What errors and inventions arose in Roman Catholicism?

[LittleLambofJesus]

Originally Posted by MoreCoffee

Deep down everybody who opines with confidence and asserts their view "is just quoting scripture" wants to be the pope
​

What a novel statement

dont need a pope.. We have the high priest. Jesus is His name.
We have the Father and we have the HS, so we are good without a pope.

I myself have been doing ok w/o one for awhile, at least so far.........







.

 

[ImaginaryDay]

Deep down everybody who opines with confidence and asserts their view "is just quoting scripture" wants to be the pope

dont need a pope.. We have the high priest. Jesus is His name. We have the Father and we have the HS so we are good without a pope.

I myself have been doing ok w/o one for awhile, at least so far.........

Christians say the darndest things...

 

[Tzaousios]

False.

How is it false? In the end, it amounts to you assuming a kind of moral relativism to rhetorically reconfigure "murder" so that it means "warfare," which permits you to justify extreme action against those with whom you have theological quibbles. No amount of crypticism is going to cover that up.

 

[tadoflamb]

But do Protestans call her the "Queen of Heaven" "Co redemreix" and do they pray to her for intercession?Didnt think so

No, protestants don't even call the Blessed Mother 'blessed' as the Sacred Scriptures say all generations will do.

Strange for a group of people who claim to hold the bible in such high esteem.

 

[tadoflamb]

I decided to start a new thread on this and I am hoping we can discuss this in a civil way so as not to get it closed down.
Also, a lot of new members have joined CF since then and it will also give them a chance to share their views. God bless

http://www.christianforums.com/t6870602/#post54128393

This is a list I comprised from the first 40 posts on this thread. I will work on another 40 posts when time allows...........

I put up the "post link" for each one mentioned here. The duplicates that I could see I put in "RED"......Thanks

http://www.christianforums.com/t6870.../#post43628489

Scholasticism
Filioque
Papal Supremacy
Immaculate Conception

http://www.christianforums.com/t6870.../#post43630346

Inventions:
-Infallability of the Pope
-Papal supremacy
-Immaculate coneption
-purgatory
Errors:
-Vatican I and II(not the councells but their decisions....although II was worse than I)
-indulgencies
-crusades
-Vatican City.... (never should have been a "seperate state"but goes hand in hand with the Papal supreority)

http://www.christianforums.com/t6870.../#post43629206

Hmmmmm, let me think on that one..................................................................................................

http://www.christianforums.com/t6870.../#post43630926
um, I got one, well kind of, not an error by the Pope but some errors made by a Catholic King and Catholic Monk.
Luthernism and Anglicanism

http://www.christianforums.com/t6870.../#post43632320
None

http://www.christianforums.com/t6870.../#post43636094

I'm going to have to go with Mr. O'Briens answer.

http://www.christianforums.com/t6870.../#post43636190
Change in Paschalion.

http://www.christianforums.com/t6870.../#post43636780
Lack of fasting. [of which post # 36 clarifies what is meant]

http://www.christianforums.com/t6870.../#post43636255

*snip*

Crusades.

http://www.christianforums.com/t6870.../#post43646993

*snip*
......so you see LLoJ...the RCC or any "business" that is involved in day to day ops certainly can't allow ALL MEN to believe in Him...the only ones who are allowed to believe are those who ADHERE to their particular organizations DOCTRINE...because THAT is the FORCE they use to keep their CUSTOMERS...and if you don't buy into ANY "churches" system...they will DAMN YOU TO BURN ALIVE...

http://www.christianforums.com/t6870.../#post43652400

assumption of mary

submission to the pope of Rome being absolutely neccessary for salvation

penance to atone for sins committed after baptism

auricular confession

sacerdotal sacramentalism

meritorious works for the attainment of salvation

the whole Roman system of justification

http://www.christianforums.com/t6870.../#post43668261
Lateran IV

Unam Sanctum

Trent

Vatican I

Vatican II

the papacy

the Marian dogmas

the dogma of papal infallibility

auricular confession and penance

sacerdotal sacramentalism

purgatory

indugences

transubstantiation

and admit that the Roman religion was built upon the deceptions and frauds of forgeries invented during the dark ages



.

You call that a list?

C'mon that ain't no list.

 

[Rick Otto]

Lol!

 

[Pteriax]

How is it false? In the end, it amounts to you assuming a kind of moral relativism to rhetorically reconfigure "murder" so that it means "warfare," which permits you to justify extreme action against those with whom you have theological quibbles. No amount of crypticism is going to cover that up.

No. False because the person I was responding to did not read all of my posts and so didn't really know what I was talking about. And I would not justify that kind of action today, since it's not mandatory to be Catholic anymore.

 

[yogosans14]

No, protestants don't even call the Blessed Mother 'blessed' as the Sacred Scriptures say all generations will do.

Strange for a group of people who claim to hold the bible in such high esteem.

This has to be the weakest argument I have ever heard. Oh im sorry i didnt realize praying a rosary and bowing to statue of her is consiered calling her blessed. Protestants do CALL HER BLESSED. They dont stress on importance on her as much as Jesus. Sorry truth hurts.

 

[intojoy]

They began by excluding the Jews. This is how so many counterfeits began like sprinkling vs immersion. Forbidding to marry and abstaining from meats.

 

[intojoy]

Because of the desire to replace the nation of Israel as the people of God Rc promoted the allegorical hermeneutic. Terrible - led to the dark age

 

[intojoy]

It would've been better to be a Muslim than a Rc because they took baths.

 

[intojoy]

Ok I'm done

 

[Tzaousios]

Because of the desire to replace the nation of Israel as the people of God Rc promoted the allegorical hermeneutic. Terrible - led to the dark age

Please explain what you mean by "dark age." I hope it does not mean that it was dark because there wasn't any Protestantism.

It would've been better to be a Muslim than a Rc because they took baths.

That sounds like playground humor.

 

[intojoy]

Please explain what you mean by "dark age." I hope it does not mean that it was dark because there wasn't any Protestantism.

That sounds like playground humor.

No need

 

[Tzaousios]

No need

Uh huh. It must be nice to think you don't have to defend the statements you make.

 

[MoreCoffee]

Because of the desire to replace the nation of Israel as the people of God Rc promoted the allegorical hermeneutic. Terrible - led to the dark age

Please explain what you mean by "dark age." I hope it does not mean that it was dark because there wasn't any Protestantism.

It would've been better to be a Muslim than a Rc because they took baths.

That sounds like playground humor.

Pretty fair assessment.

"Dark ages" is a very outmoded and highly prejudicial name for the period between the fall of the city of Rome until the reintroduction of Greek and other learning in the Catholic cultures of southern Europe. "Middle ages" is the more common and more useful term.

 

[intojoy]

Uh huh. It must be nice to think you don't have to defend the statements you make.

Yea just having fun. At least I don't think the old burnin alive stuff was a good thing. Or the rack brother tazomo? How about the ..... Iron maiden? Or it was against the law to take a bath in the 6th century by decree of the pope lol - name of the rose - favorite movie.

 

[Albion]

Pretty fair assessment.

"Dark ages" is a very outmoded and highly prejudicial name for the period between the fall of the city of Rome until the reintroduction of Greek and other learning in the Catholic cultures of southern Europe. "Middle ages" is the more common and more useful term.

Not true. Even the PC types who don't like the term "Dark Ages" know that the Dark Ages and the Middle Ages don't refer to the same time period.

 

[intojoy]

Not true. Even the PC types who don't like the term "Dark Ages" know that the Dark Ages and the Middle Ages don't refer to the same time period.

Oh, the dark ages. That refers to the entire period of time when Catholicism ruled the world circa 400 - 1700s? Dark = Catholic Reign (in my theology)

 

[PaladinValer]

Isn't the Catholic religion considered a different religion? Like Islam took bits and pieces from the Bible and created their distortion, the Catholics took bits and pieces too and comprised their own religion.

The church in the Bible started @33 A.D. Apostacy was foretold and started happening thereafter.

No, it isn't, and to suggest it is would be a violation of point 3 under Flaming and Harassment hereat CF.