Jimmy West said:
What you are saying is that God created us of sinful flesh. God would NOT create anything of sinful flesh! Why would He do that. Did He mess up? Everything God creates is perfect. We become imperfect through our free will. If God hads created us of sinful flesh, He would have discarded us and started over, for God is perfection and that which comes out of the breath of God MUST be perfect.
The potential to sin comes from free will. And free will can also lead us away from sin! It is our choice and that is the way that God wants it to be.
We are all sinners, but we are not born that way. Every baby that is born is innocent and has the potential to be sinful or godly. Mans sinful nature is not heredetary. It is learned!
Your point about the flesh is right and VERY important, but first...
You can SAY we're not "born" sinners -- but it's NOT HARD to get that implication from Paul:
Romans 5
12 Therefore, just as through one man sin entered into the world, and death through sin, and so death spread to all men, because all sinned--
13 for until the Law sin was in the world; but sin is not imputed when there is no law.
14 Nevertheless death reigned from Adam until Moses, even over those who had not sinned in the likeness of the offense of Adam
Enough of that...Now, about the "sinful flesh"... (a much more important issue...)
It is VITAL that we understand that the flesh -- in and of itself -- is NOT SINFUL.
That's part of the sin of Gnosticism -- Gnostics deny that Jesus came in the flesh because (they say) the flesh is sinful! And since Jesus never sinned and the flesh is sinful (they say) He never came in the flesh!
BTW -- all you end-timers out there... The ONLY place the antichrist is ever mentioned is in 1 John and HE uses the term to refer to anyone who tries to deny that Jesus came in the flesh! THAT IS THE ANTICHRIST. In the BIBLE, BTW, that is the ONLY definition of the antichrist.
Now -- back to the point...
It is VITAL that we understand that the flesh -- in and of itself -- is NOT SINFUL. In 1 John, John builds his whole case for divine Love on this basis:
Jesus came in the flesh and He loved us IN HIS FLESH (nailed it to the Cross!) and THEREFORE we MUST Love one another IN THE FLESH AS WELL.
This is a KEY CONCEPT! Once we've become Christians, we are IN CHRIST and we are NO LONGER SINNERS...
WE ARE SAINTS...
...and our FLESH is no longer the
vehicle of sin,
our flesh has become the vehicle of God's Love through us into the lives of those around us.
Here's what got St. John all angry over the antichrists (NOTE:
plural -- there were "many antichrists" already tearing God's congregations apart in John's day..)
Anyway, John was incredibly angry at people who dissed the flesh, because anyone who believes that the flesh is inherently sinful and wicked
is thereby relieved of loving others in the flesh and laying down their flesh for the interests of others!!! They can simply shrug, say "the flesh is wicked and can't do anything good" and then they can get by with "loving" their "brothers" in just "word" and not in "action". (All that's in 1 John... Go re-read it if you doubt it.)
Anyway, Jimmy -- I'm glad you challenged that "flesh is wicked" idea.
Bless you!
KingdomScribe