No I Am NOT Agreeing with Velikovsky's Conclusions
By Bruce D McKay, Elijah.
.
Hey! I didn't say one thing about "the head of a comet," and nothing about anything like that, did I. That's forever the "theme of Velikovsky's works." I like his books because they are packed with details of the ancient world, however. I guess it's not too difficult to mistake the crux of his World's in Collision conclusions(?) with what I have presented.
If that's what you got out of it, however, I am truly surprised!
.
I AM EVEN GOING TO TAKE A MOMENT TO EXPLAIN TO YOU WHAT'S GOING TO CAUSE "THE TRUMPET OF GABRIEL" TO SOUND - AND WHAT'S GOING TO HAPPEN WHEN IT DOES! Nor is it that the planets can make music, or the "music of the spheres!" Give me a break. And He, Velikovsky even tries to repeatedly say that "the waters (that) were heaped at their highest above the surface of the earth before they fell down - followed by a rain of debris, were "torn from the very body and tail of a comet!" In contrast, what I wrote is that the waters were highly charged, and they moved to the left and right, due to a great release of energy and new matter, coming up from the mantle! Then the water molecules were no longer the same shape, and being more like the atoms making up "a solid," then they obviously began to stack! That's what I wrote. This was "an effect," which caused a "double wall of water," and between the two - the sea was without any water molecules - in that the NORMALLY WET MOLECULES were all pulled out(!) and so the area or zone between the two walls of water, was immediately turned into "dry land!" Thus, they went through the flood on foot - and the Egyptians, who were planning to "ride over their heads" with their chariots, were all killed. .
So, I don't agree with Velikovsky's conclusions; He claimed it was all because of a comet.
.
When he notes things like Appollodorus' description of the Typhon, that "out-topped all the mountains, and his head often brushed the stars," I tend to take notice. What also gets me is the discription. They called it, the mighty "Typhon" rushing at heaven" and his being "pelted at a distance with thunderbolts" thrown by Zeus. And he fled he was pursued closely, as far as Mount Casius, which overhangs Syria. I take that to mean, a massive, super high wall of water passed through the area. And when it started to "flee through the Sicilian sea," Zeus picked up Mount Etna in Sicily and "threw it upon him."(pg 79) It is unfortunate that a comet passed by "in the sign of Capricorn," and Velikovsky was able to imagine all this as due to "a comet, encountering a planet," as if the comet's tail became "entangled and drawn away from it's own path."(pg 78) It is not difficult to realize
the difference. The supposed "tail of a comet" versus a massive water wall, or the rapid release of new matter from the mantle, so there reaches up Typhon, (Quote)"who they add, was a dragon, when struck by the bolts of lightning, (and he) fled in search of a descent underground."
.
"And not only did he cut great furrows into the earth and from the beds of rivers," Velikovsky writes, "but he also descendeding underground," where "he made fountains to break forth." "Then the earth shook and trembled; the fountains also of the hills moved and were shaken because he was wroth. ...He bowed the heavens also, and came down: and darkness was under his feet. ...At the birghtness that was before him his thick clouds pased, hair stones and coals of fire. The Lord also tundered in the heavens... there were stones and coals of fire. ...He shot out lightnings. ...Then the channels of water were seen, and the foundations of the world were discovered."(Esdra IV)
.
You get a little of the altering of reality here. Velikovsky has everything laid out in terms of it being a comet. But, I do take note, when he points out things like Philo, the Alexandrian philosopher, as describing (Quote) "the commotion on the earth below and in the sky above: 'The mountain (Sinai) burned with fire and the earth shook and the hills were removed and the mountains overthrown; the depths boiled, and all the inhabitable places were shaken... and flames of fire shone forth and thunderings and lightnings were multiplied, and winds and tempests made a roaring; the stars were gathered together (collided, possibly an optical turning of their projected light.)* Referring to the verse, "He bowed down the heavens also, and (this as he) came down. (Psalms 19), Pseudo-Philo describes the events of Mount Sinai and says that the Lord "impeded the course of the stars."* "The earth was stirred from her foundation, and the mountains and the rocks trembled in their fastenings, and the clouds lifted up their waves against the flame of the fire that it sould not consume the world... and all the waves of the sea came together."*
.
Moreover, please do not think all this is merely a "Christian invention." The Hindus even (Quote) "depict the cosmic catastrophe at the end of a world age: 'The whole world breaks into flames. So also, a hundred thousand times ten million worlds. All the peaks of Mount Sineru, even those which are hundreds of leagues in height, crumble and disappear in the sky. The flames of fire rise up and envelop the heaven." So it was when the sixth sun or sun age ended. Similarily, in the Jewish tradition, with the revelation at Sinani, the xisth world age was terminated and the seventh began.(pg 96)
.
"Twisting of strata and building of mountains, earthquakes and rumbling of volcanoes joined in an infernal din. It was a voice not only in the desert of Sinai; the entire world must have heard it. "The earth and the sky resounded... mountains and hills were moved," says the Midrash. "Loud did the firmament roar, and earth with echo resounded," says the Gilgamesh. In Hesiod, "the huge earth groaned, when Zeus lashed Typhon with his bolts, "the earth resounded terribly, and the wide heavens above."
.
According to Midrashic literature, the trump sounding at Mount Sinai had seven different pitches (or notes), [not unlike the seven reaches of the periodic table...] and the rabbinical literature speaks of "the heavenly music" heard at the revelation. "At the first sound the sky and the earth moved, the seas and the rivers turned to flight, mountains and hills were loosened in their foundations."
.
Homer depicts a similar occurrence in these words: "THE WIDE EARTH RANG, AND ROUND ABOUT THE GREAT HEAVENS PEALED AS WITH A TRUMPET." "The world all burns at the blast of the horn," is said in the Voluspa. When you hear it, this is what it sounds like when the molecules of the very air begin to vibrate in unison, on a global basis! And when that happens, when that final or last trumpet sounds according to the scriptures, everyone all over the entire earth is going to hear it and they will ALL know that it is - the return of Christ!.
.
Elijah
.
*From The Biblical Antiquities of Philo (transl. M. R. Jams, 1917, Chap XI XIII, and XXXII.)
By Bruce D McKay, Elijah.
.
Hey! I didn't say one thing about "the head of a comet," and nothing about anything like that, did I. That's forever the "theme of Velikovsky's works." I like his books because they are packed with details of the ancient world, however. I guess it's not too difficult to mistake the crux of his World's in Collision conclusions(?) with what I have presented.
.
I AM EVEN GOING TO TAKE A MOMENT TO EXPLAIN TO YOU WHAT'S GOING TO CAUSE "THE TRUMPET OF GABRIEL" TO SOUND - AND WHAT'S GOING TO HAPPEN WHEN IT DOES! Nor is it that the planets can make music, or the "music of the spheres!" Give me a break. And He, Velikovsky even tries to repeatedly say that "the waters (that) were heaped at their highest above the surface of the earth before they fell down - followed by a rain of debris, were "torn from the very body and tail of a comet!" In contrast, what I wrote is that the waters were highly charged, and they moved to the left and right, due to a great release of energy and new matter, coming up from the mantle! Then the water molecules were no longer the same shape, and being more like the atoms making up "a solid," then they obviously began to stack! That's what I wrote. This was "an effect," which caused a "double wall of water," and between the two - the sea was without any water molecules - in that the NORMALLY WET MOLECULES were all pulled out(!) and so the area or zone between the two walls of water, was immediately turned into "dry land!" Thus, they went through the flood on foot - and the Egyptians, who were planning to "ride over their heads" with their chariots, were all killed. .
So, I don't agree with Velikovsky's conclusions; He claimed it was all because of a comet.
.
When he notes things like Appollodorus' description of the Typhon, that "out-topped all the mountains, and his head often brushed the stars," I tend to take notice. What also gets me is the discription. They called it, the mighty "Typhon" rushing at heaven" and his being "pelted at a distance with thunderbolts" thrown by Zeus. And he fled he was pursued closely, as far as Mount Casius, which overhangs Syria. I take that to mean, a massive, super high wall of water passed through the area. And when it started to "flee through the Sicilian sea," Zeus picked up Mount Etna in Sicily and "threw it upon him."(pg 79) It is unfortunate that a comet passed by "in the sign of Capricorn," and Velikovsky was able to imagine all this as due to "a comet, encountering a planet," as if the comet's tail became "entangled and drawn away from it's own path."(pg 78) It is not difficult to realize

.
"And not only did he cut great furrows into the earth and from the beds of rivers," Velikovsky writes, "but he also descendeding underground," where "he made fountains to break forth." "Then the earth shook and trembled; the fountains also of the hills moved and were shaken because he was wroth. ...He bowed the heavens also, and came down: and darkness was under his feet. ...At the birghtness that was before him his thick clouds pased, hair stones and coals of fire. The Lord also tundered in the heavens... there were stones and coals of fire. ...He shot out lightnings. ...Then the channels of water were seen, and the foundations of the world were discovered."(Esdra IV)
.
You get a little of the altering of reality here. Velikovsky has everything laid out in terms of it being a comet. But, I do take note, when he points out things like Philo, the Alexandrian philosopher, as describing (Quote) "the commotion on the earth below and in the sky above: 'The mountain (Sinai) burned with fire and the earth shook and the hills were removed and the mountains overthrown; the depths boiled, and all the inhabitable places were shaken... and flames of fire shone forth and thunderings and lightnings were multiplied, and winds and tempests made a roaring; the stars were gathered together (collided, possibly an optical turning of their projected light.)* Referring to the verse, "He bowed down the heavens also, and (this as he) came down. (Psalms 19), Pseudo-Philo describes the events of Mount Sinai and says that the Lord "impeded the course of the stars."* "The earth was stirred from her foundation, and the mountains and the rocks trembled in their fastenings, and the clouds lifted up their waves against the flame of the fire that it sould not consume the world... and all the waves of the sea came together."*
.
Moreover, please do not think all this is merely a "Christian invention." The Hindus even (Quote) "depict the cosmic catastrophe at the end of a world age: 'The whole world breaks into flames. So also, a hundred thousand times ten million worlds. All the peaks of Mount Sineru, even those which are hundreds of leagues in height, crumble and disappear in the sky. The flames of fire rise up and envelop the heaven." So it was when the sixth sun or sun age ended. Similarily, in the Jewish tradition, with the revelation at Sinani, the xisth world age was terminated and the seventh began.(pg 96)
.
"Twisting of strata and building of mountains, earthquakes and rumbling of volcanoes joined in an infernal din. It was a voice not only in the desert of Sinai; the entire world must have heard it. "The earth and the sky resounded... mountains and hills were moved," says the Midrash. "Loud did the firmament roar, and earth with echo resounded," says the Gilgamesh. In Hesiod, "the huge earth groaned, when Zeus lashed Typhon with his bolts, "the earth resounded terribly, and the wide heavens above."
.
According to Midrashic literature, the trump sounding at Mount Sinai had seven different pitches (or notes), [not unlike the seven reaches of the periodic table...] and the rabbinical literature speaks of "the heavenly music" heard at the revelation. "At the first sound the sky and the earth moved, the seas and the rivers turned to flight, mountains and hills were loosened in their foundations."
.
Homer depicts a similar occurrence in these words: "THE WIDE EARTH RANG, AND ROUND ABOUT THE GREAT HEAVENS PEALED AS WITH A TRUMPET." "The world all burns at the blast of the horn," is said in the Voluspa. When you hear it, this is what it sounds like when the molecules of the very air begin to vibrate in unison, on a global basis! And when that happens, when that final or last trumpet sounds according to the scriptures, everyone all over the entire earth is going to hear it and they will ALL know that it is - the return of Christ!.
.
Elijah
.
*From The Biblical Antiquities of Philo (transl. M. R. Jams, 1917, Chap XI XIII, and XXXII.)
Upvote
0