• Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.

The Status of Secular Music Forum

What should the status be of the Secular Music Forum?

  • It should remain as it is, Christians only.

  • The status should change and allow Christians and non-Christians to post.

  • Undecided


Results are only viewable after voting.

blackwasp

Skinless
Nov 18, 2003
4,104
95
40
Midwest
Visit site
✟4,736.00
Faith
Atheist
Politics
US-Others
neenie said:
why did you vote christians only? Why vote at all? What is your purpose here? Do you think the whole forum should be removed because of "your" "opinion" of you see the bible?
Every CF member who posts on the Secular forum is entitled to his/her vote.
 
Upvote 0

DJ_Ghost

Trad Goth
Mar 27, 2004
2,737
170
54
Durham
Visit site
✟18,686.00
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Engaged
Politics
UK-Liberal-Democrats
blackwasp said:
Every CF member who posts on the Secular forum is entitled to his/her vote.

I think Neennies point was why vote "Christians only" when he feels the forum should not be here at all. Not to imply that he was not entitled to a vote, but to question the legitimacy of registering a vote that does not, actualy, reflect his intentions.

Ghost
 
Upvote 0

brettnolan

Senior Member
Dec 16, 2003
678
31
56
KC, MO
✟23,484.00
Faith
Protestant
Marital Status
Single
DON'T MOVE IT PLEEEEAAASE!!!

I love nadro, and his opinions are excellent and well thought out, but I rarely venture out of the Christians only section anymore for two reasons.

1 - for me it serves as a stumbling block on some issues, I get angry, I become doubtful and most importantly I take my eyes off Christ for my own selfish pride.

2 - unfortunately, while not the case across the board, there are many non-christian posters who are, let's just say, less than tolerant of Christians and our "silly" notions.

I think the dialogue here is good on topics that relate to Christians. I would like another option. Perhaps add a music forum is the non-Christian section and combine all the Christian only music forums into one.
 
Reactions: ps139
Upvote 0

peanutbutter12

Senior Veteran
Oct 14, 2002
5,156
237
✟29,037.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Private
MOVE IT PLEEEEAAASE!!!

I love nadro, and his opinions are excellent and well thought out, And I always venture out of the Xians only section anymore for a few reasons.

1 - Because Xians aren't the only ones who have good, thought out ideas and conversations, much to the argument of others around. I have had some of my best conversations with non-believers where as Xian's like to be put in a little box away from them because they are afraid to let them see that they aren't perfect and don't have all the answers after all.

2 - Because sometimes you get a few flamers, but sometimes you also get people who are genuinly interested in what we have to say and might be looking for answers themselves. It would be wrong of us to push them away. Did God push us away when we were horrid swine who only looked to ourselves and lived for ourselves?

3. Because it would make people like PreacherFergy, blackwasp, and bretnolan mad and hopefully stop posting all together in a part of the forum they are against and only constantly whine about to people who come here to discuss. It would take them out of their little self build comfort zone a little more and maybe see that there is more to life than inside their little box of safety that they hide behind.

Personally, I think the whole forum should be open to everyone. What kind of message is sent when someone who is an non-believer comes here and sees "You can't chat here cause you aren't saved." That's total c***. "You can't come to church cause you're not a Xian!" "You can't follow me around and watch my miracles because you didn't believe me the first time I said I was God!" Even His own disciples doubted Him!

Granted, there is a place for discussion and a place for debate and it should be made known in the rules, but I think the place needs to be open for everyone, Xian and non, to chat freely about issues of faith. The message that a lot of people send here is that we are better than everyone else. The fact is that in my years preaching and living out on my own, I found more help and security in those who wern't saved because of that fact. Because we aren't perfect and we can call ourselves saved and still make mistakes or be selfish.

Yeh, the world may have this mega revival, but I have yet to see the masses who step up getting saved.

CJ
 
Upvote 0

brettnolan

Senior Member
Dec 16, 2003
678
31
56
KC, MO
✟23,484.00
Faith
Protestant
Marital Status
Single
 
Upvote 0

blackwasp

Skinless
Nov 18, 2003
4,104
95
40
Midwest
Visit site
✟4,736.00
Faith
Atheist
Politics
US-Others
Now wait just a cotton-picking minute. If you took the time to look at any posts of mine in the Secular Forum outside of the ones where Fergy is attacked you would realize that I am all for secular music. If anything, I don't believe in christian 'entertainment' music. However, because I support posts that are based on scripture rather than ones that flame, I'm stuck in the christian bubble? Please take a look at my other posts in CF before making a sweeping generalization of my beliefs.
 
Upvote 0

ps139

Ab omni malo, libera nos, Domine!
Sep 23, 2003
15,088
818
New Jersey
Visit site
✟45,407.00
Faith
Catholic
Marital Status
Single
 
Upvote 0

ps139

Ab omni malo, libera nos, Domine!
Sep 23, 2003
15,088
818
New Jersey
Visit site
✟45,407.00
Faith
Catholic
Marital Status
Single
One more point, its not like this is the only forum on the internet where secular music is discusses. A member of CF can be a member of another forum if he pleases. If this forum is Christian only it isnt restricting any nonChristians from talking about music, as there are hundreds of music forums they can join.
 
Reactions: Neenie
Upvote 0

* kittie *

Contributor
Oct 19, 2002
6,315
385
✟31,671.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Private
i agree with that ^.

however, in the case that the forum is moved, there should be rules.
actually, even if it isn't, there still should be rules. i see arguing around that..hmm...shouldn't be there. i've gotten headaches from those.
 
Upvote 0

peanutbutter12

Senior Veteran
Oct 14, 2002
5,156
237
✟29,037.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Private
I was going by what was posted in the past few threads. Ya'll wanna keep it "specifically for Xians" when it should be for everyone. I guess then that only people who have memorized the Bible can come to church.

It's my job to come dangerousely close to lines. It ticks ppl off and makes them think for a moment. I appriciate that people agree with me sometimes when I say something. It shows they are using their brains instead of just doing what the church tells them to do and what not to do. Too often does a church mislead its people. I've seen it too many times to be able to put up with it. They follow blindly because if the pastor said it, it must be right.

And blackwasp, I was under the impression you were taking sides for a while with Fergy. Please let me know if I took that the wrong way.

CJ
 
Upvote 0

* kittie *

Contributor
Oct 19, 2002
6,315
385
✟31,671.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Private
TerraSin said:
It's my job to come dangerousely close to lines. It ticks ppl off and makes them think for a moment.

CJ
haha you are so cool.
I like it when I see people think for themselves, instead of rely on what he or she said.

Now I bet some people are going to jump and speak against that, but you all need to remember that this doesn't mean that we're ignoring the Bible. And really, we're not stupid people who live mindlessly either. We do search things out.

What's sad isn't people listening to secular music.
It's sad that people have put up these limitations that aren't there. In my personal experience, I have found that when I live like that, I limit God. And really, all my belief becomes then is...religion.
Search things out for yourself. Until then, let's not criticize others.
 
Upvote 0
D

DMBfanLongliveStrongBad!

Guest
yeah, i feel bad that non christians can't post here, but i just can't stand the environment of the "co-ed" forums. I just don't want every thread here to turn into a theology debate, rather than a place where we can talk about music we like, or get other christian's opinions of what music we should listen to from a biblical standpoint.
 
Upvote 0

DJ_Ghost

Trad Goth
Mar 27, 2004
2,737
170
54
Durham
Visit site
✟18,686.00
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Engaged
Politics
UK-Liberal-Democrats
I don't think the Secular music forum belongs in the Christian only section at all. The argument that we get other christians views on what music we "should" listen to does nothing for me, becasue this is a forum about SECULAR music. Either we decide we don't listen to secular music at all (Like Preacher Fergie, respect to him for having the currage of his convictions, although I don't share his conclusions), or we discuss secular music opensly like everyone else.

I am made unesay by the "closset ourselves from none christians" argument as well. Christ would not approve of such an attitude in my opinion. He didn't avoid those who denied him, so we certainly have no right to either. If mixing with those who do not share your faith taxes it, grow stronger in your faith.

I hear people metnion that the open forums get flamy, i am surprised as the ones I have frequented (Games and Social science) don't tend to. There are people there that I respect greatly (Jamz667 and feral for example) that I would love to discuss music with as well. I can understand people not enjoying being attacked for their faith, but as good christians it is encumbant upon us to be open about it is it not?

Well thats how I feel, others may disagree and that is their right, but please consider my words then make up your own mind.

Ghost
 
Upvote 0

brettnolan

Senior Member
Dec 16, 2003
678
31
56
KC, MO
✟23,484.00
Faith
Protestant
Marital Status
Single
TerraSin said:
Ya'll wanna keep it "specifically for Xians" when it should be for everyone. I guess then that only people who have memorized the Bible can come to church.

I offered an alternate solution...add a music forum to the entertainment section of the open forums and leave this one here.


I have no problem with this, but I must admit I was quite ticked when I was accused of attacking the forum itself. I felt it was unfair and unfounded considering my posting history in this forum.

I still feel this forum provides a service that would not be available in the open forums. That is to offer a place where Christians can talk about "secular" music from a Christian perspective. That will be COMPLETELY lost in the open forums.

Some of the threads I have started concern why Christians don't like or don't listen to Christian music. They were not meant to condemn anyone for listening to secular music, I'm only trying to increase my understanding as to why Christians don't listen to BOTH. In any case, there is no where else to pose those questions and expect an intelligent answer.

TerraSin said:
And blackwasp, I was under the impression you were taking sides for a while with Fergy. Please let me know if I took that the wrong way.

CJ

blackwasp WAS defending Fergy on a specific issue. Namely, does a Christian have a right to judge behavior of others? I understand the point he is making, but I think in the context of defending Fergy, it gets lost. He is not defending Fergie's viewpoint, I don't think, that secular music is evil.
 
Upvote 0

Larry

Fundamentalist Christian
Mar 27, 2003
2,002
96
Visit site
✟2,635.00
Faith
Christian
ps139 said:
I tend to get headaches in areas like GA, politics, science etc - here it is a nice place to relax without dealing with that stuff.

The thing is, arguments and heated debates are not limited to the open areas. There's just as many of those type exchanges in the Christian Only forums. I see this happening in all kinds of Christian Only forums. The P/R/E and the Creation Science & Theistic Evolution forums come to mind right now.

Whoever is geniunely looking for answers would probably come to a different forum than the music one.

Precisely. And, whoever is genuinely looking for a doctrinal debate, or to debate the existance of God, or to challenge Christianity, would probably come to a different forum than the secular music forum.

Take a look at this forum. How many heated arguments do you see? Except for the few which were based on secular music in general, hardly none. Why do you think that is? Is it because we are all in agreement and all like the exact same music, just because we are all Christians? I think not. Like I mentioned, there are all kinds of arguments and heated debates going on in the Christian Only forums. So why is it that we don't see too many heated arguments in this forum? It could be that what I stated in my earlier post is true. Music is universal, spanning all barriers - religeous, political and cultural.
 
Upvote 0

brettnolan

Senior Member
Dec 16, 2003
678
31
56
KC, MO
✟23,484.00
Faith
Protestant
Marital Status
Single
DJ_Ghost said:
Either we decide we don't listen to secular music at all (Like Preacher Fergie, respect to him for having the currage of his convictions, although I don't share his conclusions), or we discuss secular music opensly like everyone else.

Discussions about whether or not you should listen to it, will not be found in other forums, the open ones in particular. Not biblically discussed in any case.


I think I made the point about needing to be stronger in one's faith. However, you won't grow your faith when constantly surrounded by influences (people, music, whatever) that are opposed to it.


Try the General Theology forum, or even the Creation/Theistic Evolution forum on the Christian-only side. We poor, stupid, naive, YECS apparently haven't the mental capacity to even be on the internet in the first place.

Create a new music forum in the open section to discuss music with those guys.

We are supposed to be able to give an answer for our hope, but everyone needs a recharge, or a safe haven. Didn't Jesus go off by himself to pray? Didn't he likely spend time with only his disciples?
 
Upvote 0