Yes, I suppose so.
Whoever claims to be noble must conduct himself nobly
Noblesse oblige - Wikipedia
What is fitting for the good Creator whose nature is love? I would think it includes succeeding at creating a good creation, i.e. no evil. Obviously, it's a process but doesn't the telos of God being all in all assume the eradication of evil? Isn't God capable of eradicating evil without destroying the creature? What is more noble, more divine, saving some of creation in the process of eradicating evil or saving all creation in the process of eradicating evil? I say the latter, but we'll just have to wait and see.
I don't think it's unfortunate. I think the scriptures are sufficiently ambiguous for my being justified in withholding judgment concerning God's final judgment. I consider it prudent. But do I wish all to be reconciled? Yes. Do I think God capable. More than yes. Do I think it necessary that hell have everlasting occupants? No, I don't see why that must be.