Latest activity Postings About Inventory
-
-
TGGIL replied to the thread Free will and determinism.Maybe the entire debate about “free will” goes off the rails because the term itself is misleading. Nothing in human life is truly free... -
TGGIL replied to the thread Free will and determinism.Bradskii is saying this to us all... “I defined free will in a way that makes it impossible, and since you’re not allowed to question my...
-
TGGIL replied to the thread Free will and determinism.The “you just dislike fate” line doesn’t address anything I’ve argued — it simply shifts the discussion from logic to psychology. My...
-
TGGIL replied to the thread Free will and determinism.You’re misunderstanding the point of the inward‑experience argument. It’s not “Gee, it feels obvious, so it must be true.” It’s that any...
-
TGGIL replied to the thread Free will and determinism.You’re treating “free will” as a single definition shared by both compatibilists and incompatibilists, but that’s simply not true. The...
-
TGGIL replied to the thread Free will and determinism.The OP from post number 1 sums this up like this... "Free will means uncaused choice. Choices are caused. Therefore free will doesn’t...
-
TGGIL replied to the thread Free will and determinism.I’ve read through the many arguments here — the philosophers, the theologians, the scientists, the authors, the videos, the historical...
-
TGGIL replied to the thread Free will and determinism.I think we may be talking past each other a bit, so let me reset my points calmly and clearly. You’re saying you’ve simply provided the...
-
TGGIL replied to the thread Free will and determinism.You’re describing exactly the problem I pointed out. The OP’s definition is incompatibilist, but your own description of free will...
-
TGGIL replied to the thread Free will and determinism.You’re trying to preserve rational evaluation while denying the agency required for it. If determinism is true, then “accepting...
-
TGGIL replied to the thread Free will and determinism.Calling the agent a “causal center” is not libertarian metaphysics. It’s compatibilism. Compatibilists hold that actions are caused —...
-
TGGIL replied to the thread Free will and determinism.You keep saying my beliefs are “inevitable” because of my nature — but that is the point. If determinism is true, then my openness...
-
TGGIL replied to the thread Free will and determinism.You’re not defending determinism — you’re defending a definition that makes your conclusion true by definition. If you define free will...
-
TGGIL replied to the thread Free will and determinism.A claim I never made. I didn’t say the agent is separate from the environment. I said the agent is a distinct causal center within it...
-
Biblically Speaking, the "I don't know part", in my understanding, is a good place to start. Is. 55: 6 Seek ye the LORD while he may...
-
-
Loading…
-
Loading…
-
Loading…
