There's something else going on, here, and I get the feeling that it's not at home. There's no way that hearing someone say, in all sincerety, "Thank you!", or, "I appreciate what you did!", is going to roll off like water off the proverbial duck's back. How's your love life? Does he come home to sweet and sour liver, with eggplant as the veggie, when he's hoping for steak? He needs to actually say, "I like it when you_____" or, "I like it when you don't _____." He needs to say, "You're welcome," when you say, "Thank you." Obviously, I don't know for sure; I can only speculate. Husbands are called to love their wives as Christ loved the church, and gave Himself for her. There are no qualifiers, tangents, modifiers, conditions or exceptions. Not even for PMS. If you give him your full attention when he wants or needs it, and you don't make excuses when he wants to be intimate, and you are supportive, and do whatever God leads you to do, above and beyond those things, then you've done all you can do and it's his responsibility to respond.