Eudaimonist
I believe in life before death!
- Jan 1, 2003
- 27,482
- 2,738
- 58
- Gender
- Male
- Faith
- Atheist
- Marital Status
- Private
- Politics
- US-Libertarian
Upvote
0
Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.
That makes no sense.
That makes no sense.
How do you distinguish works of love done by human beings from "works of love that he works in our lives through us"?
You do realise that what you said was contradictory?I don't expect you to understand. It's difficult for me to put in words, even. At best, the words point to a reality, but they are not identical to the reality. To know God, you have to deny what you know and be willing to enter into unknowing.
That doesn't answer my question. It seems to me that you have no way of distinguishing works of love done by human beings from "works of love that he works in our lives through us." Given that human beings seem capable of loving on their own, why credit this love to some supernatural being?God gives common grace to everyone as he wills. I see no contradiction. As Jesus says, the Father causes the sun to rise and the rain to fall on the just and the unjust.
You do realise that what you said was contradictory?
That doesn't answer my question. It seems to me that you have no way of distinguishing works of love done by human beings from "works of love that he works in our lives through us." Given that human beings seem capable of loving on their own, why credit this love to some supernatural being?
You asked before about how Christianity could lead to nihilism. This is how, FireDragon76. You take something that is good in human beings - their ability to love - and you steal it and hide in the vault of your theology. What happens to love when that vault is destroyed? The very ability to love is destroyed with it, along with everything else you've hidden in there.God illuminates those works and lifts them up into the sacramental mystery of his own Trinitarian life.
You asked before about how Christianity could lead to nihilism. This is how, FireDragon76. You take something that is good in human beings - their ability to love - and you steal it and hide in the vault of your theology. What happens to love when that vault is destroyed? The very ability to love is destroyed with it, along with everything else you've hidden in there.
Yes you do. That's part of what it means to be human. And yet you've taken it and locked it away in some theological box. You've given credit to someone else - credit that is not due to them - for one of humanity's most remarkable traits. Now, according to you, we can't even love without that love being credited to some supernatural agency.All I know, is that I'm a sinner in a sinful world. I don't have this ability to love and hope to extraordinary lengths that you seem to think is natural.
Yes you do. That's part of what it means to be human. .
My view is naive? Why don't you lock those "monsters" in your theological vault along with love?Your view of human nature is presumptuous and naïve. There are monsters in this world. If not for God, I would be one of them. I can feel the allure of evil every day.
My view is naive? Why don't you lock those "monsters" in your theological vault along with love?
Why wouldn't it be the other way around? Why not put the monsters in the theological box and allow humans to love naturally (as they do anyway)? You're selecting all the things you like about humanity and ripping them from it to place in your theological vault, while leaving behind all the things you don't like. When your vault is destroyed, that's all you're going to be left with.Monsters are the natural consequence of rejecting God's grace.
This is a claim.
Now, support it with evidence.
Why wouldn't it be the other way around? Why not put the monsters in the theological box and allow humans to love naturally (as they do anyway)? You're selecting all the things you like about humanity and ripping them from it to place in your theological vault, while leaving behind all the things you don't like. When your vault is destroyed, that's all you're going to be left with.
Because the vault has already crumbled, though many have yet to realise it and some pretend otherwise.What makes you think the "vault" will be destroyed? Do you have some satanic plan to rid the world of the Church of God? The Church has endured for 2,000 years, I see no reason why it won't endure for 2,000 more.
The saints are my evidence.
What makes you think the "vault" will be destroyed? Do you have some satanic plan to rid the world of the Church of God? The Church has endured for 2,000 years, I see no reason why it won't endure for 2,000 more.
Monsters are the natural consequence of rejecting God's grace.
All discussions with the intent of belittling or mocking Christians or Christianity will be promptly removed.
Wow, what misanthropy!
In my experience, people who "reject God's grace" are not significantly more likely to be monsters on average than are Christians who arguably have accepted God's grace.
eudaimonia,
Mark
And, the evidence would suggest, perhaps less likely.
I really should have started this thread in general apologetics. But for some reason I cannot post there. I really was looking for answers from other Christians, not atheists. I am very familiar with atheist arguments on this issue. This thread has become a megaphone for atheists to ridicule Christian faith. Please, I don't go to atheist forums and rant about the evils of atheism (what a waste of my time that would be)... why do those hostile to Christianity come here? To gawp at us like animals in a zoo?
I don't mind atheists posting to this forum in a respectful manner the rules of the forum should be kept in mind:
This thread, and numerous others here, have had too many instances of belittling of the Christian faith. Our faith has been compared to a crumbling edifice designed to manipulate our humanity towards nefarious ends. An image that in my mind conjure up the ghosts of the regimes of Pol Pot and Joseph Stalin, not Sunday morning at a mainline church where the most offensive thing is probably the green jello or the coffee.
You have no right to assert, without evidence, that I am a misanthrope, merely because I take an orthodox Christian position on human depravity. Lots of other Christians have done so as well, such as the late theologian and pastor Reinhold Niebhur, who made and make significant contributions in the US in the area of social justice (hardly typical for a misanthrope to care about such things). So please, stop with the bigotry.
If this is to be a philosophy forum, it must be the honest pursuit of truth (that's what philosophy is after all, the love of wisdom), and not merely a place to voice ignorant, bigoted opinions of the Christian faith.
It seems to me much more skepticism of religious claims are warranted, regardless of whether or not the Christian God exists.
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?
We use cookies and similar technologies for the following purposes:
Do you accept cookies and these technologies?