Actually, they're exactly the same point, said differently.
Well why is it that when I read it, the first doesn't mention the right way to worship God, while the second does?
"It has nothing to do with God's ways, expectations, or reasons. I'm saying it's not a free-choice. I'm not choosing between God and no-God, I'm choosing between reward and punishment. I just think that's choosing between the wrong things."
There, you're just complaining about slaving for a reward.
"That would not be genuine love for God, or respect for others, that's just looking out for myself."
Here you are saying the correct way to worship God is not by slaving for a reward.
I think in light of whether we look for right or wrong in what we read, there is quite a variety of meanings we can derive from a text.
I'm sorry, but I cannot look at Christians, or religious people as a whole and think that they are somehow privy to some special information from God about how to treat humanity well. From where I sit, it doesn't look as though they do.
Well that is the matter of what you must decide for yourself. Sadly you are right about that, many "Christians" don't have the correct relationship with God because they haven't come to Christ for the right reason, instead they are motivated by self esteem, greasing up to their pastor and peers. In fact the majority of those Christians you see as being the intolerant ones aren't even listening to Jesus, they're listening to their pastor! Their pastor preaches against abortion and they bomb the clinics, their pastor preaches against homosexuality and they draw picket lines. I know what you're saying very well, Paul predicted the coming of false teachers, and even identified plenty of them while he was alive, and if you have concerns about the sort of behaviour you know to be wrong, then you ought not fear that you'll ever become that sort of person. Your conscience is already working.
It doesn't work that way for me. If I wanted to believe in Scientology, I would simply believe in Scientology. If I wanted to believe in Allah, I'd believe in Allah. If I wanted to believe in the tenets of Buddhism or Hinduism, I would simply believe. If I wanted to believe in ghosts, and UFOs and the Loch Ness Monster, I would. But I don't "want to believe." I want to be able to find the truth, not settle on believing in something for the sake of believing in something. If the Christian God is the truth, then It has an infinite number of ways of making me believe, not the least of which are convincing me, or just making me believe. But I'm not going to believe because I want to, but because I have no other option. Essentially, I have to believe against my will, because that is the only way I will truly believe. These stories may be believable to you, but they just aren't believable to me.
Yes yes yes, totally the hardest thing is to overcome the argument of the flesh and listen to the spirit. I don't even know how to tell you how to do that, but I do know that if you're genuinely interested in knowing God then you'll never give up until you've truly found Him. I can tell you that God has done everything that is reasonably expected of Him to prove who He is, there's a whole universe of incredible design to prove that we can never possess the same knowledge He has, there's the Bible as a testimony of the history of His people which is incredibly accurate and reliable, there's the evidence of Jesus Christ who never put a foot wrong or said something false, and there's evidence in the lives of Christians all over the world that the Holy Spirit has the power to unite us with God. For all these reasons there are countless arguments against, so your decision is one of determining whether all this evidence that God has given us is really just to be discarded because you are expecting something of Him which He has decided not to give you.
Yeah, I suppose I understand the verse. I spent a long time "listening," and found nothing. So I started looking.
Well it would seem that you have yet to contribute a certain matter of faith to the topic. Take a read of Hebrews 11
Hebrews 11 - Passage Lookup - New Living Translation - BibleGateway.com to learn about what faith is. In fact Hebrews is a very good read, I suggest if you haven't read it yet, sit down for half an hour and read the whole thing through.
John 24-29: Now Thomas (also known as Didymus[a]), one of the Twelve, was not with the disciples when Jesus came. 25 So the other disciples told him, We have seen the Lord!
But he said to them, Unless I see the nail marks in his hands and put my finger where the nails were, and put my hand into his side, I will not believe.
26 A week later his disciples were in the house again, and Thomas was with them. Though the doors were locked, Jesus came and stood among them and said, Peace be with you! 27 Then he said to Thomas, Put your finger here; see my hands. Reach out your hand and put it into my side. Stop doubting and believe.
28 Thomas said to him, My Lord and my God!
29 Then Jesus told him, Because you have seen me, you have believed; blessed are those who have not seen and yet have believed.
Now if you're a believer then this is not a parable. And it should be noted that Jesus showed all of the apostles his hands, and side before they believed, but Thomas was different. Thomas was told of Jesus' return, and he was skeptical, maybe wrongly, but he was. And Jesus understood, acknowledged that, and gave Thomas what he needed to believe. Maybe the blessed are those who believe without seeing, but so is Thomas the Believer, and he had to see to believe.
Most certainly, there is no way that believing becomes real until God becomes real to us, and for that to happen we must be prepared to hear what He says to us. Admittedly some people require less of a reason than others, some people have had physical experiences with Him, others merely spiritual, and others yet have only taken the word of their fellow man for testimony. I also know that He never turns away a true seeker, but that is not as easy to do as it is to say, because accepting God means to cut loose some particular desires we have to not comply with His commands. I'm not sure exactly what the particular hurdles are that you can't get over, but I'm sure you do know. So (forgive me for saying so) you'll have to really be honest with yourself about that, and if you can accept the particular problem you have with the Bible, then you can progress to acknowledge that God wants something from you that you don't want to give Him.
But He did. Heaven and Hell. Eternal life, or eternal torment. That's pretty basic.
Well that's obviously the way it is. When we ask what happens after life, do you expect Him to be honest or lie? I think He has very good reason for disclosing this information to us, it's not every person who can comprehend the reality of eternal life before it's been granted to them, but I have no doubts whatsoever that many people in their lifetime have come to understand the nature of God by hearing and accepting His methods of justice. And if this information has saved even one soul then would you dispute that God should never have spoken to us of it?
Okay, but the point still is that it is a reward. I don't really need the reward, I really don't see how death is that bad. I cease to exist. I didn't exist before I did, and it wasn't bad. Dying might be terrible, but death I don't see as being bad.
You merely have no idea what is in store. Consider the human with all his limbs, takes life for granted. Consider a human who loses his limb, is filled with remorse for a while at the severe loss. Consider the human who is ignorant to computers who one day discovers the thrills of such a toy. Consider the dog who finds a new thrill when given a bone. The point is that we can be content with anything God has given us if that is our attitude about it, but it is not until we discover the greatest gift which is the knowledge of God that we can ever comprehend how good it is. God is the one who gives us what we want, He is the giver. The problem we face is that we tend to want things that God doesn't want to give us, so we become takers. Also might I say, it's a dangerous proposition you make in that statement. When the creator of the universe and life has told us what the story about life is, what is expected of us, and what is promised, and you think you can make up your own rules and believe that death is the end of your life, that's you thumbing your nose at Him. Is that the antichrist speaking to you, that Christ lived died and rose for someone other than you?
What? Don't you think that good should be praised and evil should be punished? Care to explain?
I don't know full well what God does and doesn't approve of. According to my in-laws it's cheeseburgers, shellfish, and bacon and eggs. I don't really understand why God doesn't approve of cheeseburgers, they're delicious! According to my colleague it's seeing women's hair. According to another it's eating beef (cheeseburgers again!). I just assume that if there's a God, He wouldn't approve of me punching a guy in the face. However, more importantly, the guy wouldn't approve of me punching him in the face.
Now that is a very good point to raise, one that I think you do already know the answer to, and it basically comes down to common-sense. Deciding what fits well with your conscience and at the expense of greed or whatever other fleshly motive there is to contest the conscience.
Romans 2
14 Even Gentiles, who do not have Gods written law, show that they know his law when they instinctively obey it, even without having heard it. 15 They demonstrate that Gods law is written in their hearts, for their own conscience and thoughts either accuse them or tell them they are doing right. 16 And this is the message I proclaimthat the day is coming when God, through Christ Jesus, will judge everyones secret life.
And
Romans 14 (New Living Translation)
The Danger of Criticism
1 Accept other believers who are weak in faith, and dont argue with them about what they think is right or wrong. 2 For instance, one person believes its all right to eat anything. But another believer with a sensitive conscience will eat only vegetables. 3 Those who feel free to eat anything must not look down on those who dont. And those who dont eat certain foods must not condemn those who do, for God has accepted them. 4 Who are you to condemn someone elses servants? They are responsible to the Lord, so let him judge whether they are right or wrong. And with the Lords help, they will do what is right and will receive his approval.
According to Paul, and as a consistent message through all his letters, the matter of sin is the matter of disobeying the conscience. And it takes a conscious effort to strenthen ones rebellion against the conscience.
I don't think so. I mean, you can certainly decide to believe, but from where I sit, that isn't true belief, there is no basis for it. That doesn't last for me because I will always have to question it, and with no basis for belief, I have to move on. That's just the way I work.
I can tell you I moved on at one point and after a long excursion came to plead with God to bring me back. Now after having the reality of life with God and without God as direct comparisons, I do firmly believe that there will be no such time where I might turn from God again. Of course, your life, your decisions.
Thanks, but no Holy Spirit for me yet, which is my point. The only reason I can come up with for wanting to know God is that He is the truth. And I don't believe that. At least not right now. If God wants me He knows an infinite number of ways to get me. I even know of a few. Nothing yet. In the meantime I have lots of other places to look.
Yes, well it has to be a mutual decision. When it happens will be at just the right moment when you both have exactly the same understanding of the nature of the arrangement.
And no, no more pastors. Fool me thrice and all that...
Oh you've been fooled! Yet another feather in your cap

Yes, you can't rely too much on a human, in fact I would warn you as any good pastor would, against blatantly trusting what someone says until you can verify that it is consistent with the truth that God has revealed to us in the Bible.