No and no. I can't "disprove" other religions. I can show that some beliefs of other religions are harmful, certainly, and I can give my opinion of them as a non-believer in that religion. I do so regularly. Why not?
Hello Rae, Why Not? Because you doing exactly what many wiccans accuse Christians of doing.
Not every path is Divine. Many paths lead people into hatred, bigotry, intolerance, etc. Would you say such a path is Divine? Neither would I. I would say most fundamentalisms fall under such a category...leading them into arrogance, hatred, and lies against anything different from themselves. They are not Divine. Just one example.
From a Christian belief lies would be consider a sin but since wiccans and sin don't mix, how can that be your call??? By who's authority do you decide who's path is divine or harmful??? I don't understand why some wiccans are so judgmental. Is it only divine if you agree with it???
Paths being divine is a wiccan belief, not my belief as a Christian. Here is how it was explained to me in Jan. of 2003 by Havoc: Do you agree with his definition???
Havoc
123 Christian Veteran
Joined: 23 Dec 2001
Posts: 807
Posted: Sun Jan 12, 2003 9:29 pm Post subject:
Of course I'm not ashamed of my beliefs. I'm not sure you actually asked me to explain more than the answers I have given.
I don't belief your God exists, at least not in the way the majority of Christians view him, so whether I think Christianity is better than my faith or not is moot. It is better for me.
My faith teaches that all paths lead to the Divine so whether you believe as I do or not is not relevant to me. My faith also does not proseletyse, so I won't try to convince you to become a Witch. I am bound to teach those who sincerely want to become Witches, but only if they seek what they already truly desire
.
I won't challenge another persons beliefs since no religion has more substantive proof than any other. I will challenge anyone who claims to have the absolute truth but cannot back that claim up with proof
Indeed. Someone appears to have an agenda to bash Pagans under the guise of wanting to know more about us. Too bad. I wish people would honestly seek, not seek in order to destroy.
Havoc
123 Christian Veteran
Joined: 23 Dec 2001
Posts: 807
Posted: Sun Jan 12, 2003 11:43 pm Post subject:
I believe I did answer his questions, do you require more clarification?
I don't question that you believe in your God, I question the oft used (or misused) claim that the Christian God is "absolute truth". Such a claim cannot reasonably be made without provideing substantive evidence, especially if that claim exludes the possibility of my faith being valid. I have never challenged anyone who says, "this is what I believe". I do challenge anyone who claims to have absolute truth, or who claims other religions are false.
I can assure you that in the 14 years I've been a Witch I certainly have thought about that statement.
I believe every soul will ultimately reach the same destination. Those who make bad choices or choose to do harm will take a longer path and will not reach the end until they have learned. Those who make good choices and choose to heal will get to their destination sooner.
Why wouldn't Satanism lead eventually to the Divine. Satanists don't hurt anyone (at least not more than any other group). They simply believe differently than you. In their case they are in opposition to your beliefs but that's not harmful in and of itself.
Quote:My proof is his word, creation, my life, and I feel his spirit in my soul.That's all well and fine but it is certainly not unique. I would say the same things of my Gods and Goddesses. As would most religions that have a Diety/ies. Your "proof" is meaningles to anyone but yourself, it is certaainly not the basis of a reasonable claim of "truth".
With the second quote please explain to me how wiccans can challenge anyones choices good or bad??? The way I read/understand the above, paths do NOT have to be just about religious choices. Does this mean if someone choice is to kill/murder, rape, steal and so forth that those paths are also divine???
Originally Posted by:
Rae
For many of us, the Bible is the words of fallible humans only. We find "God" elsewhere
Any non-biased reader would see the above as my opinion only. I did not bash Christians (e.g. "you're so stupid to believe the Bible" was not in there...and don't you dare clip this quote to make it look like I said this, either!), try to convert anyone to my point of view, or anything else. Thanks for showing how balanced and fair I am in my comments.
Obvious attempt at slander and libel. Disgusting, SoulSearcher. Disgusting. Shame on you.