Mercy74

Mercy Messianic Judaism
Mar 15, 2017
642
86
50
Usa
✟52,952.00
Country
United States
Faith
Messianic
Marital Status
Single
Hello! I'm studying the Calvinism debate and looking at passages on both sides. The current passage I'm looking at is one that currently seems to go against Calvinism: Romans 11:16-22. I could be wrong; if so, could you answer the following questions of mine?

1. Are the branches individuals or groups?
2. If groups, what do the two trees represent?
3. What causes branches to be in the cultivated olive tree as opposed to the wild olive tree?
4. Can branches grafted into the cultivated tree be cut off?
5. Can branches cut off from the cultivated tree be grafted in again?

Thanks in advanced,
Kilk
We must read these scriptures with the mind of Christ. The grafting of the gentiles is only a "mental connection" with Israel. This is why the gentiles stand by faith; the Israelites were broken off because of unbelief. The gentiles were grafted in because they believed the truth. All of Israel were not broken off, they are the natural branches, only the dead ones on the ground that don't bear fruit are disconnected. The gentiles are grafted in among them since the truth was sent through those dead branches broken off of the gentiles from the cultivated tree which are still holy.
 
Upvote 0

yeshuaslavejeff

simple truth, martyr, disciple of Yahshua
Jan 6, 2005
39,944
11,098
okie
✟214,996.00
Faith
Anabaptist
We must read these scriptures with the mind of Christ. The grafting of the gentiles is only a "mental connection" with Israel. This is why the gentiles stand by faith; the Israelites were broken off because of unbelief. The gentiles were grafted in because they believed the truth. All of Israel were not broken off, they are the natural branches, only the dead ones on the ground that don't bear fruit are disconnected. The gentiles are grafted in among them since the truth was sent through those dead branches broken off of the gentiles from the cultivated tree which are still holy.
I believe the spiritual reality is much much more real and more important , from the Father in Heaven, than the "mental" aspects, if there are any.

Yes, the gentiles "stand by faith", if they are born again. Just like the Israelites.

Most are not , so that must be realized, remembered, when looking at things in the world and wondering why there is so much wickedness in high and low places, everywhere.
 
Upvote 0

Mercy74

Mercy Messianic Judaism
Mar 15, 2017
642
86
50
Usa
✟52,952.00
Country
United States
Faith
Messianic
Marital Status
Single
I believe the spiritual reality is much much more real and more important , from the Father in Heaven, than the "mental" aspects, if there are any.

Yes, the gentiles "stand by faith", if they are born again. Just like the Israelites.

Most are not , so that must be realized, remembered, when looking at things in the world and wondering why there is so much wickedness in high and low places, everywhere.
Abraham was a gentile; the grandfather of Israel, Romans 7:25.
 
Upvote 0

Mercy74

Mercy Messianic Judaism
Mar 15, 2017
642
86
50
Usa
✟52,952.00
Country
United States
Faith
Messianic
Marital Status
Single
I think more important: Abraham at the time was the one man called by Yahuweh, chosen, and set apart for Yahuweh. Let's not derail the thread further this way though, as Abraham had nothing to do with Calvinism at all.
Those gentiles were gathered among those dead branches that were broken off the cultivated tree. Those who have faith in Yeshua are considered sons of Abraham. For this cause, those gentiles should not boast over those natural branches that were broken off of the cultivated tree because of unbelief. If the tree is holy so are the branches.
 
Upvote 0

Mercy74

Mercy Messianic Judaism
Mar 15, 2017
642
86
50
Usa
✟52,952.00
Country
United States
Faith
Messianic
Marital Status
Single
Hello Kilk1.

1 Are the branches individuals or groups?

The branches are two nations; the nation of Israel and the Gentile nations.

2. If groups, what do the two trees represent?
Two olive trees, one cultivated olive tree and one wild olive tree. The nation of Israel and the nation of the Gentiles; Gentile means not Jewish.

The root is Christ and the branches in an olive tree are attached to the root of the olive tree. The branches are not attached to a tree trunk on an olive tree.

3. What causes branches to be in the cultivated olive tree as opposed to the wild olive tree?

There are two answers to this question and at two levels.

The first is that the Jews represent the branches in the cultivated olive tree and this was a result of God's choice. That is God chose the nation of Israel and it is was therefore His will that Israel was a cultivated olive tree. So at one level a Gentile can convert to Judaism and therefore be a member of the cultivated olive tree.

The second level is that Gentiles who convert to a belief in Jesus Christ are grafted into the root. Hence, the Gentiles become a cultivated branch by virtue of being attached to the root.


4. Can branches grafted into the cultivated tree be cut off?

Yes, the text specifies that branches were cut off. Paul also warns the Gentiles that they can be severed for unbelief.

5. Can branches cut off from the cultivated tree be grafted in again?

Yes, severed branches can in fact be grafted back into the root. Paul states this to be true.

Romans 11:23
And they also, if they do not continue in their unbelief, will be grafted in, for God is able to graft them in again.

There are two levels in the text and for this reason the text is difficult to understand.
Paul the Pharisee never said the gentiles are connected to the root; he says the "root" supports them. There is a root from the cultivated tree but also another root from the wild olive tree. Verse 24 Paul the Pharisee uses the word "if" to create an analogy where the gentiles were cut off from their wild olive tree, grafted into a cultivated tree CONTRARY TO THE LAW of nature (Torah), it is more likely that those dead natural branches will be reunited with their own family tree.
 
Last edited:
Upvote 0

Mercy74

Mercy Messianic Judaism
Mar 15, 2017
642
86
50
Usa
✟52,952.00
Country
United States
Faith
Messianic
Marital Status
Single
Upvote 0

yeshuaslavejeff

simple truth, martyr, disciple of Yahshua
Jan 6, 2005
39,944
11,098
okie
✟214,996.00
Faith
Anabaptist
Those gentiles were gathered among those dead branches that were broken off the cultivated tree. Those who have faith in Yeshua are considered sons of Abraham. For this cause, those gentiles should not boast over those natural branches that were broken off of the cultivated tree because of unbelief. If the tree is holy so are the branches.
Yes (so it seems), except of course for those branches that do not bear fruit and the OWNER breaks them off..... the branches that are not holy, nor obedient, nor true, nor faithful....
 
Upvote 0

yeshuaslavejeff

simple truth, martyr, disciple of Yahshua
Jan 6, 2005
39,944
11,098
okie
✟214,996.00
Faith
Anabaptist
I often hear those in the NOSAS camp interpret Romans 11:16-22 to mean that saved individuals can lose their salvation. I would like to hear how those in the OSAS camp interpret Romans 11:16-22.
Let's read it >> (in English it is clear) >>
"But they were broken off because of unbelief, and you stand by faith. Do not be arrogant, but tremble. 21 For if God did not spare the natural branches, he will not spare you either.

22 Consider therefore the kindness and sternness of God: sternness to those who fell, but kindness to you,

provided that you continue in his kindness.

Otherwise, you also will be cut off."
 
Upvote 0
This site stays free and accessible to all because of donations from people like you.
Consider making a one-time or monthly donation. We appreciate your support!
- Dan Doughty and Team Christian Forums

Knee V

It's phonetic.
Sep 17, 2003
8,415
1,741
41
South Bend, IN
✟100,823.00
Country
United States
Faith
Eastern Orthodox
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Others
Hello! I'm studying the Calvinism debate and looking at passages on both sides. The current passage I'm looking at is one that currently seems to go against Calvinism: Romans 11:16-22. I could be wrong; if so, could you answer the following questions of mine?

1. Are the branches individuals or groups?
2. If groups, what do the two trees represent?
3. What causes branches to be in the cultivated olive tree as opposed to the wild olive tree?
4. Can branches grafted into the cultivated tree be cut off?
5. Can branches cut off from the cultivated tree be grafted in again?

Thanks in advanced,
Kilk

The context of the Epistle to the Romans, as is the case for most of St Paul's epistles, is refuting the heresy of the Judaizers, and we ought to avoid trying to read into the text more than what the context calls for.

In the first several chapters, Paul tells the Jewish believers, "You have no room to boast over the Gentiles!" In this passage, Paul tells the Gentiles, "You have no room to boast, either!"

And that is the nuts and bolts of it. Trying to draw more conclusions is reading into the passage and the epistle a conversation that never took place. The questions you asked, while perfectly fine questions, aren't addressed and are not part of the topic that Paul was writing about.
 
Upvote 0

Kilk1

Well-Known Member
Jul 21, 2019
607
193
Washington State
✟103,140.00
Country
United States
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Private
Instead of challenging Calvinism, this passage is one of the most discussed concerning other doctrinal dividing issues among Reformed Christians - the covenants. The other would be Hebrews. There are several interpretations.

The paedobaptist will use this to defend the concept of infant baptism, while most baptist will use this to attack such a concept and understand the real meaning behind it.

Brandon Adams wrote great articles on this years ago, and I'd rather share it first before expanding it in my own words.

It is recommended that you read this article first --> They are not all Israel, who are of Israel (Romans 9:7), before reading this one --> The Olive Tree (Romans 11:16-24). Great stuff here! He is a giant among us, if you have learned anything give him a shout out if you could!
Hello! I apologize for taking a long time (20 days, apparently!) to reply. I looked into what you shared, and I was surprised to find that as far as the olive tree is concerned, I agree with the majority of what was said. Here's the summary from the end of the article:
  1. Natural branches (Israel after the flesh) were vitally connected to the root (Abraham) apart from faith.
  2. At one specific point in history (the end of the Old Covenant), unbelieving natural branches lost their connection to the root and were corporately cut off.
  3. The branches that remained (Israel after the spirit) were only those vitally connected to the root (Abraham) through faith.
  4. Wild believing branches (Israel after the spirit) were grafted in and vitally connected to the root (Abraham) through faith.
  5. Believing branches will not be cut off because God preserves their faith.
  6. There are now no branches in the olive tree without faith.
  7. The tree represents Israel, both as type (Israel after the flesh) and later anti-type (Israel after the spirit).
What's interesting is that I actually agree with six of the seven bullets here; as far as I can tell, six of these are true. It's the fifth point that I'm disagreeing with. Brandon Adams gives his defense in the section titled, "Elect Excised?"

However, I believe that the text directly denies point 5. Instead of saying that no believing branches will be cut off by God, verses 20-21 explicitly states that "He may not spare" them (NKJV). At least that's how I'm seeing it; if I'm wrong, I don't want to be in error, so pointing out where my line of thought fails will only be appreciated. Thanks!
 
Upvote 0

Mercy74

Mercy Messianic Judaism
Mar 15, 2017
642
86
50
Usa
✟52,952.00
Country
United States
Faith
Messianic
Marital Status
Single
Yes (so it seems), except of course for those branches that do not bear fruit and the OWNER breaks them off..... the branches that are not holy, nor obedient, nor true, nor faithful....
The root is holy so are the branches. The branches that have been cut off of the cultivated tree are still holy, the gentiles who have faith are grafted in among them (Romans 11:16-17).
 
Upvote 0

Mercy74

Mercy Messianic Judaism
Mar 15, 2017
642
86
50
Usa
✟52,952.00
Country
United States
Faith
Messianic
Marital Status
Single
Hello! I apologize for taking a long time (20 days, apparently!) to reply. I looked into what you shared, and I was surprised to find that as far as the olive tree is concerned, I agree with the majority of what was said. Here's the summary from the end of the article:
  1. Natural branches (Israel after the flesh) were vitally connected to the root (Abraham) apart from faith.
  2. At one specific point in history (the end of the Old Covenant), unbelieving natural branches lost their connection to the root and were corporately cut off.
  3. The branches that remained (Israel after the spirit) were only those vitally connected to the root (Abraham) through faith.
  4. Wild believing branches (Israel after the spirit) were grafted in and vitally connected to the root (Abraham) through faith.
  5. Believing branches will not be cut off because God preserves their faith.
  6. There are now no branches in the olive tree without faith.
  7. The tree represents Israel, both as type (Israel after the flesh) and later anti-type (Israel after the spirit).
What's interesting is that I actually agree with six of the seven bullets here; as far as I can tell, six of these are true. It's the fifth point that I'm disagreeing with. Brandon Adams gives his defense in the section titled, "Elect Excised?"

However, I believe that the text directly denies point 5. Instead of saying that no believing branches will be cut off by God, verses 20-21 explicitly states that "He may not spare" them (NKJV). At least that's how I'm seeing it; if I'm wrong, I don't want to be in error, so pointing out where my line of thought fails will only be appreciated. Thanks!
Paul the Pharisee has been cut off of Israel; he is still a holy branch; the gentiles have been grafted in among him and others (Acts 18:6).
 
Upvote 0

Mercy74

Mercy Messianic Judaism
Mar 15, 2017
642
86
50
Usa
✟52,952.00
Country
United States
Faith
Messianic
Marital Status
Single
The context of the Epistle to the Romans, as is the case for most of St Paul's epistles, is refuting the heresy of the Judaizers, and we ought to avoid trying to read into the text more than what the context calls for.

In the first several chapters, Paul tells the Jewish believers, "You have no room to boast over the Gentiles!" In this passage, Paul tells the Gentiles, "You have no room to boast, either!"

And that is the nuts and bolts of it. Trying to draw more conclusions is reading into the passage and the epistle a conversation that never took place. The questions you asked, while perfectly fine questions, aren't addressed and are not part of the topic that Paul was writing about.
How could the gentiles boast over those natural branches that have been broken off the cultivated tree? The root still supports those branches by faith and fervent prayer; those broken off branches brought the truth to the gentiles. Paul the Pharisee has been rejected by his family tree.
 
Upvote 0
This site stays free and accessible to all because of donations from people like you.
Consider making a one-time or monthly donation. We appreciate your support!
- Dan Doughty and Team Christian Forums

Kilk1

Well-Known Member
Jul 21, 2019
607
193
Washington State
✟103,140.00
Country
United States
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Private
Paul the Pharisee has been cut off of Israel; he is still a holy branch; the gentiles have been grafted in among him and others (Acts 18:6).
Hello! My question is directed to @Jonaitis, who says those grafted in will never be cut off later. Do you believe those grafted in may later be cut off?
 
Upvote 0

Mercy74

Mercy Messianic Judaism
Mar 15, 2017
642
86
50
Usa
✟52,952.00
Country
United States
Faith
Messianic
Marital Status
Single
Hello! My question is directed to @Jonaitis, who says those grafted in will never be cut off later. Do you believe those grafted in may later be cut off?
The gentiles being grafted in among those broken off branches from the cultivated tree CONTRARY to the law of nature; the gentiles stand by faith; they could be cut off from their own wild olive tree to be physically joined with Israel.
 
Upvote 0

Kilk1

Well-Known Member
Jul 21, 2019
607
193
Washington State
✟103,140.00
Country
United States
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Private
The gentiles being grafted in among those broken off branches from the cultivated tree CONTRARY to the law of nature; the gentiles stand by faith; they could be cut off from their own wild olive tree to be physically joined with Israel.
But can they afterward be cut off from Israel?
 
Upvote 0
This site stays free and accessible to all because of donations from people like you.
Consider making a one-time or monthly donation. We appreciate your support!
- Dan Doughty and Team Christian Forums

Kilk1

Well-Known Member
Jul 21, 2019
607
193
Washington State
✟103,140.00
Country
United States
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Private
The gentiles are still connected to their own family tree.
In Romans 11:19-21, we see that Gentiles were grafted into the tree of Israel. Does the text say that branches grafted in may be broken off?
 
Upvote 0