I'm Catholic now, but I was originally Presbyterian. I was with the Wesleyan Methodists for a while, and my wife is Baptist.
I found them all OK, although I most enjoyed the Presbyterian Church while I was there. Not because if was "Presbyterian" but because of the quality of the people there. I was younger then - we had a gym under the church; I was actually encouraged to pick up a guitar (not something I ever thought I'd do as I'm hard of hearing), and the pastor was outstanding.
Otherwise I suppose I've got a leaning towards the Wesleyan Methodists, partly because most of my original pastor's family and a number of his Presbyterian flock moved to that congregation after he died, as the new pastorate left a lot to be desired.
Having said that, I think the Catholic Church is "closest" to the truth, dogmatically and liturgically speaking. But from experience I've found people make a church, regardless of the denomination.
It's a bit like your neighbours can make or break a neighbourhood.
Someone mentioned the Jews. I haven't had much to do with them, although I did meet a bloke who had the somewhat mixed fortune of having a Jewish father and Catholic Mother. It was a challenge being a good Catholic boy on Sunday, and a good Jewish boy on Saturday. But a psychiatrist I see (mainly because we have had similar spiritual experiences) said to me once that they (the Jews) "... have a lot of love."