Arminianism is untenable

[Hammster]

If you don't know the punishment, why do you bring it up?

Let me help you; the wages of sin... well, you know the rest.

That's off topic for this thread.

 

[EmSw]

That's off topic for this thread.

Sorry you forgot; this is the topic of your own OP. Maybe you should read it again.

 

[Hammster]

Sorry you forgot; this is the topic of your own OP. Maybe you should read it again.

I did. The subject is the Arminian view of atonement. It's not a general thread on the atonement.

 

[OzSpen]

If you agree with my allegation, then there's no need for support. If you disagree with my allegation, then that's a good thing.

You have provided not a shred of evidence to support your allegation. No evidence means no evidence to defend your claim.:o

 

[Hammster]

You have provided not a shred of evidence to support your allegation. No evidence means no evidence to defend your claim.:o

So are you saying I'm wrong?

 

[OzSpen]

So are you saying I'm wrong?

Please provide the evidence so that I have a basis on which to assess your accusation. To this point no evidence has been provided by you. Until the evidence is supplied, you have provided no case to answer.

A judge would chuck your case out of court because of a lack of evidence.

 

[Hammster]

Please provide the evidence so that I have a basis on which to assess your accusation. To this point no evidence has been provided by you. Until the evidence is supplied, you have provided no case to answer.

A judge would chuck your case out of court because of a lack of evidence.

This isn't a trial. I made an assertion. Do you disagree with my assertion?

 

[OzSpen]

This isn't a trial. I made an assertion. Do you disagree with my assertion?

Evidence has not been presented. Your case remains unproven.

Case dismissed.

 

[Hammster]

Evidence has not been presented. Your case remains unproven.

Case dismissed.

So you disagree with the OP. That's good to hear.

 

[EmSw]

I did. The subject is the Arminian view of atonement. It's not a general thread on the atonement.

Here are your exact words, in which 'punishment' is in the very first sentence; atonement isn't even mentioned.

Arminians insist that Jesus took the punishment for all sins. Yet, they admit that there are people in hell because of their sins. This makes God disingenuous because He punishes people for sins that His Son already paid for.

You say, and I quote, "Jesus took the punishment for all sins". What punishment do the Arminians insist Jesus took?

If you don't know the subject you are portraying, why even start a thread on it? Also, if you don't know the 'punishment' you push upon Arminians, you accuse Arminians of something which could be false.

So, let's have it, what 'punishment' do the Arminians insist Jesus paid for all sins?

 

[Hammster]

Here are your exact words, in which 'punishment' is in the very first sentence; atonement isn't even mentioned.

Arminians insist that Jesus took the punishment for all sins. Yet, they admit that there are people in hell because of their sins. This makes God disingenuous because He punishes people for sins that His Son already paid for.

You say, and I quote, "Jesus took the punishment for all sins". What punishment do the Arminians insist Jesus took?

If you don't know the subject you are portraying, why even start a thread on it? Also, if you don't know the 'punishment' you push upon Arminians, you accuse Arminians of something which could be false.

So, let's have it, what 'punishment' do the Arminians insist Jesus paid for all sins?

Ask them. Don't derail this thread. I will not ask again.

 

[OzSpen]

So you disagree with the OP. That's good to hear.

I never said a word about the OP. You lied about my view. Please quit your flaming!

 

[Hammster]

I never said a word about the OP. You lied about my view. Please quit your flaming!

You either agree with my assertion, or you disagree. Which is it?

 

[JCFantasy23]

MOD HAT ON


Temporarily closing for staff review

MOD HAT OFF
​

 

[James Is Back]

Mod Hat On

This thread will be closed permanently as you were warned not to derail the thread and didn't listen. Next time folks don't derail threads so threads won't be closed for good.

Mod Hat Off
​