An interesting question born from an atheists lips...

SaphireOwl

Who are you?Whoo whoo whoo whoo! Yeah, I know
May 15, 2014
995
51
✟1,488.00
Faith
Christian Seeker
Marital Status
Single
Does prayer work?

Christopher Hitchens â–ª Does Prayer Work? [2008] - YouTube


Christopher Hitchens or, "Hitch", as people who knew him called him and from both sides of the Atlantic, poses a very curious observation in this video. Though terribly sunburned, and I've been there myself, he none the less stands out for other reasons as well.
Now departed due to complications from his fight with cancer in 2011, Christopher Hitchens leaves a legacy as one of the most articulate atheists of our time. With not a care in the world as to whom he offended in the process.

At the end of this short piece he makes a very interesting observation. And while ministers and others could come up with all sorts of answers I thought to pose the question here after people might choose to watch Hitch.

When God is omnipresent and omniscient and most importantly we're told, omnibenevolent, why did the sun shine above Auschwitz in WW2 Nazi Germany? Why did the skies remain blue and clear above Dackow in Poland?
Why was the morning like every other morning in NYC on September 11, 2001 while 19 terrorists were boarding planes that would alter the present and the future of America and make history in the name of Muslim fanatic terrorism?

Why didn't God stop the evil that carried on before his eternally present all knowing eye?




So then the question is, as posted by Hitchens; where was God? Why did the skies over Nazi Germany, Poland, and elsewhere, darken with God's wrath as he interceded in the evil that men were doing?


I look forward to heart felt sincere replies. This is not a thread inviting flaming, goading, personal attacks, nor is it intended to insult anyone's faith. Rather, it is posted to pose the question an atheist gave voice to and answered with; because God isn't real! In Hitchens manner of speaking.

But what do we Christians believe?



(*as a side note* Ironically, Hitchens brother was/is a Theist. I find that surprising given then that all he condemned about God, faith, and religion and the religious, first spoke in rebuttal to the beliefs of his own blood.)
 

Archie the Preacher

Apostle to the Intellectual Skeptics
Apr 11, 2003
3,171
1,011
Hastings, Nebraska - the Heartland!
Visit site
✟38,822.00
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Celibate
Politics
US-Republican
The answer has been made many times. The answer has been ignored by atheists and some theists just as often.

God does not - by His choice, not by outside constraint - control every aspect of every human's life. We - humans - have ability to make choices. If we did not, we would be automatons. Atheists - the Controller permitting - would then complain about how God 'interferes' in life.

As a race (human) we choose to not honor God. The repercussions of that choice is what creates most of human suffering. Not because God doesn't want to stop it, but because man wants it that way.

God gives us directions how to live life to the fullest and cause no problems on Earth. Most humans simply ignore those directions and most of us Christians - followers of God - don't really live as properly as we ought.

That's really the simple answer. Which is also ignored. That sort of makes sense, considering we generally ignore God in the first place.
 
Upvote 0

ValleyGal

Well-Known Member
Dec 19, 2012
5,775
1,829
✟114,245.00
Country
Canada
Faith
Anabaptist
Marital Status
Divorced
Why didn't God stop the evil that carried on before his eternally present all knowing eye?
In addition to the response above by Archie, God did intervene a couple of times in the past such as the flood and Sodom/Gomorrah. So we know he intervenes when intervention is going to bring him more glory than not. There are also times when God will not intervene - and he has his reasons for that, too. The real question is why do we need to know how or why he chooses when and when not to intervene? It is one of his great mysteries.

Where was he? He was in every plane, every building on 9/11, and he was in every camp during the Holocaust, hoping that people would turn to him.

Why should the sky darken during devastating times? Trials fall on both the righteous and the unrighteous. And when it rains, it rains on all of us.

Prayer works for the one praying, for us to adapt to God's will, not to ask God to adapt to our will. Whose will matters more - mine or God's? I may not understand God's will, but I take it on faith that he knows what he's doing.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sorednax
Upvote 0

sorednax

Champion of the 80's
Aug 11, 2011
246
7
East Ohio
✟7,957.00
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Others
I quote the film "Time Bandits."

"Kevin: Why did all these people have to die?

Supreme Being: Well, might as well ask why do we have to have evil?

Kevin: Yes, why do we have to have evil.

Supreme Being: Ahh, I believe it has something to do with free will."
 
Upvote 0

FlameAlchemist

Mustang
Oct 21, 2013
168
10
Some beach, somewhere
✟7,854.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Single
Politics
US-Libertarian
The simple answer is that we have free will. If God intervened in our lives and stopped us from doing this or that, we would have limited will.

It also raises another interesting question, if we want God to stop evil, where do we draw the line? What about lying, what about our evil thoughts? That means you and I would be eliminated too. Where do we stop? The murder level, the lying level, or the thinking level? If we want God to stop evil we have to be consistent, we can't just pick and chose, evil is evil.
 
Upvote 0