews. In the Old Testament, there is overlap. The Jews have their laws which include the prohibitions on murder, theft, sexual immorality, etc that all the nations are supposed to follow, plus many other commands that were only given to the Jews, such as kosher requirements. Acts 15 fleshes some of this out a little more as well. Basically, if the New Testament forbids it, all Christians are to avoid it. If the New Testament does not forbid it, it's likely that Christians of a non-Jewish background are in the clear to enjoy it, within the boundaries of other New Testament commands and teachings, most of all love for God and one's neighbor. If you can't love both God and your neighbor doing it, don't do it. Christians of a Jewish background may need to do more things out of obedience to God, though not for salvation - but I leave the specifics to between them and God. I'm not going to tell them to not keep kosher, but I'm not going to pretend to be enough of an expert to definitively tell them they must keep it, or may not.
Upvote
0