Did I just hear a clergyman say "crappy!?" LOL.....
Oh well, it's not a fasting period, so we'll let it go.
I thought the FX were fine. My only criticism of the film is Hayden Christenson's acting. He stinks. But since I like the story and everything else, I can overlook it. It's like the old Star Wars. Mark Hamill is an AWFUL actor in every way, but the strength of everything around it obscured it for me. I can push the FX and HC aside if I liked the rest. And honestly the FX weren't that bad really. Most space movies look about the same, and it was 13 years ago. I thought Attack of the Clones had far worse FX.
Go back and watch Lord of the Rings. It can get cartoonish, man. But those 3 films are still an utter joy.