Dont be shy, what is one example of incredulous creationist argument for the Christian God?
Clarification: do you want arguments specifically about god's existence, or any creationist argument in general? Are you asking about YEC or just someone who believes god created?
What is one example of a credulous evolutionist argument against the Christian God?
Speedwell answered how I would have.
Why does it matter what i believe in?
I never said it did.
Why do you think it matters to me what you believe in?
Because you called atheists elitists, so it clearly bugs you.
You hint it maybe a possibility the Christian God exists. No matter how ridiculously improbable this is to you, why is it still a small possibility?
I have always been open-minded. I was once an evolution bashing, fundamental evangelical myself.
If it is not the reason i think it is, what have you got?
You dont believe me - obviously - or else you wouldnt have said there is maybe another explanation?
Give me what you got, show me how i could be wrong or what i should consider?
Why? You'll just scoff and say, "nah, couldn't be that. It was real."
But whatever....people's minds can do amazing things when emotions are strong, and it has nothing to do with our mental health; it can happen to anyone. Why were the ladies laying hands and praying with you? Were you going through something particularly rough at the time? Some cause for emotions to be heightened?
Sometimes it doesn't even take much. You mentioned that you are Pentecostal. When I was in the Army, a friend of mine invited me to his Pentecostal church service. I was a conservative Baptist at the time, and believed that spiritual gifts like speaking in tongues, prophecy, and some others were no longer given in modern times. And honestly, the service was a bit uncomfortable for me. But the energy in there was palpable. And even though I didn't believe speaking in tongues was still a thing, I couldn't help but want to be a part of it. To feel what they were feeling. But you see, everyone there felt the same, had the desire to feel lifted. And it builds. And builds. And you start to convince yourself that something is happening. And the leaders know what to say and sing to egg it on...not in a deceptive way, because they are fully convinced themselves.
And before you ask, no, I did not speak in tongues at the service.
And that euphoria is not just for spiritual/religious things, either. One can become so emotionally invested in their favorite sports team that they become euphoric, PARTICULARLY when others are doing it with you. Or due to pride when your child is accomplishing something special.
We are going to have to agree to disagree on this one. Cause I know you aren't buying what I'm saying, and I've already told you that second hand testimonies are not very convincing.
I gave you my testimony on purpose - again. You gave me a hypothetical one so I give you a real one. I want to see how you react.
How do you feel about my claim?
I feel that it is not the type of claim toward which I am incredulous.
Do you question my sincerity?
No
Do you question my sanity?
No.
Why would you disbelieve me?"
I don't believe there was anything supernatural about my own past emotional states, why would I believe yours. ;-)
So because there are 1000s of belief system therefore Christianty cannot be true?
You always do this. You know that is not what I meant, but you twist the meaning hoping for a "gotcha" moment. Try taking my comments at face value, and have a normal conversation, rather than a debate you are trying to win.
In some of my experiences with conversing with atheists. There is always a sense of uncertainty, nothing is ever 100% or certain to happen.
Why is that a bad thing?
Do you fall into this category?
Of course. I've learned that it is far less humiliating to admit you are wrong....and everyone is sometimes...when you keep in mind that, hey, I might be wrong, so let's see what I can learn.
How certain are you that the Christian God does not exist?
That depends on which version you're talking about.
Hey hey
What is the core of your atheism?
A lot of things are involved, but at it's root, I'd say it's philosophical; more specifically, logic.
Hey hey my dear
Looks like you skipped many questions and chose the ones you wanted to answer.
Ironic, since you still have not answered the first questions I asked in this discussion, except to say that you don't care. Not to mention the fact that you never answered my last post in our last discussion as you said you would.
Im going to do something similar and answer only what i want and not what has been addressed.
You always have. Why stop now?
Anyways we are getting closer to where i want to be - funny how that always happens.
Yes, you are very adept at changing the question asked of you to a question you would rather answer instead. Pretty easy to get where you want when you do that.
What is your atheism built on?
Philosophy/logic
What has made you certain that there is no God?
Cheers ;p
I never said I was certain there is no god.