The elliptical looks deceptively easy! "Oh, you just climb on and run smoooothly in place, right?" Pfffft. What nobody tells you is that, unlike a treadmill, YOU power the thing, and you have to lift your entire body weight with each pedaling motion, and if you're not a thin wisp of a girl, it's ridiculously hard! A great workout, sure, but I can walk for miles without a problem, I can even jog for short distances, but after just... well... I won't say how long... on the elliptical, I'm panting and dying for oxygen! And my legs are all quivery and jellied with the effort lol.
So, given the choice between a treadmill and elliptical (and they might be more comparable for a skinny chick)... I'd choose a treadmill just because I can actually survive a few miles on there lol. I did read that you don't get the same workout benefits on a treadmill though, because you aren't propelling your body forward as if you were walking down the street, the treadmill does it for you, so you don't work your calves and butt as much. So I dunno. Maybe I'd stick with the Murderous Elliptical just because it works me harder, even though I feel like a dork for barely surviving a minute or two on it.
Ethnog, I'm not on FB much, but thank you for the offer