Where do you fit ?

[Douggg]

Is that other category too much, Douggg? The distinct difference is how the covenants are perceived. In Progressive Covenantalism....all covenants are viewed to have God's grace carried through as one story of redemption from Genesis to Revelation. The other hermeneutic frameworks (i don't believe) perceive things that way. Progressive Covenantalism is closer to the Catholic/Orthodox view of Covenant Theology.

Hi mkgal1, right now I am concerned that it might be over-categorzing. So, unless I get some other posters asking for the same category to be added - I wll leave the list as covenant theology and new covenant theology. Not that I am questioning what you wrote (albeit I am unlearned on the concept).

 

[mkgal1]

Hi mkgal1, right now I am concerned that it might be over-categorzing. So, unless I get some other posters asking for the same category to be added - I wll leave the list as covenant theology and new covenant theology. Not that I am questioning what you wrote (albeit I am unlearned on the concept).

No problem, Douggg.

 

[Douggg]

bump. see the opening post. voluntary participation.

 

[Douggg]

bump, so that anyone who has not participated and may not even be aware of the list - can have the opportunity to post their positions where they fit - so I can add to the opening post.

 

[Douggg]

I think since I see a lot of new posters in the forum, time to bump this thread again.

Please go to the opening post; make a post if you want to participate, and I will add your name to your fundamental position(s). So we all will have an idea of what each of us believe to aid us in our discussion. It is all voluntary.

 

[Deep Truth]

Grand experiment.

Because there are so many posters here, which it is sometimes hard to keep track of each persons fundamental position(s), especially when discussing. I am going to try on a voluntary basis, for each of you to fit yourself under each of these categories. Yourself only and not what you think someone else is.

In you

In your post, please keep it simple by saying....for example.... furturist, pre-trib
That's all I need. Thanks.

r post, please keep it simple by saying....for example.... furturist, pre-trib
That's all I need. Thanks.

Make a post, and I will add your screen-name alphabetically in each category. If there are some categories I left out - let me know.


Amil
Christian Gedge
Dave L
grafted branch
Hank77
Hazelelponi
JM
kdm1984
mkgal1
TribulationSigns

Anytime rapture
Douggg
TribulationSigns

Covenant Theology
claninja
grafted branch
Hazelelponi
mkgal1
nonaeroterraqueous
TribulatonSigns

Dispensationalism
christiansoccerplayer
Michael Collum
nolidad
Rachel20

Futurist
christiansoccerplayer
Douggg
Handmaid for Jesus
JIMINZ
Marilyn C

Historicist
Christian Gedge
Cshuffle777
JM
Saint John
StephenDiscipleofYHWH

Idealism (of Christian Eschatology)

Mid-trib rapture

New Covenant Theology
ChristianGirl_96
Christian Gedge
Hank77

No rapture (traditional)
keras
Llleopard

Non-dispensationalist
Cshuffle777
Douggg
Hazelelponi
mkgal1
nonaeroterraqueous
TribulationSigns

Partial Preterism
claninja
grafted beanch
Josheb
Maria Billingsley
mkgal1

Postmillennialism
JM

Post-trib rapture
Christian Gedge
DavidPT
ewq1938
StephenDiscipleofYHWH
TribulationSigns

Pre-mil
christiansoccerplayer
Cshuffle777
DavidPT
Douggg
ewq1938
Handmaid for Jesus
Marilyn C
Michael Collum
nolidad
Rachel20
Rebecca4Christ
Timtofly

Pre-trib rapture
christiansoccerplayer
Handmaid for Jesus
JustRachel
Marilyn C
nolidad
Rachel20

Pre-wrath rapture
Deep Truth
Rebecca4Christ

Recapitulation Theory
Christian Gedge
Dave L

Sabbatarian
Cshuffle777

In your post, please keep it simple by saying....for example.... furturist, pre-trib
That's all I need. Thanks.

Dougg,
Here is a new category that you might want to add which is how I believe the rapture will happen.
I believe in a pre-trib rapture for the 5 wise virgins and the Church of Philadelphia. And a pre-wrath rapture for the foolish virgins and the Church of Laodicea.

The new category could be called Pre-trib for wise virgins, Pre-wrath for lukewarm and foolish virgins.

The scripture below I believe is when Jesus will return from the wedding feast for his foolish virgins in the second or third watch of the tribulation.

Luke 12:35-38 "Stay dressed for action and keep your lamps burning, (36) and be like men who are waiting for their master to return from the wedding feast, so that they may open the door to him at once when he comes and knocks. (37) Blessed are those servants whom the master finds awake when he comes. Truly, I say to you, he will dress himself for service and have them recline at table, and he will come and serve them. (38) If he comes in the second watch (of tribulation), or in the third, and finds them awake, blessed are those servants!

 

[nolidad]

Grand experiment.

Because there are so many posters here, which it is sometimes hard to keep track of each persons fundamental position(s), especially when discussing. I am going to try on a voluntary basis, for each of you to fit yourself under each of these categories. Yourself only and not what you think someone else is.

In your post, please keep it simple by saying....for example.... furturist, pre-trib
That's all I need. Thanks.

Make a post, and I will add your screen-name alphabetically in each category. If there are some categories I left out - let me know.


Amil
Christian Gedge
Dave L
grafted branch
Hank77
Hazelelponi
JM
kdm1984
mkgal1
TribulationSigns

Anytime rapture
Douggg
TribulationSigns

Covenant Theology
claninja
grafted branch
Hazelelponi
mkgal1
nonaeroterraqueous
TribulatonSigns

Dispensationalism
christiansoccerplayer
Michael Collum
nolidad
Rachel20

Futurist
christiansoccerplayer
Douggg
Handmaid for Jesus
JIMINZ
Marilyn C

Historicist
Christian Gedge
Cshuffle777
JM
Saint John
StephenDiscipleofYHWH

Idealism (of Christian Eschatology)

Mid-trib rapture

New Covenant Theology
ChristianGirl_96
Christian Gedge
Hank77

No rapture (traditional)
keras
Llleopard

Non-dispensationalist
Cshuffle777
Douggg
Hazelelponi
mkgal1
nonaeroterraqueous
TribulationSigns

Partial Preterism
claninja
grafted beanch
Josheb
Maria Billingsley
mkgal1

Postmillennialism
JM

Post-trib rapture
Christian Gedge
DavidPT
ewq1938
StephenDiscipleofYHWH
TribulationSigns

Pre-mil
christiansoccerplayer
Cshuffle777
DavidPT
Douggg
ewq1938
Handmaid for Jesus
Marilyn C
Michael Collum
nolidad
Rachel20
Rebecca4Christ
Timtofly

Pre-trib rapture
christiansoccerplayer
Handmaid for Jesus
JustRachel
Marilyn C
nolidad
Rachel20

Pre-wrath rapture
Deep Truth
Rebecca4Christ

Recapitulation Theory
Christian Gedge
Dave L

Sabbatarian
Cshuffle777

My post for the bump.

 

[Gregory Thompson]

remove me from premil, put me under no rapture.

 

[Douggg]

remove me from premil, put me under no rapture.

Okay Michael, done. Thanks for your participation.

 

[Douggg]

The new category could be called Pre-trib for wise virgins, Pre-wrath for lukewarm and foolish virgins.

Deep Truth, I am going to decline because the list is not intended to be a debate platform.

 

[iamlamad]

Grand experiment.

Because there are so many posters here, which it is sometimes hard to keep track of each persons fundamental position(s), especially when discussing. I am going to try on a voluntary basis, for each of you to fit yourself under each of these categories. Yourself only and not what you think someone else is.

In your post, please keep it simple by saying....for example.... furturist, pre-trib
That's all I need. Thanks.

Make a post, and I will add your screen-name alphabetically in each category. If there are some categories I left out - let me know.


Amil
Christian Gedge
Dave L
grafted branch
Hank77
Hazelelponi
JM
kdm1984
mkgal1
TribulationSigns

Anytime rapture
Douggg
TribulationSigns
iamlamad

Covenant Theology
claninja
grafted branch
Hazelelponi
mkgal1
nonaeroterraqueous
TribulatonSigns

Dispensationalism
christiansoccerplayer
Michael Collum
nolidad
Rachel20
iamlamad

Futurist
christiansoccerplayer
Douggg
Handmaid for Jesus
JIMINZ
Marilyn C
iamlamad

Historicist
Christian Gedge
Cshuffle777
JM
Saint John
StephenDiscipleofYHWH

Idealism (of Christian Eschatology)

Mid-trib rapture

New Covenant Theology
ChristianGirl_96
Christian Gedge
Hank77

No rapture (traditional)
keras
Llleopard
Michael Collum

Non-dispensationalist
Cshuffle777
Douggg
Hazelelponi
mkgal1
nonaeroterraqueous
TribulationSigns

Partial Preterism
claninja
grafted beanch
Josheb
Maria Billingsley
mkgal1

Postmillennialism
JM

Post-trib rapture
Christian Gedge
DavidPT
ewq1938
StephenDiscipleofYHWH
TribulationSigns

Pre-mil
christiansoccerplayer
Cshuffle777
DavidPT
Douggg
ewq1938
Handmaid for Jesus
Marilyn C
nolidad
Rachel20
Rebecca4Christ
Timtofly
iamlamad

Pre-trib rapture
christiansoccerplayer
Handmaid for Jesus
JustRachel
Marilyn C
nolidad
Rachel20
iamlamad
Pre-wrath rapture
Deep Truth
Rebecca4Christ

Recapitulation Theory
Christian Gedge
Dave L

Sabbatarian
Cshuffle777

 

[Douggg]

lamad, did you want to say something? Or are doing a bump to keep the thread toward the top? Appreciated for anyone who wants to do that.

 

[iamlamad]

It was a good idea. It sometimes takes several posts from someone before you locate where they are doctrinally.

 

[Douggg]

It was a good idea. It sometimes takes several posts from someone before you locate where they are doctrinally.

Yes, that was my thoughts as well. Plus, when discussing with a multitude of other posters, it is hard to remember everyone else's fundamental positions.

 

[grafted branch]

Grand experiment.

Because there are so many posters here, which it is sometimes hard to keep track of each persons fundamental position(s), especially when discussing. I am going to try on a voluntary basis, for each of you to fit yourself under each of these categories. Yourself only and not what you think someone else is.

In your post, please keep it simple by saying....for example.... furturist, pre-trib
That's all I need. Thanks.

Make a post, and I will add your screen-name alphabetically in each category. If there are some categories I left out - let me know.


Amil
Christian Gedge
Dave L
grafted branch
Hank77
Hazelelponi
JM
kdm1984
mkgal1
TribulationSigns

Anytime rapture
Douggg
TribulationSigns

Covenant Theology
claninja
grafted branch
Hazelelponi
mkgal1
nonaeroterraqueous
TribulatonSigns

Dispensationalism
christiansoccerplayer
Michael Collum
nolidad
Rachel20

Futurist
christiansoccerplayer
Douggg
Handmaid for Jesus
JIMINZ
Marilyn C

Historicist
Christian Gedge
Cshuffle777
JM
Saint John
StephenDiscipleofYHWH

Idealism (of Christian Eschatology)

Mid-trib rapture

New Covenant Theology
ChristianGirl_96
Christian Gedge
Hank77

No rapture (traditional)
keras
Llleopard
Michael Collum

Non-dispensationalist
Cshuffle777
Douggg
Hazelelponi
mkgal1
nonaeroterraqueous
TribulationSigns

Partial Preterism
claninja
grafted beanch
Josheb
Maria Billingsley
mkgal1

Postmillennialism
JM

Post-trib rapture
Christian Gedge
DavidPT
ewq1938
StephenDiscipleofYHWH
TribulationSigns

Pre-mil
christiansoccerplayer
Cshuffle777
DavidPT
Douggg
ewq1938
Handmaid for Jesus
Marilyn C
nolidad
Rachel20
Rebecca4Christ
Timtofly

Pre-trib rapture
christiansoccerplayer
Handmaid for Jesus
JustRachel
Marilyn C
nolidad
Rachel20

Pre-wrath rapture
Deep Truth
Rebecca4Christ

Recapitulation Theory
Christian Gedge
Dave L

Sabbatarian
Cshuffle777

Douggg, can you take me out of the Amil category. I still believe we are in the millennium but I’ve come to realize that I have too many other issues with the Amil view.

Thanks.

 

[Douggg]

Douggg, can you take me out of the Amil category. I still believe we are in the millennium but I’ve come to realize that I have too many other issues with the Amil view.

Thanks.

okay, done.

 

[iamlamad]

Grand experiment.

Because there are so many posters here, which it is sometimes hard to keep track of each persons fundamental position(s), especially when discussing. I am going to try on a voluntary basis, for each of you to fit yourself under each of these categories. Yourself only and not what you think someone else is.

In your post, please keep it simple by saying....for example.... furturist, pre-trib
That's all I need. Thanks.

Make a post, and I will add your screen-name alphabetically in each category. If there are some categories I left out - let me know.


Amil
Christian Gedge
Dave L
Hank77
Hazelelponi
JM
kdm1984
mkgal1
TribulationSigns

Anytime rapture
Douggg
TribulationSigns

Covenant Theology
claninja
grafted branch
Hazelelponi
mkgal1
nonaeroterraqueous
TribulatonSigns

Dispensationalism
christiansoccerplayer
Michael Collum
nolidad
Rachel20

Futurist
christiansoccerplayer
Douggg
Handmaid for Jesus
JIMINZ
Marilyn C

Historicist
Christian Gedge
Cshuffle777
JM
Saint John
StephenDiscipleofYHWH

Idealism (of Christian Eschatology)

Mid-trib rapture

New Covenant Theology
ChristianGirl_96
Christian Gedge
Hank77

No rapture (traditional)
keras
Llleopard
Michael Collum

Non-dispensationalist
Cshuffle777
Douggg
Hazelelponi
mkgal1
nonaeroterraqueous
TribulationSigns

Partial Preterism
claninja
grafted beanch
Josheb
Maria Billingsley
mkgal1

Postmillennialism
JM

Post-trib rapture
Christian Gedge
DavidPT
ewq1938
StephenDiscipleofYHWH
TribulationSigns

Pre-mil
christiansoccerplayer
Cshuffle777
DavidPT
Douggg
ewq1938
Handmaid for Jesus
Marilyn C
nolidad
Rachel20
Rebecca4Christ
Timtofly

Pre-trib rapture
christiansoccerplayer
Handmaid for Jesus
JustRachel
Marilyn C
nolidad
Rachel20

Pre-wrath rapture
Deep Truth
Rebecca4Christ

Recapitulation Theory
Christian Gedge
Dave L

Sabbatarian
Cshuffle777

Sorry, missed this. You should already know I am premill and pretrib.

 

[Douggg]

Sorry, missed this. You should already know I am premill and pretrib.

Would you like me to add your name to premill and pretrib on the list ?

 

[Spiritual Jew]

Grand experiment.

Because there are so many posters here, which it is sometimes hard to keep track of each persons fundamental position(s), especially when discussing. I am going to try on a voluntary basis, for each of you to fit yourself under each of these categories. Yourself only and not what you think someone else is.

In your post, please keep it simple by saying....for example.... furturist, pre-trib
That's all I need. Thanks.

Make a post, and I will add your screen-name alphabetically in each category. If there are some categories I left out - let me know.


Amil
Christian Gedge
Dave L
Hank77
Hazelelponi
JM
kdm1984
mkgal1
TribulationSigns

Anytime rapture
Douggg
TribulationSigns

Covenant Theology
claninja
grafted branch
Hazelelponi
mkgal1
nonaeroterraqueous
TribulatonSigns

Dispensationalism
christiansoccerplayer
Michael Collum
nolidad
Rachel20

Futurist
christiansoccerplayer
Douggg
Handmaid for Jesus
JIMINZ
Marilyn C

Historicist
Christian Gedge
Cshuffle777
JM
Saint John
StephenDiscipleofYHWH

Idealism (of Christian Eschatology)

Mid-trib rapture

New Covenant Theology
ChristianGirl_96
Christian Gedge
Hank77

No rapture (traditional)
keras
Llleopard
Michael Collum

Non-dispensationalist
Cshuffle777
Douggg
Hazelelponi
mkgal1
nonaeroterraqueous
TribulationSigns

Partial Preterism
claninja
grafted beanch
Josheb
Maria Billingsley
mkgal1

Postmillennialism
JM

Post-trib rapture
Christian Gedge
DavidPT
ewq1938
StephenDiscipleofYHWH
TribulationSigns

Pre-mil
christiansoccerplayer
Cshuffle777
DavidPT
Douggg
ewq1938
Handmaid for Jesus
Marilyn C
nolidad
Rachel20
Rebecca4Christ
Timtofly

Pre-trib rapture
christiansoccerplayer
Handmaid for Jesus
JustRachel
Marilyn C
nolidad
Rachel20

Pre-wrath rapture
Deep Truth
Rebecca4Christ

Recapitulation Theory
Christian Gedge
Dave L

Sabbatarian
Cshuffle777

You can add me to the Amil, Idealist, Non-dispensationalist and Recapitulation Theory groups.

Can you please define Covenant Theology and New Covenant Theology? I may belong to one or both of those, but it depends on how they are defined. If it has anything to do with "this age" being the old covenant age and "the age to come" being the new covenant age, then count me out.

I'm also post-trib rapture in a way, but I don't know how you are defining that, either. My understanding of a tribulation period before Christ's return differs from a 3.5 or 7 year time period before His return. Instead, I see the tribulation before His return as being Satan's little season (undefined short period of time) when a falling away from the faith occurs and an increase in false teaching, wickedness and persecution and such. So, if that qualifies me for the post-trib rapture group you can add me to that, too.

 

[Douggg]

You can add me to the Amil, Idealist, Non-dispensationalist and Recapitulation Theory groups.

Okay, done.

Can you please define Covenant Theology and New Covenant Theology? I may belong to one or both of those, but it depends on how they are defined. If it has anything to do with "this age" being the old covenant age and "the age to come" being the new covenant age, then count me out.

I don't define any of the categories. It is up to you whether you want your name added to a particular category - as you see fit.