To Luminousfive.......
I would change a few things so as not to be too pushy. Pushy turns people off............
"Hi I'm John, Would you mind if I asked you a few questions?"
No, I would say, "do you mind if we talk"?
"First, Whats your name?"
No..."Hi I'm _____,...... ALLOW them to decide if they want you to know their name.
"Dave, would you consider yourself religious?"
No....."Are you a Christian"?
"Would you mind telling me a little about why you don't believe in God?/Why you believe in your religion?"
No, too harsh, they may take offense, like you are critisizing their God, or they could say to themselves, "who in the h-ll is this stranger"? too nosey (if possible keep the issue on Jesus, and not his belief, he will start comparing if you do).....I would say " Have you ever thought about Jesus"?
Listen to what he/she has to say. People actually do have reasons for what they believe. Then I usually tell them why I am a Christian. "I'm a Christian because of Gods amazing love for me, not because I am a sinner, not because I'm worried about going to hell, but because God created me I appreciate the fact that I'm even alive, and for that God deserves my worship. I honor God by having a relationship with His son Jesus Christ."
No....NEVER even bring up the word "SIN", for some unbelievers don't even believe in sin. I have NEVER brought up the word "SIN"....... BUT if they ASK?.....I would add......"all of my sin's have been removed by what the Lord has done for me (SIN IS NEVER THE ISSUE), All I needed to do was believe, and in believing, I become a member of His family, His Royal family, for forever. He did it for me, I did nothing! (Keep work's out of it all together) It's what God does, not what I do. This is His gift to all mankind". Keep the point DIRECTED ON the Lord, and off ourselves. We are emphasizing the gospel, not ourselves.
Then I follow that by asking them if there is anything really tough going on in their life.
No, No....WAY too personal (you don't know this person, he doesn't know you, would you tell a total stranger your business? I certainly wouldn't) I would start by saying, "the problems that I had before Jesus are now gone, (this opens up another conversation, where his free will may WANT to enter) Jesus took care of that too, I just ALL put my problems in His hands (this tells a little about the omnipotence of the Lord, without mentioning the word omnipotent) and let Him take care of them,..... and He did. My worries are gone"! Then stay silent, and let the person think, and if he wants to, he may (or may not,....I respect his privacy) share some with you. I Don't get personal, our privacy of the priesthood (us believers) don't ask these things, for he might be embarrased to tell of his personal things, for they may contain sins. This is too much pressure, and really none of our business. I mean after all, we are strangers to one another. This is probally why most unbelievers call us crazy, religous nuts!
"Dave, is there anything going on in your life that is really tough to deal with?
No, again too nosey....Instead say "I have stress at work sometimes, then I go home after work and have so much to do". Stop! This opens up a new venue, and I stop talking, letting him have the opportunity to speak IF he so desires. The more talking I do, the less he does.
"If you want, or if not I can pray for you later."
No.....by you praying to your God, (for him) may lead him to take the defensive about the possibility of offending HIS God?! (Put yourself inside his shoes, and inside his belief, AND he may not believe in ANY God?? or believe in praying) This is a touchy ground, so I tread easy.
We should always stay on the main subject...."Believe on the Lord Jesus Christ and thou shall be saved"! Period!
God in His wisdom made it SO simple to become a believer. All else is really none of our business.
I say to unbelievers..............."Believe on the Lord Jesus Christ and you will be saved"!
Then I say to the unbeliever....."all you have to do is...... in the "PRIVACY OF YOUR OWN SOUL, SAY TO THE FATHER, I AM BELIEVING ON YOUR SON",
Then I say, "THIS IS PRIVATE MATTER BETWEEN YOU AND THE FATHER, (they love the opportunity of their privacy, don't make them feel as if they are on display. Doesn't embarrass them.) "WITH YOUR HEAD BOWED AND YOUR EYES CLOSED, ALL YOU HAVE TO SAY, "IN YOUR OWN WORDS, FATHER I AM BELIEVING IN YOUR SON".
This gives the individual PRIVACY. If this individual doesn't do it then, then he will ALWAYS remember, (because I had already told him how simple the father had made it for him) that HE KNOW"S at any time in the privacy of his own soul, in the future, and what he needs to do to accept Jesus in his life.
I have planted the seed, God the Holy Spirit will Do the "drawing" out of the unbeliver. God the Holy Spirit is "Faithful", He will seek them out.