- Jan 28, 2003
- 9,969
- 2,521
- Country
- United States
- Gender
- Male
- Faith
- Humanist
- Marital Status
- Married
- Politics
- US-Democrat
I have written a parable to help explain:
There is battle going on and you as an old man leave you post. The crime is punishable by 40 lashes or equivalent, but that will kill you. Your young innocent son offers to take your place and explains to the judge (general) that; 40 lashes on him will cause you tremendous pain and anguish. The judge (general) refuses because that would not be just to punish an innocent for the guilty (Whipping Boy). The innocent son then says: I will go over to the enemys camp for my fathers sake and they will beat me and imprison me until the end of the war. The Judge (general) says he cannot stop the young man from doing such a thing and knows this will really hurt the father when you find out, so the judge will not have to punish you father (justice has been done). You plead for the sons return, but there is really no other way for you to be punished and live.
And the human judge in your story accepts that as justice? What judge would accept an innocent man submitting himself to torture as a valid reason to free a guilty man?
If a mother offers to die so her murdering son can go free, would that be acceptable? I cannot understand how that would be justice.
Why not write the law so that the judge can show mercy? If 40 stripes is too much in one instance, then why not 2 stripes, or 2 months in prison, or 200 hours of community service?
Those benefits include: not wanting to sin again, knowing how bad sin really is, feeling I have been punished and nothing else awaits me, knowing that I am a child (parents see to the discipline of their children), knowing the pain I will go through does not compare to his, and really feeling Loved.
If a man commits a crime, and the wrong man is arrested and put in jail, does the criminal then feel that he has been punished? I would think the opposite would happen, that the criminal would think he got away with a crime, and would think that his crime pays.
Upvote
0