Why is homosexuality wrong if it's not long term?

[The Cadet]

In this text, God is defining for us what is appropriate sexual behavior. It is between a man and his wife.

Right, but why? We're talking about an activity with no harm to anyone outside the consenting adults performing it, and virtually no harm to them. Why in the world should the almighty creator of the universe care if we do that? Especially when you consider that many of us are hardwired to want this. It seems petty and meaningless, and simply makes no sense.

 

[AHH who-stole-my-name]

I see sin as a verb and being sinful is acting out on something and not just being something.

 

[TastyWallet]

Right, but why? We're talking about an activity with no harm to anyone outside the consenting adults performing it, and virtually no harm to them. Why in the world should the almighty creator of the universe care if we do that? Especially when you consider that many of us are hardwired to want this. It seems petty and meaningless, and simply makes no sense.

Are you familiar with Christianity and what it teaches about sin and God's judgment? If not, I could explain it to you. If you do, then you should already know the answer.

 

[The Cadet]

Are you familiar with Christianity and what it teaches about sin and God's judgment? If not, I could explain it to you. If you do, then you should already know the answer.

I know some of the basics; by all means, cue me in. What am I missing here?

 

[TastyWallet]

I know some of the basics; by all means, cue me in. What am I missing here?

According to the Bible, God originally created us good (Genesis 1:26-31), and gave us a single commandment to follow (Genesis 2:17). Adam eve disobeyed, and brought sin upon the whole world (Romans 5:12), causing not just physical death, but a "second death" (Romans 6:23, Revelation 20:14). This "second death" is everlasting separation from God, which is caused by sin. Sin is defined as breaking God's Laws, or Commandments, or both (1 John 3:4).

Homosexual behavior is sin according to the Bible and, just like all other sins, results in punishment, that is, the "second death", eternal separation from God.

Why is homosexuality a sin? Because it goes against God's original design for sexual behavior, that is, between a man and a woman, in marriage.

Why does God care so much? Because He created us, to be in a loving, personal relationship with Him. When we sin and break His Laws, it hurts that relationship.

What has God done about sin? He's given is three institutions to deal with sin: the Government, the Church, and the family unit. When these three entities fails to do their jobs, sin goes unchecked and rules the nations.

Of course, God also became a man, Jesus, who paid the penalty for our sins, to make forgiveness possible to those who are willing to accept it. Those who do can enter into a personal relationship with God, who will help us become more and more like Him.

Does that help?

 

[Reasoning]

You're missing the point. I was referring to sinful behavior, in accordance with the Bible, God's Word. But since you're an atheist, does not surprise me that you would reject my conclusion, since it's based on the Bible.

Ok true. But then how do you pick and choose? Why do homosexuals get repelled with such a strong voice, but divorced people, or people who have sex before marriage are accepted? That should then get the exact same treatment according to scripture.

 

[Blondepudding]

An odd question I'd think for a Christian to pose. Why is something the faith calls wrong wrong if it doesn't last long?
Why not expand the question in a different context so as to see the conflict in this first question in the OP.
Why is stealing wrong if it's not long term?
Why is murdering people wrong if it's not long term?

No, same sex sex isn't the same as robbing people or murdering people. However, it is a matter of moral composure that the scriptures of the Christians Bible are concerned . And the teachings of Christ are also a matter of moral composure and being created in his own image through faith having left the worldly material carnal nature behind. Part of what the ritual of baptism includes is to wash that old worldly self away and be reborn, as we are born from the water that is in our mothers womb nurturing us for those 9 months, into a new world.
How then is one expected to be reborn as a new creation in the image of Christ's message, when he was the message, the word, and ask how it is wrong to live as their old worldly selves while wearing his name as their faith?

 

[Reasoning]

Why does God care so much? Because He created us, to be in a loving, personal relationship with Him. When we sin and break His Laws, it hurts that relationship.

This does not explain why he cares so much what we do naked. Homosexuals can be very loving, and also have the idea to have a personal relationship with God.

 

[Blondepudding]

but the thing is if it were due to structure that wouldn't include people who did it without desire to be serious

Pardon me while I make the observation, being you've identified yourself as a female who's had lesbian encounter, that there is nothing more serious than oral copulation on another female by choice.
Don't fool yourself for one minute. If what you're claiming in the OP is true, you were serious and you were aroused when you copulated with another female and achieved climax.And you were serious.

It's not like a practical joke that you pull on someone and then say, "HAAA! Just kiddin!" You don't put your face between another girls legs when you're not serious about being there.


Or, you've never done any such thing and you're here playing games with the Christians just to get a rise out of them by posting on a subject such as this.

 

[TastyWallet]

Ok true. But then how do you pick and choose? Why do homosexuals get repelled with such a strong voice, but divorced people, or people who have sex before marriage are accepted? That should then get the exact same treatment according to scripture.

There really should not be any picking or choosing: all of these behaviors ought to be condemned by Christians. However homosexuals get repelled because it's currently a hotly debated political issue.

Unfortunately, many Christians will condemn the homosexual simply for being homosexual, thinking they are doing something good. However, Jesus would have never done such a thing. We've done such a horrid job of loving people as Jesus would. To that, I am ashamed.

 

[TastyWallet]

This does not explain why he cares so much what we do naked. Homosexuals can be very loving, and also have the idea to have a personal relationship with God.

The idea of it? Sure. But not the actuality of it, if they continue to live in an unrepentant lifestyle of sin. I don't think you quite understand the seriousness of sin, which is why the "why" answer makes little sense to you.

 

[essentialsaltes]

but the thing is if it were due to structure that wouldn't include people who did it without desire to be serious

So you weren't serious about sinning, it was just idly sinning? Almost by accident!

 

[Reasoning]

The idea of it? Sure. But not the actuality of it, if they continue to live in an unrepentant lifestyle of sin. I don't think you quite understand the seriousness of sin, which is why the "why" answer makes little sense to you.

Homosexuals can be just as loving as heterosexuals, to either each other, other people, the community, or the children they raise like their own when heterosexuals cannot take care of them. No matter what scripture litirally says, if God is really loving, he should have no issue with this behavior. He would be proud of the Christians that also see that vision of love, who learned to take the bible as He intended it. Inclusions instead of exclusion. Love instead of hate.

That should be the only way people should read the Bible. And I am sure God would agree.

 

[TastyWallet]

Homosexuals can be just as loving as heterosexuals, to either each other, other people, the community, or the children they raise like their own when heterosexuals cannot take care of them. No matter what scripture litirally says, if God is really loving, he should have no issue with this behavior. He would be proud of the Christians that also see that vision of love, who learned to take the bible as He intended it. Inclusions instead of exclusion. Love instead of hate.

That should be the only way people should read the Bible. And I am sure God would agree.

Yet, that's not what the Bible teaches. If you have an issue with God, I suggest you take it up with Him yourself.

 

[Blondepudding]

Homosexuals can be just as loving as heterosexuals, to either each other, other people, the community, or the children they raise like their own when heterosexuals cannot take care of them. No matter what scripture litirally says, if God is really loving, he should have no issue with this behavior. He would be proud of the Christians that also see that vision of love, who learned to take the bible as He intended it. Inclusions instead of exclusion. Love instead of hate.

That should be the only way people should read the Bible. And I am sure God would agree.

That last part is very odd for an atheist to claim sureness of.

Maybe you should crack open a Bible so as to know of what is being discussed. There are passages there that tell readers that God hates. In fact there is a list of the particulars.

You failed to make your point as anything but an atheist in this dialog when you made the presumptuous statement, no matter what scripture literally says....
What scripture literally is believed to be is the words of the God of the Christian and the Jew. Though the Jews do not accept the authority within the new testament unless they are of the Messianic variety.
You're attempting to argue what you prefer to read into the Christians Bible as an atheist. You can't win this debate that way. What the scriptures literally say is at the heart of this discussion that arose from the import of the OP.

 

[AsPatat]

well it goes back to who you date and settle down with. Either way. That's what it boils down to.

Not taking sex seriously impedes our ability to settle successfully with anyone.

 

[SkyWriting]

A lot of people don't think the same about that. How is there no such thing as casual sex for pleasure?

No matter what they think, relationships effect the soul of a person.
People seeking and discarding relationships get damaged just as
babies who do not form strong relationships early, are damaged
for all their lives and unable to cope well in society.

 

[quatona]

Why is homosexuality wrong if it's not long term?

Homosexuality isn´t wrong.

 

[SkyWriting]

I know it does but my question is why?

The problem is the type of relationship in action. If one follows their LUST as a guideline
every type of sex interaction goes bad. This is the point of those passages. Some people
are born with gender identification from both sexes. How would we even judge if two of
the same gender are together? So....homosexuality is not the issue.

How the relationship is actioned is the issue. I'm called to love Jesus. He's a guy, so am I.
God seems OK with that. HOW I treat that relationship is the issue.

 

[Armoured]

I know it does but my question is why?

You're not going to get much more here than "it's wrong because the Bible says so, the Bible says so because it's wrong *repeat as necessary *" and variations on that.