• Starting today August 7th, 2024, in order to post in the Married Couples, Courting Couples, or Singles forums, you will not be allowed to post if you have your Marital status designated as private. Announcements will be made in the respective forums as well but please note that if yours is currently listed as Private, you will need to submit a ticket in the Support Area to have yours changed.

Why a true omniscient cannot coexist with true free will.

Status
Not open for further replies.

Wiccan_Child

Contributor
Mar 21, 2005
19,419
673
Bristol, UK
✟46,731.00
Faith
Atheist
Marital Status
In Relationship
Politics
UK-Liberal-Democrats
You do not understand the concept for one important reason, the Holy Spirit is not with you. How can you understand the way of God when you have turned from Him?
There is a difference between nonbelief and denial. I have nonbelief towards your God's existance.
That said, my scenario deals purely with the notion of an omniscient. As I explicitly stated, do not draw more theology that is evident.

His knowledge does not negate our desire or desicison about our lives. In other words, if i make the choice to sin then that is my free will to do so. God's knowledge of what I am going to do is not going to impact my choice.
I disagree. For foreknowledge to be able to exist, the universe cannot be probabalistic; moreover, it must be entirely deterministic (though not necessarily deducably so).
 
Upvote 0

Wiccan_Child

Contributor
Mar 21, 2005
19,419
673
Bristol, UK
✟46,731.00
Faith
Atheist
Marital Status
In Relationship
Politics
UK-Liberal-Democrats
Upvote 0

GenemZ

Well-Known Member
Mar 1, 2004
22,169
1,377
75
Atlanta
✟109,031.00
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Private
There is a difference between nonbelief and denial. I have nonbelief towards your God's existance.

Not really. You have non belief about what we communicate about God. But, its not us who could win you to Christ.


John 6:44 (New International Version)
"No one can come to me unless the Father who sent me draws him, and I will raise him up at the last day."


Its God himself has who first makes himself known to you. Some have met him like the air you breath. They take it for granted.

Their denial will not allow themselves to admit it. The very creation itself with its precise order and ultra complexity, all working in perfect harmony is his calling card. To think it could have all happened simply by chance?

Well..... everyone's choice. Our free will. The fact that many have enough sense to see what's obvious makes some who want to reject it to seek data used in a way in attempt to obscure and contradict the obvious, so they are left feeling free with their free choice. And, God allows us to make that choice. For he does not coerce volition, even though man might try to.



Romans 1:19-20 (New International Version)
"....Since what may be known about God is plain to them, because God has made it plain to them. For since the creation of the world God's invisible qualities—his eternal power and divine nature—have been clearly seen, being understood from what has been made, so that men are without excuse."




 
Reactions: Nadiine
Upvote 0

Wiccan_Child

Contributor
Mar 21, 2005
19,419
673
Bristol, UK
✟46,731.00
Faith
Atheist
Marital Status
In Relationship
Politics
UK-Liberal-Democrats
Not really. You have non belief about what we communicate about God.

No. I neither believe that your god exists, nor believe that your god doesn't exist. This is nonbelief.


I have no such knowledge. Sorry to disappoint you, but Biblical quotations don't dictate reality.

Their denial will not allow themselves to admit it. The very creation itself with its precise order and ultra complexity, all working in perfect harmony is his calling card. To think it could have all happened simply by chance?

Chance? Only technically (chaos theory + quantum mechanics = wholly probabalistic universe). But in our world of perception? No. Evolution explains the mechanism by which modern biodiversity formed, and the only 'chance' involved is merely one of statistics (specifically, pseudo-random mutation coupled with selective pressures).
That siad, there is no 'precise order', no 'ultra complexity'. My absurdly designed spinal column, for instance, is a testament to this fact.


Says who? God? Circular logic, that be.
 
Upvote 0

GenemZ

Well-Known Member
Mar 1, 2004
22,169
1,377
75
Atlanta
✟109,031.00
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Private

No. I neither believe that your god exists, nor believe that your god doesn't exist. This is nonbelief.


You call yourself Wiccan....

Do you believe in the supernatural?


IC, GeneZ






t
 
Upvote 0

GenemZ

Well-Known Member
Mar 1, 2004
22,169
1,377
75
Atlanta
✟109,031.00
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Private
That all depends on how you define 'supernatural'. For example, I believe in the Tarot, but I scoff at astrology.

You show fine taste...


[Enjoy life] in My Presence, for Mine is the ecstasy of the spirit and ... joy on earth. - The Goddess

Is that reality to you???

Do you believe in goddesses?

What do you believe is the power behind the Tarot?
 
Upvote 0

Wiccan_Child

Contributor
Mar 21, 2005
19,419
673
Bristol, UK
✟46,731.00
Faith
Atheist
Marital Status
In Relationship
Politics
UK-Liberal-Democrats
You show fine taste...
What can I say, I like the finer things in life.

Is that reality to you??
It is a metaphor for a Wiccan way of life, just as 'Love Thy Neighbour' is a metaphor for a Christian way of life. They are two of my favourites.

Do you believe in goddesses?
Yes. Do you? What about gods?

What do you believe is the power behind the Tarot?
No idea. Whatever it is, it occurs during the shuffling of the cards.
 
Upvote 0
B

BlueAfgani

Guest
God's foreknowledge of what you will do doesn't negate your free will

Yes, it absolutely does, because I can't choose different than my pre-scripted choice. I can not choose contrary to what God knows I will choose, thus I only have one choice.

Nothing you say negate this. If God knows what I am going to do, and God can not be wrong, then I have no choice but to do what God knows I will do, otherwise I prove God wrong, and then God isn't all-knowing.

There's some biblical teaching for this principle as to why the spiritual is silly and not understood:

It goes agqainst logic. No Biblical insight needed.

Now THAT is truly pathetic if you think about it. A God that ONLY creates people that would accept Him?

More pathetic than a God who knowingly creates people to burn for all eternity?

You have CONSEQUENCE if you CHOOSE (by your will) to reject Christ. You HAVE the free will to reject or accept. It's a choice.

There is no choice, because the choice is made before I make it, and I can't choose otherwise, hence there is no choice.

God cannot honor their [free will] choice of "eternal bliss"

Then God isn't all powerful. He is limited by the constructs of His creation.

So all people who chose to reject God, and embrace that sin, DON'T HAVE THEIR SIN REMOVED from them, so they MUST be put where it can be contained to live out the sentence of a "death penalty" (2nd death) by Law.

Do you know what "death" means? Because eternal torture is a little different.

If everyone had free will, as some here claim it should be? Every contestant on quiz shows would always win the top prize. For they would always be free to go back and redo the question.

No, you don't understand what free will means. Free will is being able to make a choice, without the choice being known and made before the choice presents itself. That's all. Has nothing to do with winning every game show.

Now?

If that were the case?

Would it allow for free will?

Yes? No?

No, that bypasses God being a jerk and making people who He knows would end up in hell.

It's doesn't bypass the fact that God would still know every choice we will ever make, thus the choice is still made for us, thus no free will.
 
Upvote 0

GenemZ

Well-Known Member
Mar 1, 2004
22,169
1,377
75
Atlanta
✟109,031.00
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Private
Yes. Do you? What about gods?


Like I said.... you are without excuse. Even more so!

Many do not know the supernatural is real. Yet, you? You do.

Yet? You reject Jesus Christ.

If anything? You have less of an excuse. They can at least might claim they did not believe in anything supernatural.....
 
Upvote 0

Wiccan_Child

Contributor
Mar 21, 2005
19,419
673
Bristol, UK
✟46,731.00
Faith
Atheist
Marital Status
In Relationship
Politics
UK-Liberal-Democrats
Like I said.... you are without excuse. Even more so!

You quoted a Bible verse that said "...have been clearly seen, being understood from what has been made, so that men are without excuse"
Since I have not clearly seen, I do not understand what has been made, I am not without excuse.

Many do not know the supernatural is real. Yet, you? You do.

You have yet to define 'supernatural', so I can neither confirm nor deny.

Yet? You reject Jesus Christ.

By your own arguement, I could criticise you for rejecting Zeus, and Odin, and Gautama Buddha.
 
Upvote 0

GenemZ

Well-Known Member
Mar 1, 2004
22,169
1,377
75
Atlanta
✟109,031.00
Country
United States
Gender
Male
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Private
[/size]You quoted a Bible verse that said "...have been clearly seen, being understood from what has been made, so that men are without excuse"
Since I have not clearly seen, I do not understand what has been made, I am not without excuse.

It also says by wickedness the truth is suppressed. It says God did make it known....but it was suppressed. Today we commonly refer to that as being 'denial.'


You have yet to define 'supernatural', so I can neither confirm nor deny.

Ahhhemmm..... You call yourself, Wiccan? And? I need to define what supernatural means? I think its too late to try to define it if you do not know by now.


By your own arguement, I could criticise you for rejecting Zeus, and Odin, and Gautama Buddha.


I believe they are/were real entities who went by those names. I do not deny they existed.


As you were saying?


In Christ, GeneZ




truth
 
Upvote 0

Wiccan_Child

Contributor
Mar 21, 2005
19,419
673
Bristol, UK
✟46,731.00
Faith
Atheist
Marital Status
In Relationship
Politics
UK-Liberal-Democrats
It also says by wickedness the truth is suppressed. It says God did make it known....but it was suppressed. Today we commonly refer to that as being 'denial.'

Like I said, the Bible doesn't dictate reality. Just because the Bible says that all non-Judaeo-Christians are in denial, doesn't mean we are.

Ahhhemmm..... You call yourself, Wiccan? And? I need to define what supernatural means? I think its too late to try to define it if you do not know by now.

Yes, you do. It is an ambiguous term for a nebulous concept. Define it, or retract it.

I believe they are/were real entities who went by those names. I do not deny they existed.

Nevertheless, you reject them as gods/Buddhas. You criticise me for 'believing in the supernatural, yet rejecting Jesus'. By your own argument, I could criticise you for rejecting Zeus, Odin, and Gautama Buddha.

As you were saying?
I stand by my argument. You arbitrarily choose Christianity over other faiths.
 
Upvote 0

EternallyPierced

Jesus, I am so in love with you.
May 25, 2006
3,408
99
41
South Carolina, US
✟26,553.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Republican
Knowing what decison your going to make before you make it isn't imposing on your free will. Knowing isn't controlling.
 
Upvote 0

Nadiine

Well-Known Member
Apr 14, 2006
52,800
48,336
Obama: 53% deserve him ;)
✟292,219.00
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Republican
Knowing what decison your going to make before you make it isn't imposing on your free will. Knowing isn't controlling.
A few of us have said this repeatedly now - it seems to be a chronic misnomer and I don't honestly understand why it seems so hard to grasp.

In fact, it WOULD be imposing on our free will if God only made people who would accept Him as their Lord & Saviour. THAT would be the violation imo; not to allow anyone who would hold an opposing position to Him.
 
Upvote 0

EternallyPierced

Jesus, I am so in love with you.
May 25, 2006
3,408
99
41
South Carolina, US
✟26,553.00
Faith
Christian
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Republican
I wonder the same thing myself.
 
Reactions: Nadiine
Upvote 0

Nadiine

Well-Known Member
Apr 14, 2006
52,800
48,336
Obama: 53% deserve him ;)
✟292,219.00
Faith
Non-Denom
Marital Status
Married
Politics
US-Republican
This might come off as rude or "arrogant"... but I hope not... and that's becuz I consider myself one of them - but, this is basically a layperson's forum.
I'm by no means a Theologian or biblical scholar; and from the looks of it around this place, neither is anybody else!!!!
Sometimes I sit here in the backseat & just watch people's posts - how "wise" so many people think they are in debating and reasoning....
I just see a bunch of little kids sometimes, thinking they're professional scholars trying to make points about things - and so much of it is just plain WRONG and nonsensical - and alot of it lacks thought and depth.

Example:
One thread a few mos. ago we had a girl claiming to be a Christian, yet she rejected the Bible as her basis of truth about God - denying the Bible is even inspired by God. "fallible men" wrote it, so we can just use it for some reference truths...
Yet she uses that same bible to get most all of her "truths" about the GOOD benefits God gives and all the "loving things" within it!
She LIKES the blessings, salvation, eternal life with Him, protection & so on, but she just yanks out whatever she doesn't view is compatible with "love, mercy & goodness" that God is.
So, since God is "love", then all the verses where God speaks of His wrath or justice get thrown in the 'burn pile'. Instead of trying to wrap her head around how love AND pure justice/righteousness/holiness MESH and work together, she just rejects them randomly.

Think about it, Someone thinking they're SO wise that they can cherry pick the bible apart and decide truth from falsity within it - and deny anything at will - yet USING IT (trusting it) FOR SPIRITUAL TRUTHS about God that she finds agreement with! (in her limited mind that won't accept anything she can't fathom)...

She hadn't once stopped to think that if the writers are writing LIES and falsities that she finds repulsive and cruel all thru it, that they aren't trustworthy to give her the TRUTH either! Or that, maybe she's wrong in God being LOVING at all, and it's the WRATHFUL verses that are the correct ones, not the sticky syrupy ones she races to believe in. Talk about contradictory teachings...
Who in the world do people think they are? That to me is the epitomy of sheer arrogance and ignorance. I see this kind of stuff all the time.

Another guy in another thread argues that "hell" means 'grave' (only) - ignoring the fact that in Greek, there is more than one word for hell - "tartaroo"...
then in another thread, there's a guy using John 3:16 to "prove" God saves everyone and everyone ends up in heaven eternally... contrary to the dozens of verses that directly say otherwise.

The blind lead the blind - and Jesus said BOTH WILL FALL INTO THE DITCH.
The more I see in this forum, the more I realize now why God gifted and has appointed the church with teachers and Shepherds to oversee them.
As I see it, the more we reject being taught by educated teachers, the more we'll see self taught & self appointed novices that speak without knowledge - as in Job 39-41.

*K, I'll step off my little soapbox now LOL
But suffice it to say, I don't come to this forum to "LEARN" from people - I listen to what's said, but before I buy into anything, I do my own deep study of it before it's accepted by me.
I'm willing to change my views in some things [non essential doctrines] but someone needs to do alot better job in study than what I see here in most posts.
 
Upvote 0
Status
Not open for further replies.