• Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.

Question about Hell from another thread.

razeontherock

Well-Known Member
May 24, 2010
26,546
1,480
WI
✟35,597.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Single
Do you believe in nuns? I hear they are forever.

No seriously; what makes you so sure that hell is forever? Some people said so? Is that the best ya got? Doesn't sound like something to let sway you one way or the other. Clearly there's something there beyond what we can fathom, but what we CAN know is this: all Judgment has been given to the Son.
 
Upvote 0

drich0150

Regular Member
Mar 16, 2008
6,407
437
Florida
✟59,834.00
Country
United States
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Republican
No, it is because I read the bible, understanding what kind of literature each section is. I don't read allegorical passages literally and I don't read literal passages figuratively.

For God so loved the world, that he gave his only Son, that whoever believes in him should not perish but have eternal life.

From this verse I understand that some perish and some have eternal life. The ones who perish do not have eternal life being tortured in hell.
Perhaps you should take some of that bible discernment and turn it towards what you read in forums. Because your reply does not address any of the points I have made.
 
Upvote 0

Timothew

Conditionalist
Aug 24, 2009
9,659
844
✟36,554.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Private
Perhaps you should take some of that bible discernment and turn it towards what you read in forums. Because your reply does not address any of the points I have made.
Wow, why this hostility? You haven't posted in any threads I've been posting in for at least 4 months. I checked. You did post once in this thread, but I answered you kindly and well. I showed the bible passage that I got my belief from. Of course there are many other bible passages that support my beliefs. My belief comes directly from what I read in the bible.

I don't know what makes you so hostile, but do I really need to be the target for your anger? As a matter of fact, I am always happy to answer questions, and give the biblical support for what I believe.
 
Upvote 0

Timothew

Conditionalist
Aug 24, 2009
9,659
844
✟36,554.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Private
This was your question/statement:
There are those who do not know how to incorporate the Hell described in the bible into their understanding of God, and then there are some who get to go. Why? I suspect it is to help balance out the notion that Love and righteousness can not coexist with in the same God.
Here is my reply:
No, it is because I read the bible, understanding what kind of literature each section is. I don't read allegorical passages literally and I don't read literal passages figuratively.

For God so loved the world, that he gave his only Son, that whoever believes in him should not perish but have eternal life.

From this verse I understand that some perish and some have eternal life. The ones who perish do not have eternal life being tortured in hell.
How is it that you think I'm not addressing your point? You think that I believe something for one reason (Can't balance God's Love and Righteousness) when really I believe something for a different reason (I read it in the bible).
 
Upvote 0

drich0150

Regular Member
Mar 16, 2008
6,407
437
Florida
✟59,834.00
Country
United States
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Republican
Wow, why this hostility?
I believe you are projecting. I simply said that if you take such great care as to read the bible it would also help you to take some care and apply it to what is written here.

You haven't posted in any threads I've been posting in for at least 4 months. I checked. You did post once in this thread, but I answered you kindly and well.
What does it matter when the last time I posted or you posted or we posted together??? I honestly do not understand. Unless you have convinced yourself of hostility or a need for revenge, when their indeed isn't any..

I showed the bible passage that I got my belief from. Of course there are many other bible passages that support my beliefs. My belief comes directly from what I read in the bible.
:) Do you honestly think everyone else simply has misread their bible?


I don't know what makes you so hostile, but do I really need to be the target for your anger? As a matter of fact, I am always happy to answer questions, and give the biblical support for what I believe
Perhaps I can offer a solution for this "emotion" that has been introduced in this thread. You need God to be the compassionate God you have created because not everyone you know is going to Heaven. And when anyone objects or points to the possibility the your interpretation of ONE verse maybe wrong, or is dismissed as wishful thinking especially in light of ALLLL of the other verses that contradict the belief you need to continue to love God. Which is fine if you need this i will not take it from you, just know there is freedom joy past an all compassionate God if you learn to trust Him.


New topic:
I am one of those crazy people who got to goto Hell for a brief time. Or rather "I got to peer in to the Gate." My personal feeling was (While being consumed by the black darkness) that what made me, Me. my mind, my soul would loose cohesion shortly after the pearly gate closed and the last rays of creation were sealed off forever.

It was because our souls, the ability to exist, was a gift from God. It is apart of creation. Hell is the absents of creation. I would be gone or consumed by Hell, but the core elements of my essence (The animal instincts for lack of a better term) would remain.

Hell is a Big place. It is big enough to encapsulate both understandings of it even if you/we are not able to.

(Again no hostility just another observation, and if you do have people going there i am sorry for the coarseness of my words, but it is what it is. We all have a decision to make. We all have loved ones going there.)

You will never be free to completely Love God withal of your being if you are dictating terms to God. Like God Can Not Be a God WHO sends people to Hell for eternal Damination...

The Lord Gives and the Lord Takes Blessed be the Name of the Lord. We are His Vessels to do with as it pleases Him. For me I does not matter what He does, because I know that no matter what it is, it is Good. Even if I can not understand it to be good. Place your trust and understanding in God, and you will not be disappointed.
 
Upvote 0

drich0150

Regular Member
Mar 16, 2008
6,407
437
Florida
✟59,834.00
Country
United States
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Republican
This was your question/statement:

Here is my reply:

How is it that you think I'm not addressing your point? You think that I believe something for one reason (Can't balance God's Love and Righteousness) when really I believe something for a different reason (I read it in the bible).


Because in my statement i sought an understanding and balance (I think I even used that word) of the scriptures that can mean Eternal life in Hell and those that can be understood that Hell is a temporary place. You sought to correct a statement that did not exist. In that You assumed that i was of the thought that Hell was eternal for those who were sent there.

Because you did not speak to the balance i was trying to achieve, in concert with the two post you wrote and the two PM you sent calling me a troll and telling me to silence myself or apologize to you, I drew the conclusion that you misunderstood the body of my efforts here.

Here is the copy of the PM:
mistaken identity or merely trolling?
Either you have the wrong person, or you are just trolling.

Here's the post. http://www.christianforums.com/t7632580-5/#post59884453

Tell me you made a mistake, or go away and rethink your attitude.
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0

Timothew

Conditionalist
Aug 24, 2009
9,659
844
✟36,554.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Private
Here is what I object to:
Perhaps you should take some of that bible discernment and turn it towards what you read in forums.
My replies to people are kind and thoughtful. My "discernment" doesn't stop when I read CF.
your reply does not address any of the points I have made.
You didn't make any points in any thread I posted in so how could I address them? You made it seem as if I lost a debate when I didn't even know you and I were debating anything. The first thing I see from you is an accusation of not addressing your points. What am I to think? I think that either you are addressing someone else other than me, or you are just trying to get a rise out of me, ie trolling.

If you have questions about what I believe, why don't you ask me?
 
Upvote 0

drich0150

Regular Member
Mar 16, 2008
6,407
437
Florida
✟59,834.00
Country
United States
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Republican
Here is what I object to:

My replies to people are kind and thoughtful. My "discernment" doesn't stop when I read CF.

You didn't make any points in any thread I posted in so how could I address them? You made it seem as if I lost a debate when I didn't even know you and I were debating anything. The first thing I see from you is an accusation of not addressing your points. What am I to think?
You do realize all of this is contained with in Your mind.

I think that either you are addressing someone else other than me, or you are just trying to get a rise out of me, ie trolling.
What I am guilty of is showing those who challenge an equally challenging statement based on the body of work they themselves initially posted. It is a philosophy based on the do unto others rule. When I challenge I look to have someone answer that challenge in kind. I do not want a watered down version of what they are saying i want to go straight to the meat of the conversation. So I have extended you this same courtesy.

If you have questions about what I believe, why don't you ask me?
The "meat." I know what you believe, it is spelled out all over this thread. It represents a person who does not understand a God who can potentially cause a soul to suffer for eternity, so you have sought out the proof you need to hang on to the idea that God is the God you want Him to be.

(Now the seeking out the Balance; )

The only question I have is what if He is not that God? What if Souls burn for eternity, and it pleases Him to put them there? Will you be OK with that?
 
Upvote 0

Ernst Junger

Junior Member
Feb 19, 2012
258
6
✟512.00
Faith
Christian Seeker
Marital Status
Private
Why does God, being a righteous Judge and all, make Him sadistic? Why are His punishments "evil?" By what standard are we judging God? Where does that standard come from? Are we fit to judge Him?

As per Hell, I believe it's only torment because by definition, it's the absence of God's presence (of course He's omnipresent, but He doesn't associate or show Himself to anyone there). That would mean it's void of love, joy, peace, righteousness, purity, etc. so logically that leaves...


In most standard theologies, yes there is humiliation via the separation of God until the end of time. Then the righteous and the wicked are alike resurrected into physical bodies, and the wicked are tossed into a physical lake of fire and are tortured by corporeal flame. In most standard theologies.
 
Upvote 0

Timothew

Conditionalist
Aug 24, 2009
9,659
844
✟36,554.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Private
The only question I have is what if He is not that God? What if Souls burn for eternity, and it pleases Him to put them there? Will you be OK with that?
You ask this question because you think I've rejected the God of the bible, but I haven't.

The fact is that the bible doesn't describe God as being a God who tortures people in fire. Why are you not OK with that?
 
Upvote 0

drich0150

Regular Member
Mar 16, 2008
6,407
437
Florida
✟59,834.00
Country
United States
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Republican
You ask this question because you think I've rejected the God of the bible, but I haven't.

The fact is that the bible doesn't describe God as being a God who tortures people in fire. Why are you not OK with that?

Again I am not arguing that God will burn people forever. Truthfully I do not personally know for sure. My argument is a different one all together. I am asking will you, can you still love God if it pleases Him to burn people in Hell forever? Does God have that authority in your life?

This is the problem I am addressing, because in the end it does not matter how we twist the bible to accommodate our personal beliefs. The bottom line is can you love God even if you judge what He is doing to be wrong? This is the issue and this is what needs to be balanced.

Otherwise know you are dictating terms to God. If you can not love God with all of your Heart, Mind, Spirit, and strength if He (in this case) burns people in Hell for an eternity, then you know are putting a condition on your faith or belief. The next question should be; Can one have a truth faith/Love for God if God has to meet terms and conditions to be considered to be worthy of worship?

With the proper perspective, it does not matter what happens to the people in Hell, Heaven or any other scenario or circumstance. Because the Righteous and Most Holy God will determine what is right. If we truly have faith in God then we can re assuredly accept any judgment He may levy on any of us.
 
Upvote 0

Timothew

Conditionalist
Aug 24, 2009
9,659
844
✟36,554.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Private
Again I am not arguing that God will burn people forever. Truthfully I do not personally know for sure. My argument is a different one all together. I am asking will you, can you still love God if it pleases Him to burn people in Hell forever? Does God have that authority in your life?

This is the problem I am addressing, because in the end it does not matter how we twist the bible to accommodate our personal beliefs. The bottom line is can you love God even if you judge what He is doing to be wrong? This is the issue and this is what needs to be balanced.

Otherwise know you are dictating terms to God. If you can not love God with all of your Heart, Mind, Spirit, and strength if He (in this case) burns people in Hell for an eternity, then you know are putting a condition on your faith or belief. The next question should be; Can one have a truth faith/Love for God if God has to meet terms and conditions to be considered to be worthy of worship?

With the proper perspective, it does not matter what happens to the people in Hell, Heaven or any other scenario or circumstance. Because the Righteous and Most Holy God will determine what is right. If we truly have faith in God then we can re assuredly accept any judgment He may levy on any of us.
You are asking me if I could love God even if it turns out that God is not good. Would you still love God if you found out that God is evil?

Alright, I'll answer your question, even though it is misleading.
No, I would not love God if it turned out that God was evil. No matter what the result of not loving an evil god turns out to be. If this supposed evil god decides to give me eternal life just to torture me forever in flames without mercy, I would spend every second of that eternal life in flames not loving the evil god that you have imagined. Not loving the evil god is the right thing to do. Worshipping this evil god would be idolatry.

Now that I've answered your weird hypothetical scenario, I get to ask you one. If someone you knew was torturing babies by setting them on fire would you support the person doing this?
 
Upvote 0

drich0150

Regular Member
Mar 16, 2008
6,407
437
Florida
✟59,834.00
Country
United States
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Republican
You are asking me if I could love God even if it turns out that God is not good.
No I am asking you is What if God is not YOUR VERSION of Good. Meaning what if your version of Righteousness did not match His?

Would you still love God if you found out that God is evil?
You do not seem to understand the concept.

Sin is anything not in the Expressed will of God
Evil is a malicious intent to commit sin.

God can not be evil because He can not be outside of His own expressed Will.

In Short that means anything God wants or Does is by default "good."
No matter what that is. "Good" is not a standard or value that has any merit outside of the expressed will of God. That means, If I am in a position to judge God "evil" then I know it can't be by His standard in which I judge Him. My next question is If I am judging God apart from His own Righteousness then who's righteousness am I using?

The short answer is my own. I nor anyone else is in a position to judge God by our own self righteousness.


Alright, I'll answer your question, even though it is misleading.
No, I would not love God if it turned out that God was evil.
Not the questioned i asked. This is a straw man you have created, to side skirt the real issue. My question points to the authority in which you deem God evil. Again I am asking will you judge God with an "righteousness" apart from His own? Will you judge God by your own self righteous standard?

Can God ever be wrong? Now what if you wittiness something He did and perceived it as wrong? Who is right? you or God? Why?

No matter what the result of not loving an evil god turns out to be. If this supposed evil god decides to give me eternal life just to torture me forever in flames without mercy, I would spend every second of that eternal life in flames not loving the evil god that you have imagined. Not loving the evil god is the right thing to do. Worshiping this evil god would be idolatry.
Again this whole presupposition is based on a straw man argument you created. I asked that you Tell me how you can ever be in a position to Judge God. I am not talking about speculative doctrine about the eternal nature of Hell. I am asking from where would you get the authority if God openly and with pleasure sentenced people to eternal Hell, and you got to witnessed it?

Now that I've answered your weird hypothetical scenario, I get to ask you one. If someone you knew was torturing babies by setting them on fire would you support the person doing this?
Person no, God Yes.
 
Upvote 0

Timothew

Conditionalist
Aug 24, 2009
9,659
844
✟36,554.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Private
No I am asking you is What if God is not YOUR VERSION of Good. Meaning what if your version of Righteousness did not match His?


You do not seem to understand the concept.

Sin is anything not in the Expressed will of God
Evil is a malicious intent to commit sin.

God can not be evil because He can not be outside of His own expressed Will.

In Short that means anything God wants or Does is by default "good."
No matter what that is. "Good" is not a standard or value that has any merit outside of the expressed will of God. That means, If I am in a position to judge God "evil" then I know it can't be by His standard in which I judge Him. My next question is If I am judging God apart from His own Righteousness then who's righteousness am I using?

The short answer is my own. I nor anyone else is in a position to judge God by our own self righteousness.


Not the questioned i asked. This is a straw man you have created, to side skirt the real issue. My question points to the authority in which you deem God evil. Again I am asking will you judge God with an "righteousness" apart from His own? Will you judge God by your own self righteous standard?

Can God ever be wrong? Now what if you wittiness something He did and perceived it as wrong? Who is right? you or God? Why?


Again this whole presupposition is based on a straw man argument you created. I asked that you Tell me how you can ever be in a position to Judge God. I am not talking about speculative doctrine about the eternal nature of Hell. I am asking from where would you get the authority if God openly and with pleasure sentenced people to eternal Hell, and you got to witnessed it?

Person no, God Yes.

OK, show me the verse in the bible that says "God tortures people forever and ever". After you show me that verse, I will admit that torturing people is good, because God does it, and I will start torturing people right away. As soon as I see the verse. Good Luck.
 
Upvote 0

drich0150

Regular Member
Mar 16, 2008
6,407
437
Florida
✟59,834.00
Country
United States
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Republican
OK, show me the verse in the bible that says "God tortures people forever and ever". After you show me that verse, I will admit that torturing people is good, because God does it, and I will start torturing people right away. As soon as I see the verse. Good Luck.
Again, you are creating another straw man to avoid dealing with the true issue.

The issue being you are not willing to submit to the Authority of God in whatever decision He makes. You have in your mind who God should be, and if He is no who you think He is then to you, He is not God. (Per your last post)

This would indicate that you are Prizing your own version of Righteousness over that of God's. Your attitude should be that of Job in that if the Lord Gives or the Lord takes blessed be the name of God. One can not love his Lord God with all of his Heart, Mind, Spirit, and strength, If he has exclusion clauses tying God to his personal idea of morality. One Must yield to the authority of God's righteousness, no matter what that might look like to him personally. Otherwise know it is not the God of the bible you serve. It is one you have created from some of the facts found in scripture.

Again I am not dealing with any specific doctrine, but the attitude you have that restricts the Authority and actions of God, defined not by His righteous authority, but by your own.
 
Upvote 0

Timothew

Conditionalist
Aug 24, 2009
9,659
844
✟36,554.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Private
Again, you are creating another straw man to avoid dealing with the true issue.

The issue being you are not willing to submit to the Authority of God in whatever decision He makes. You have in your mind who God should be, and if He is no who you think He is then to you, He is not God. (Per your last post)

This would indicate that you are Prizing your own version of Righteousness over that of God's. Your attitude should be that of Job in that if the Lord Gives or the Lord takes blessed be the name of God. One can not love his Lord God with all of his Heart, Mind, Spirit, and strength, If he has exclusion clauses tying God to his personal idea of morality. One Must yield to the authority of God's righteousness, no matter what that might look like to him personally. Otherwise know it is not the God of the bible you serve. It is one you have created from some of the facts found in scripture.

Again I am not dealing with any specific doctrine, but the attitude you have that restricts the Authority and actions of God, defined not by His righteous authority, but by your own.
I want you to know something. The image I have of who God is comes from the revelation of scripture and from observing the very image of God Himself in the person of Jesus, the Christ. This is not my own preferenceor attitudes. For you to assume otherwise without knowing anything about me shows a critical and judgmental attitude on your part, but does nothing to say anything about me or what I think of God.

So when I say "Show me in the bible where it says God is going to torture anyone, it is not a strawman argument.
The Nature of God as revealed in scripture is the exact issue we are discussing. You believe God will torture people for all eternity, and think that I think less of God because I don't believe this. The fact is that I have discovered by studying scripture that God does not torture anyone for all eternity.
 
Upvote 0

drich0150

Regular Member
Mar 16, 2008
6,407
437
Florida
✟59,834.00
Country
United States
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Republican
I want you to know something. The image I have of who God is comes from the revelation of scripture and from observing the very image of God Himself in the person of Jesus, the Christ.
In turn I want you to accept that this "revelation" is little more than a personal interpretation. You have taken scripture and built an image of God. There is nothing wrong with this because this is what we are to do.

Where the problem/sin lies is when personal Pride Demands God conform to your idea of what He should look like. That God should conform to the idea you have created for Him to fill.
The idea that God can not exist outside of your interpretation of Him is foolishness. Therefore we must at some level yield to the Authority of God even if it goes beyond our current understanding of Him. If we are faithful to what we have been given, our blessings will increase. However if we bury what we have been entrusted with what we have will be taken from us.
If you deny God's true authority in your life. The authority to define and control all righteousness, (This means God tells us what right and wrong is and we do not tell or judge Him.) then know what you have been given is endanger of being taken away.

This is not my own preferenceor attitudes. For you to assume otherwise without knowing anything about me shows a critical and judgmental attitude on your part, but does nothing to say anything about me or what I think of God.
:) I've simply asked questions, and warned you what would happen if your heart lies in the areas you have created straw men to hide, or simply avoided. The conviction you feel does not come from me, for you are 100% correct I do not know you or what you truly think. I am only speaking of the darkness you are doing your best to not talk about. Everything else you mentioned is happening with in your own heart.


So when I say "Show me in the bible where it says God is going to torture anyone, it is not a straw man argument.
It is because what we are discussing has nothing to do with Hell. We are Speaking of God's ultimate authority, and if He has the Authority in your picture of God to cast people into Hell, and if He did and it pleased Him to do so (As it pleased Him to have His son hang on the cross) Would you Could you worship Him as God?

The Fact of the matter or the issue at Hand is whether or not God has the ability to cast people into an eternal Hell, and still be God in your eyes, In your Heart.

The Fact you are desperately trying to make this about scripture is the definition of a Straw Man Argument. In that you are misrepresenting your opponents argument in order to argue something (The Straw Man) you are more prepared to do. Again you are not in a position to Argue or apparently even talk about what you would do if, you grossly misinterpreted God's intentions on the subject of eternal Damnation. So you want to make this an argument of the scripture it self. And then subsequently try and convince me has you have convinced yourself.

Again the subject at hand is God's authority in your life. Not what or how we interpret His intentions.
We should have an Idea of what the bible says, but we should not love this idea over God Himself.

The Nature of God as revealed in scripture is the exact issue we are discussing.
No it is NOT! We are discussing the pride one has to have to believe God must fit your own image in order to be God.

This is made apparent by the question I have asked 5 times now. What if God does something you believe is wrong. How do you judge God to be wrong if you do not use His own standard? I am showing you that if you do not Judge God by His standards, His Expressed Will, you are indeed using your own personal version of Righteousness to Judge God. In other words you are using your own self righteousness to judge the actions of God if they do not fit what you believe God's actions to be.

You believe God will torture people for all eternity, and think that I think less of God because I don't believe this.
This is a complete and desperate lie. I have, in this thread, said 3 different times I do not know how long one's experience of Hell lasts. I even shared my personal experience and personal revelation from Hell saying that when those in Hell are sealed off from the rest of creation that "they" in a sense are completely consumed.
What are you to argue now that i have said for the 4th time i agree with you? Will you just misrepresent my position to me again in hopes that I will get confused so you do not have to face your demons?

It is not out of pride or self satisfaction that I write these things to you. I see a potentially relationship ending fatal flaw in your general theology, and I ask that if it does exist that you take this flaw to God and ask Him to help you sort it out. If you ask seek and knock as the persistent neighbor did in Luke 11, you will eventually sort it out with the help of God. But it does not stop there. Next I ask that you take this revelation to the place that taught you to prize personal revelation over that of God Himself, and makes changes there on His behalf..

The fact is that I have discovered by studying scripture that God does not torture anyone for all eternity.
So, what if you and your studies are wrong? What if me and my personal revelation is wrong? What if God did keep everyone alive and fully aware so they could feel every moment of Hell for ever and ever? What if it pleased Him to do this? Would you still Love God with all of your Heart,Mind, Spirit, and Strength? Will you bless the Name of God if He takes away as Job Did? or will you only praise His name when things happen the way you think they should?

Is God the ultimate authority in your life or is the idea of God you have created the ultimate authority in your life?

Can God exist beyond your understanding of Him?
 
Upvote 0

Timothew

Conditionalist
Aug 24, 2009
9,659
844
✟36,554.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Private
You keep on assuming that I believe what I believe about God because that it what I want to believe about God. This is not true.

You might as well ask me, "If Satan were God, would you serve him?" or "If Straw Men were Gods, would you serve them?" or "If roasted chicken were gods would you serve them?" :yum:
 
Upvote 0