RocksInMyHead
God is innocent; Noah built on a floodplain!
- May 12, 2011
- 9,421
- 10,193
- Country
- United States
- Faith
- Catholic
- Marital Status
- Single
- Politics
- US-Democrat
There was reporting on the interview pretty much immediately, and the affiliates didn't announce that they were dropping the Tonight Show until after it aired. Note that Carr didn't just threaten ABC - he also threatened the affiliates:While the indefinite suspension was announced after Brendan Carr's threat, it happened so quickly afterwards I don't think ABC's announcement was a reaction to it. And Carr's statements were given on a podcast, not as part of an actual public announcement that would have gotten ABC's attention more quickly. And even if they were worried about his comments, there wasn't an immediacy to them that required them to take action mere hours afterwards.
Much more plausibly, the reason was the affiliates saying they wouldn't air Kimmel's show. That requires a more immediate response to deal with than Carr's statements, and (as far as I can tell) ABC would have fewer legal avenues to fight the issue with. I also strongly suspect that they were experiencing problems with advertisers pulling out of the show due to the controversy, again an issue they would have to deal with far more immediately than anything from the FCC. I feel like at most Carr's statements just accelerated what ABC was already considering or even already planned to do.
Now, maybe they communicated this to ABC beforehand - but also maybe the FCC communicated these threats to Sinclair and Nextar before the interview as well. However, even if it was a totally independent decision, this statement from the FCC still has a chilling effect on speech, because now everyone else is on notice. No matter how you look at it, what Carr said was, at minimum, extremely irresponsible, and aimed at stifling first amendment rights.And frankly, I
16:45
think that it's it's it's really sort of
16:46
past time that a lot of these licensed
16:48
broadcasters themselves push back on
16:52
Comcast and Disney and say, "Listen, we
16:53
are going to preempt. We are not going
16:54
to run Kimmel anymore until you
16:58
straighten this out because we we
17:00
licensed broadcaster are running the
17:02
possibility of fines or license
17:04
revocations from the FCC if we continue
17:06
to run content that ends up being a
17:08
pattern of news distortion."
Upvote
0