Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.
to Mary, Full of Grace, as the Mother of Immanuel (God-With-Us),
and to the Saints as the Handiworks of God's manifold grace.
It seems that you've said this, almost identically, in every post to me.
For the last time, honoring Mary is not at question, and we all know her role in the Incarnation. But if you cannot appreciate or acknowledge that it is possible to go too far while attempting to honoring Mary (or any other saint), there doesn't seem to be anything more to discuss.
DO you think that there are devotions that could be abusive, cross the line from paying respect and honor into worship, whether or not intended as such?
__No. It's "anything goes" so long as you mean well.
__Yes. There is a level of homage that belongs to God alone.
Catholics are formed by the Teaching of Christ and by the Sacred Liturgy (Christian Worship) to have a real sense of the Incomprehensible grandeur of God Most High. And the centrality of Jesus truly PRESENT among us in the Blessed Sacrament of the Altar and the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass. This is KEY. The prayers to God, ... our sense of God is central and primary in all things.
Now, ... the Church does indeed warn the faithful against any excesses in devotion to Mary that would be in violation against the 1st Commandment. Of course, ... that is a given.
As I said, what are some examples of a superstitious or excessive devotion? paying homage to a stain on a silo doesn't do it, and apparitions that have not been validated by the church still attract thousands of devotees, including clergy. So what kind of excessive devotion has the church squelched?the Church warns against superstition or excessive Marian devotion.
WHAT kind of thing? Please be specific and show us something that the church has acted to prohibit or at least denounce.But if I saw a fellow brother committing this kind of thing, I would say something to him to counsel him and guide him.
Dear Albion,
I found a case where the Church acted to condemn, as idolatry, a heresy a group of people called the Collyridians who sought to deify the Blessed Virgin Mary.
I believe that the following link should answer your questions well enough:
[Sorry, ... I still need 50 posts to post a link ... but you may go to the EWTN library and just research this using the word "Collyridianism" ... and the article is written by Patrick Madrid ... OK? I hope you find it.]
I hope you see now that the Church would not tolerate any excesses in this direction of Worshipping Mary.
God bless you.
I do thank you for looking into this. I've never heard of this group, and it deserved a look by me. However, doesn't this almost prove my point? I mean if it takes a formal, organized effort that treats Mary as a god before the church will take a stand, what, we may wonder, passes inspection?
I believe it was in the year 350-400? They were heretics and idolaters according to the Church. And their heresy was rightly condemned.You have to admit that this group took it to about as far an extreme as can be imagined. From what I read, this happened about 1900 years ago and represented almost a separate religion. It was opposed mainly by one bishop.
So, while being reassured that there is a limit that will bring a response from church authorities, I still have to think that a reasonable person can appreciate that devotions (mostly of a more modern origin) that are just barely on the safe side of the line that the Collyridians represent can well be thought improper by some of us, too. Altars. Grottos. bowing. kneeling, prayers that attribute god-like authority it to her, the mediatrix of all graces, co-redeemer of the world, and so on is all very questionable in our view. It is not that Mary shouldn't be honored at all.
Hyper-Dulia towards Mary is of the Holy Spirit.
And it is the Holy Spirit that teaches us how to adore God and how to give due honor to Mary.
Where'd you get that?The Holy Spirit flies to a person who is in conscious fellowship with Mary.
That doesn't have anything to do with what you said above. Honoring Mary isn't the issue; it's HOW the honoring is done. Wouldn't it be great if you actually were willing to address that?Consider the union of Mary and the Holy Spirit in bringing to us the Mystery of the Incarnation. This is why Mary is called the Spouse of the Holy Spirit (who overshadowed her [St. Luke 1:34] even as the CLOUD overshadowed the Ark of the Covenant in the Old Testament.)
I can appreciate your difficulty as a non-Catholic looking from the outside in,
How so?
How do you know that to be so?
Where'd you get that?
That doesn't have anything to do with what you said above. Honoring Mary isn't the issue; it's HOW the honoring is done. Wouldn't it be great if you actually were willing to address that?
Sure you can claim the Holy Spirit is the cause of just about anything. The Collyridians probably used that justification, too. In the past several days, I've read on these forums that every individual person gets his doctrines straight from the HS, no need for either Scripture or Tradition or a church. Also that speaking in tongues or handling snakes is of the Holy Spirit. Everyone claims "the Holy Spirit made me do it" whatever practice that person is engaged in.
Well, I was a Roman Catholic for a lot longer than you've been one, but I've come to expect that line from every recent convert who somehow thinks that becoming a member of the RCC automatically makes him a theologian and church historian.
I'm sorry that you've decided to take refuge behind church membership, but that's what happens when the discussion gets down to the brass tacks. It's too bad, though, because this is potentially a most interesting issue, IMO.
Blessings.
The answer to the last point is that honoring her is not the issue, but how it's done, and what specifically the devotion is. I think I made that point before. As to the former matter you mention, don't assume that 1) the Roman Catholic Church is being singled out. There are plenty of Episcopalians, Lutherans, Eastern Orthodox, Old Catholics, etc. who engage in similar behavior, or 2) that the Protestants here fell off the theological turnip truck yesterday, such that it's necessary to give them the crash course in Catholicism.Dear Albion,
The reason why I invoked the Church in this matter is because that is where you have to go to know alot more about Mary, ... its that simple. Having got passed some rough issues with you ... I thought I'd share some of the things that the Church teaches on the Blessed Mother and her relationship to God the Holy Spirit.
What I said is of the Holy Spirit because the Church teaches it. Sacred Writing says in 1 Tim 3:15 that the Church is the pillar and foundation of Truth. Therefore, the Church is a trustworthy means of knowing the Word of God.
You were inquiring about some of the practices about Holy Mary ... so I shared some things that would reassure you that NORMALLY, as Scripture states, ... the Holy Spirit teaches us HOW to pray. So why is it so difficult to see that the same Spirit shows us how to honor the Saints and give due honor to the Blessed Mother of Immanuel (God-With-Us)?
Many don't. Some do.And having been Catholic, ... you ought to know better than anyone that we do not worship the Blessed Mother.
OK, but we really need to look at the whole picture. I see that you have done some of that below, so I'll read it first before commenting.As I said before, ... we do not offer up sacrifice to Holy Mary. We offer the Holy Sacrifice of the Mass to God the Father, through the Son, IN the Holy Spirit.
We PRAY the Gospel through the Most Holy Rosary.
We have Holy Days of Obligation whereby we commemorate the Marian Dogmas like August 15, the Assumption of the Blessed Virgin Mary.
We ask for Holy Mary's intercession (that she take our prayers add her own to them and present them to her Divine Son, Who is the One Mediator between God and men.)
We have images of Holy Mary, paintings and statues.
We wear a scapular (which is like wearing a thread of the Immaculate Mary's garment).
We have our children place a crown of flowers upon the statue of Holy Mary who is the Queen of Heaven.
We kneel before statues of Holy Mary and petition for her maternal assistance.
We light candles for her.
And saturdays are dedicated to Blessed Mother.
AHJE said:We PRAY the Gospel through the Most Holy Rosary.
We have Holy Days of Obligation whereby we commemorate the Marian Dogmas like August 15, the Assumption of the Blessed Virgin Mary.
We ask for Holy Mary's intercession (that she take our prayers add her own to them and present them to her Divine Son, Who is the One Mediator between God and men.)
We have images of Holy Mary, paintings and statues.
We wear a scapular (which is like wearing a thread of the Immaculate Mary's garment).
We have our children place a crown of flowers upon the statue of Holy Mary who is the Queen of Heaven.
We kneel before statues of Holy Mary and petition for her maternal assistance.
We light candles for her.
And saturdays are dedicated to Blessed Mother.
^ Just that these are some of the ways that we give expression to that very special and unique honor that is due to the Blessed Mother of Him who is our God and Saviour, Jesus Christ.
Right. We now come to the part where we disagree and there's probably no way for one of us to win over the other, so we can just say that we were able to air the issues in a calm, organized manner.
As for the above items, yes, they are all done by Catholics and do represent most of the devotions that anyone would call standard. For myself, some are benign and I don't give them much thought. That would include celebrating special days such as the Assumption and the Immaculate Conception (although I don't believe there were such events) and, I might add, naming churches and having pictures, etc.
On the other hand, the rosary and the scapular are dedicated to her, not God, and are supposed to confer certain spiritual benefits, again through the power of the saint. That's superstition. Kneeling or lighting a candle (what does lighting a candle FOR her mean, anyway?), or May festivals, are probably not wrong when considered individually. But when all are present in a culture of devotion to the Virgin, along with such pious legends about Mary as considering her a co-redeemer of the world, ever-Virgin, co-mediator of all graces, Immaculately Conceived, Assumed into heaven bodily, plus the fascination with supposed images of her appearing in window rerflections and so on, and it's way over the line. It's far more than mere honor.
In short, that's wrong IMO, and it's made worse by being based upon nothing verifiable. It's just folklore that's perpetuated by the church because of the presumption that heightening devotion to Mary is more important than how it's done. It verges upon worship, to say the least. Nor does it become better if one thinks to himself that there is also a higher kind of worship intended for God.
As I said much closer to the start of our little talk, it's not a matter of honoring or not honoring her; it's how much and in what manner.
I'm ok with that, ... you are free to seek Jesus and God according to the lights that God has given you but I encourage you to inform your conscience more on how God has revealed Himself to us. The Bible is not the only mode of transmitting the Word of God. This is not taught in Sacred Writing. I hope that you are able to admit this.Right. We now come to the part where we disagree and there's probably no way for one of us to win over the other, so we can just say that we were able to air the issues in a calm, organized manner.
Dogmas for Catholics are the Word of God ... They are Divinely Revealed ... no one made them up. This is why these Truths or events are so celebrated. It is part of the Gospel. Any part of the Gospel touches on the whole of it like a seamless thread.As for the above items, yes, they are all done by Catholics and do represent most of the devotions that anyone would call standard. For myself, some are benign and I don't give them much thought. That would include celebrating special days such as the Assumption and the Immaculate Conception (although I don't believe there were such events) and, I might add, naming churches and having pictures, etc.
The Rosary ... is the very prayer of the Gospel ... what do you have against the Gospel? The scapular is not worn for any kind of magical purposes and it is not superstitious. There are promises attached to it though by our Lady. Is it wrong to believe in the promises made by the Mother of our Saviour?On the other hand, the rosary and the scapular are dedicated to her, not God, and are supposed to confer certain spiritual benefits, again through the power of the saint. That's superstition.
This is piety and the expression of love and affection for our Mother in the order of grace. That's right May is called the month of Mary. See how much we love our Blessed Mother?Kneeling or lighting a candle (what does lighting a candle FOR her mean, anyway?), or May festivals, are probably not wrong when considered individually.
I covered this before in a previous post in this thread. All who are baptized have a participation in the mission of Christ the Redeemer. Mary has a participation in a manner Par Excellence. "CO-" ... does that mean anything to you? ... We are not calling Holy Mary the Redeemer of the human race.But when all are present in a culture of devotion to the Virgin, along with such pious legends about Mary as considering her a co-redeemer of the world
This is definitely Biblical., ever-Virgin,
Amen, ... that is, Mediatrix of all graces. That is, God has willed to give us ALL through Mary ... This is seen by the fact that He gave us His Only Begotten Son through Mary and through her consent and through her Immaculate Womb. Thus, all the graces that every comes to me or you or anyone comes from God Most High, through Jesus Christ, In the Holy Spirit, ... but before it reaches us they first pass by the hands of the Immaculate Mary. This is true whether you honor Mary or not. There is no grace that ever comes to man that does not first pass by Holy Mary. I believe that it was Calvin that called Mary the treasurer of all graces? (I'm not sure but I think it was him.)co-mediator of all graces,
Amen. Just read real closely Gen 3:15 and examine the greek of St. Luke 1:28.Immaculately Conceived,
Amen again, ... Just look at Rev. 12:1, 5.Assumed into heaven bodily,
The Church does not approve every single theory out there. If people seen something that's up to their own conscience to decide.plus the fascination with supposed images of her appearing in window rerflections and so on,
Says who? NOT the Holy Spirit. In fact, I am ashamed that I do not render a more true devotion to the Mother of Immanuel (God-With-Us).and it's way over the line. It's far more than mere honor.
Divine Tradition [not human tradition] is the Word of God whether you believe it or not. [see 2 Thes. 2:15, 1 Thes. 2:13]In short, that's wrong IMO, and it's made worse by being based upon nothing verifiable.
It's just folklore that's perpetuated by the church because of the presumption that heightening devotion to Mary is more important than how it's done. It verges upon worship, to say the least. Nor does it become better if one thinks to himself that there is also a higher kind of worship intended for God.
As I said much closer to the start of our little talk, it's not a matter of honoring or not honoring her; it's how much and in what manner.
<staff edit>
Why do you feel that way about the Blessed Virgin Mary? She is the Mother of the Second Person of the Most Holy and Undivided Trinity. Does that affect you at all?Being completely honest , I cringe every time I read and see Holy, Blessed, Our Mother, etc. in front of Mary .
A line is being crossed by Catholics that should never be crossed .
And AHJE , the majority the practices you listed regarding veneration of Mary are atrociously idolatrous . I don't understand how you can't realize that . Veneration of Mary and saints simply is not biblical , don't do it .