I am against Halloween because it is a holiday on which people celebrate death, destruction, witchcraft, and sin. I believe in Jesus, which is the opposite of all that.
Logical Fallacy of Equivocation along with straight out misinformation.
All Hallows Eve is NOT secular but a Christian feast since the days of the Undivided Church.
The secular celebration of it isn't just modern, but has nothing to do with death, destruction, actual witchcraft, and certainly not sin. More like a day to just have fun.
I am also against the idea of going house to house demanding candy.
The people expect the kids and youth to come knocking and they're in it to be kind to them. Whoopie-doo.
I believe Jesus commanded us to give to others, not demand from them.
It is a silly secular ritual; Jesus would have no issue with it.
So I do the opposite of trick-or-treating. Every October 30th I bake some sort of cookies (last year was 5 batches of cream cheese brownies) and bring some to everybody I will see that day. (I usually bring a serving to each of 3 elderly neighbors, to any classes I have that day, etc.)
Sounds like something out of a harvest festival, which, as another poster who goes by the handle ViaCrucis recently reminded everyone, is actually the Pagan thing to do since that was a major point of the actual Pagan celebration of Samhain.
It is a lot of fun! People are always really pleased with the idea. I will never forget last year because my family stopped by a local nursing home and brought a brownie to an acquaintance who had recently had a bad fall. She was surprised and delighted! Last Halloween was probably one of the best days of my life, because that round of reverse trick-or-treating brought a lot of joy to both older neighbors and ravenous teenage boys who saw FOOD. It's a nice way to serve others and refrain from celebrating a negative holiday.
There's nothing negative about giving candy away to children and youth one night a year who have a ritual way of requesting it.
I find it amazingly contradictory for the secular celebration of Halloween to be given titles like "negative" and be told it is bad because it "celebrates death" and "sin" when, quite honestly, THAT'S WHAT CHRISTIANITY IS LARGELY FOUNDED ON: the negative consequence of sin and the brutal, bloody death of God Incarnate.
Death is not evil. Destruction isn't evil. Sin is, but there is nothing sinful about kids dressing up and going door to door asking for candy. Nor are they found in bobbing for apples, eating cider and doughnuts, carving images in pumpkins, watching television specials and scary movies, listening to themed music surrounding the day, or even trivialities like haunted forests, haunted houses, and costume parties.
I have yet found any rational, let alone any real orthodox Christian, reason for anyone to call the secular celebration of Halloween wrong. Choosing not to participate is one thing based on likes and dislikes (or whims), but to call it something it is not and to try to convince others of it
is the real sin because it promotes a lie.
Does Jesus like that?
Think about it.
My advice is to learn the actual history of the day. The truth is quite complex but dispels all the nastiness associated with its two acceptable but different celebrations.