You're in a place that needs a lot of evangelism, a real tough nut to crack. Maybe you aren't there to read the Bible again in a year, and go to retreats?
Is there something you see as a need there? Not something you need but something you see others needing?
I've tried a variety of activities, such as talking to random people (VERY uncomfortable, strange, and without any result), handing out tracts (felt very fake to me, no results), and praying for the community.
There is little financial/material need here, and most people have no interest in any sort of religion. I can't help but feel phony when I try to "force" an evangelistic moment into a conversation where it clearly doesn't fit.
The pastor at my current church said something interesting... he said that he knows a lot of people who ask him things like, "What should I do as a Christian, in this circumstance?" or "When I go to the city, I want to behave in a Christian manner... what should I do?"
He responds, "Are you a man (woman)? If so, do you ask yourself how you can behave like a man when you go to the city? Do you think about how to present yourself like a man so that other people will know that you're a man?"
He has an interesting point. If we are a Christian, we shouldn't have to think about how to look like one, or how to act like one, or what a "Christian would do" in a certain situation; we should just do it because it's naturally part of who we are.
I've eagerly waited many times for a decent opportunity to share the gospel, but I've found that any attempt I've ever made has always been forced, and resulted in a damaged relationship (or failure with a stranger).
Of course we often say "don't worry, you are planting seeds." It's our way to reassure ourselves that we didn't really fail, despite the fact that nothing at all happened.
Christianese. Ways we try to assure ourselves of what we know isn't true.