My Lunar Challenge

[MrJDSmith]

Well, I've asked for evidence that the moon was created ex nihilo; and I've gotten 16 pages of nihilo.

I'm going to go ahead, per my OP, and assume you guys cannot produce any.

The reason for this thread, is that I intend to QV people to this thread from now on, instead of my Apple Challenge thread.

In effect, it replaces my Apple Challenge.

Because

What would you accept as evidence?

Absolutely nothing --- there isn't any, in my opinion --- and never was.

 

[AV1611VET]

What do you intend for this thread to prove? What I mean is, it's not proving anything, so you'll have to make something up. What is it going to be?

I use it whenever I see anyone asking someone to show them evidence (or 'proof') of creation.

I have always contended that the Creation Week left no evidence behind, and that God did not use science to create this universe.

Evidently you guys agree with me.

 

[The Lady Kate]

I use it whenever I see anyone asking someone to show them evidence (or 'proof') of creation.

I have always contended that the Creation Week left no evidence behind, and that God did not use science to create this universe.

Evidently you guys agree with me.

How do you get that out of people finding your "challenge" asinine and pointless?

 

[Thistlethorn]

I use it whenever I see anyone asking someone to show them evidence (or 'proof') of creation.

I have always contended that the Creation Week left no evidence behind, and that God did not use science to create this universe.

Evidently you guys agree with me.

This sort of "logic" doesn't impress anyone but you, AV. It's entirely silly, and a bastardization of rational thinking. Well done, you have sunk even lower than before.

 

[Freodin]

How do you get that out of people finding your "challenge" asinine and pointless?

It´s a linguistic game. An old salesman trick: get the customer to agree with something seemingly obvious without revealing the hidden meaning. He won´t deny something that he just agreed with.

Of course "we guys" agree that God did not "use" science (how do you do that, I would have to ask?) in the creation of this universe and we also agree that the creation week left no evidence, don´t we? We do not believe these things are real, so they could not "use science" or "leave evidence", could they?

But this "agreement" fails at its central point: it is not what is done by the object in question here, it is its existence.

Or it is eqally evident that AV agrees with "us guys" that the Invisible Pink Unicorn (oops, did I just mention the one who must not be named here?) did not do the same horrible crimes that the Christian God did?

It is the famous question of how to stop beating your wife when you are not married.

 

[gaara4158]

I use it whenever I see anyone asking someone to show them evidence (or 'proof') of creation.

I have always contended that the Creation Week left no evidence behind, and that God did not use science to create this universe.

Evidently you guys agree with me.

Lack of evidence is one thing. Evidence of something else is quite another.

 

[gaara4158]

edit: double post

 

[AV1611VET]

AV, it seriously looks like you need to get a job. *wink*

Thank you!

Would you tell that to my next interviewer, please?

 

[gaara4158]

Thank you!

Would you tell that to my next interviewer, please?

you and me both, man.

 

[AV1611VET]

* BUMP *
​

Show me evidence that the moon was created ex nihilo.

I will take your word on it if you say that none exists.

 

[Freodin]

* BUMP *
​

Shameless.

I refer you to my last post in this thread, which you also didn´t "dignify" with an answer.

It is a linguistic game, nothing more.


Or how about you showing me the evidence that you were cloned from A.E. Neumann? What does it mean when such evidence does not exist?

 

[MrJDSmith]

* BUMP *
​

Why Bump?

What would you accept as evidence?

Absolutely nothing --- there isn't any, in my opinion --- and never was.

 

[AV1611VET]

FYI: Post #6 for the win --

 

[Split Rock]

Show me evidence that I sneezed and the Moon popped out and went into orbit around the earth.

I will take your word on it if you say that none exists.

 

[AV1611VET]

Show me evidence that I sneezed and the Moon popped out and went into orbit around the earth. I will believe you if you say there isn't any.

There isn't any.

 

[LifeToTheFullest!]

There isn't any.

How do you know? Were you there?

 

[DontTreadOnMike]

Show me evidence that the moon was created ex nihilo.

I will take your word on it if you say that none exists.

Can't because it wasn't. Sooooo...yeah. Good thread. Same time tomorrow?

 

[AV1611VET]

How do you know? Were you there?

Yes -- read his post correctly.

 

[BananaSlug]

Show me evidence that I sneezed and the Moon popped out and went into orbit around the earth.

I will take your word on it if you say that none exists.

The moon is no older than when you sneezed.

 

[Split Rock]

There isn't any.

Exactly. The same answer you got from Aggie's post #6 back in 2009. So...... what is the point in bringing this thread back again?