thank you. It starts with first understanding who you are and the depth of your sin against God. God is holy. We are not. It isn't just recognizing that we are sinners. It is understanding the depth of our sin and what it cost God to secure forgiveness.
THE SHORT VERSION: your counsel is right on target; I tried that, and it didn't work for me.
THE LONG VERSION: when this happened I understood all that; had even taught it to others. I had been saved for many years; I definitely understood fully the depth of my sin and our indwelling sinful nature; in fact I knew that we in fact ARE sin. We are sin through and through; and because we are sin, we think sins, we act sins, we talk sins. I had thoroughly studied and taught the truths of Romans 6,7,8, about death to Self and the old Nature, Christ our life, etc; and yet when in the middle of this, I couldn't seem to make the connection or make it apply. I probably went through Romans once a year and such deeper life works every few years. What you say is right on target, and it would be good... for the next few months. But life's stresses were cumulative. Eventually she went out of town to visit her family, and it had been a bad time; so
suddenly the thought occurred to me that I could get a few drinks and would feel better (ever heard that in AA?). I took my resentment out by finding relaxation. Nothing more probably than many guys have done by getting a few relaxing drinks after a day's stress of another kind. But because it seemed to make life much more endurable, I repeated this drinking.
I need to also explain that because I knew the Word and the spiritual process, I confessed the sin, repented of the sin, had no intentions of ever repeating it again, but when the next family visit time came near, I would begin to feel the pleasure of relaxation that comes with a few drinks, even before it came; but still nothing sinful intended. The problem was that we were t-totallers (no drinking at all). So I kept it hidden. The next problem was that it was drinking for the wrong reason - drinking AT something instead of as a casual beverage. Those are two entirely different reasons for drinking (for the non-alcoholic). The third problem was that as these times approached, unknown to me the uphoric rush I would feel at the thought of it and looking forward to it became more powerful.
This became a habit, the falling to drinking, as well as the repentance and confession; each time resolving and trying to make it more real and serious than the last time. I seriously, sincerely felt I was where I needed to be, as victorious believer, father, and husband. I was told by her family and friends of her family what a wonderful husband and father I was, not knowing that to do that meant being somewhat of a passive doormat. But that was fine with them; because this was a matriarchical family (no offense intended ladies

) and the friend families were the same. I was not an outdoorsman or macho man, but deep inside I was definitely a man, not a pansie, if that makes any sense.
What we (myself included) tend to do is hold others up to standards that we feel we have met. That way we feel confident in being critical towards them.
I need to elaborate and share that I was never resentful to her personally and didn't treat her in any way other than as I thought the model Christian husband should, and tried to be that model father. That's why it was sort of stored up and finally came out when she was gone. She had an unusually close relationship to her own family, and typically had a phone bill of $100 per month, back in the 80's & 90's; and I gladly let her do it and never complained. We went into debt 3 different times to the tune of $10,000 and took 401k funds out to pay for it, and it wasn't due to my drinking in those days (once ever 6 months drinking around $25 worth) and I didn't have any hobbies but Bible study. As for sex, I checked with a psychologist friend, and sex once every 3 weeks for a beginning marriage, people in their 20's, wasn't normal and therefore wasn't a standard I had and was holding her up to. Wanting the other person to admit at least once in a while when they're wrong, instead of having to win every discussion and point, is not an unrealistic standard I don't think either.
What I wanted was a better marriage, but it wasn't enough of an issue to bring up to anyone. Any of the godly men I knew at the time would have told me, well, something like this...
When we are honest with ourselves we will see that we are no better than those we are angry with; those who have hurt us. Our sins are just different, that's all. Jesus told the parable of the man who was forgiven much but then went out and had a man thrown into prison because of a miniscule debt by comparison. That's us when we won't forgive those who sin against us. We will make their sins against us to be worse than our sins against God. We may know better, but we do it anyway.
I'm not in any way belittling this truth, but it's very standard counsel from men to men, in the body of Christ anyway. "If there are any problems, she hasn't done anything to you as bad as you've done to Christ, so suck it up, be a man, forgive, sacrifice, be the one put upon rather than the one who puts on others. You're supposed to 'come through', because you're the man." I did talk about this with my associate pastor, and this together with the counsel you gave, is pretty much what he gave. But it didn't work, not for me, not at that time, and in spite of knowing all this by heart.
Our response to the Gospel should be a gratitude so great that it spills into our everyday life.
This is what SHOULD be; but I was living in the real world, and life wasn't what it should be either. SHE wasn't what she should be; so I was being called to ignore all that and just suck it up, go on, be a man, and take it.
That gratitude comes from a deep self-examination of our sinfulness and the great gift given to us. It can't just be surface level.
I did have such a knowledge of my sinfulness, having walked with the Lord and a student of His word for many years. But that knowledge eventually led me to ask "what's wrong with ME. Why can't I get it?"
I used to be resentful of my wife for various reasons. And I didn't understand how to be Cross-centered. Once I started to see how great a sacrifice was made for such a wretch as I, then my attitude towards my wife changed.
As I mentioned, my attitude toward my wife while around her was exemplary. So much so that all our friends at church were completely floored at the situation of my drinking; and there was no obvious reason for it. They never knew what I am relating on this site. So it just appeared that I woke up one day and decided, "hey, I've got a wonderful family, a wonderful job, a wonderful life, a wonderful spiritual and church life; and I think I'll drink myself into oblivion!" In other words, they felt fooled by me, and I was evil.
And her attitude towards me changed.
My wife's attitude toward me never changed; she thought my drinking was all my own problem; we never got anywhere when we discussed the issues of our romantic life; and she never went to counseling with me, an AA meeting, or an Al-Anon meeting. So, as you've said, I learned early on that my recovery couldn't be about whether her attitude or actions would ever change or not.
I know this is a lot to digest, but I want your response to such an individual and am interested what you will counsel him given this situation, and the fact that the above advice lasted about 3 months, then more drinking.
Thanks,
H.