For the second time, none of us are denying this fact. Whatever you're reading into our position is a complete misunderstanding. Our argument is that there is no descriptive standard for modesty found in Scripture, and that which is present in our society is simply a construct. This is evidently clear when you consider the examples Archivist brought up (which you shrug off as irrelevant).
Yes I did go thru this on another level --
Since several here have spoken up and made points which essentially say: "men lust after women who are clothed, so they'de have to wear Burka's in order not to have men lust after them".
So I ask you, is "MODESTY" taking off MORE clothing - as in being 1/2 naked? or is modesty having more clothes on so as not to lead his eye to sexual features or more of the skin so he can see even more of the female body unclothed?
Yes modesty IS defined in the bible - you are redefining it with liberalism today - that's the problem here. It's relativism/subjectivism rehashed.
"your meaning of modesty isn't my modesty". But God says what's in the heart is what gets displayed outwardly.
Maybe you can list all the fine and upstanding Christian women of history and currently today who are topless sunbathers & go around topless.... or promote partial female nudity in their teachings.
The fact that it is NOT prevalent in Christianity whatsoever should be a good indicator as to the nature of this topic.
We KNOW when men are attracted to us and how to attract them - with what (even if just for them to take 2nd looks); I spent most of my youth and early adult life doing just that and it works. We KNOW.
And Christians know what God requires in what we should & shouldn't be revealing. That is a big part of this issue. Not only what the bible says that standard is, but knowing the Spirit's leading in our daily lives in how we dress.
I'm not talking about types of clothing (skirt, pants, blouse, tight sweater, etc.), I'm referring to exposure and how much of our body is exposed. Huge amounts of cleavage is inviting men to directly look your chest - not on your face - the focus is THE BODY.
women do this on purpose, it's advertising. That is what God is against - leading men to LOOK at those body parts.
How can you say we can't know what modesty is as a godly standard? It's obvious. God isn't so rigid that he puts us in uniforms, but he gives us the source of the issue - asking ourselves, WHAT WE ARE TRYING TO DO with our clothing.
That means everything -
and causing others to stumble is a sin